Updated August 31, 2023
This is an archive of events related to United Methodist division from June-August 2023. Explore this document with your browser’s search feature. Fallout archives are available for: March-May 2023, Nov 2022-Feb 2023, Aug-Oct 2022, May-July 2022, Jan-April 2022, 2021, 2020, 2019, or earlier.
Post by Lauren Porter via Mississippi WCA Facebook. A list of churches believed to be disaffiliating in Mississippi. (Added 8-31-2023)
“Next Steps 3 of 3: Manage Expectations” by Mark Holland via Mainstream UMC (PDF). “Failure to change the language at General Conference 2024 may begin an exodus from the left. We likely have the votes (a simple majority) to change the language now. We are likely NOT to have the votes at the next General Conference if regionalization fails.” (Added 8-31-2023)
Tweet by Drew McIntyre: “The vitriol which some UMC folk have for the GMC makes me wonder how they feel about AME, Nazarene, Wesleyan, CME, and other Wesleyan expressions. I don’t think you serve Christian unity by hurling insults at a train as it leaves the station.” (Added 8-31-2023)
“The Question of Bishops in the Global Methodist Church // Interview with Bishop Scott Jones” by Matt O’Reilly via Theology Project. “What will the role of bishops be in the Global Methodist Church? In this video, Dr. Matt O’Reilly sits down with Bishop Scott Jones to discuss that question from every angle.” (Added 8-31-2023)
Post by Shane Frederick via Facebook. “Running tally for [Illinois Great Rivers Conference] churches who have voted to disaffiliate awaiting a December release… (Added 8-31-2023)
Post by Dave Westlake via Facebook. “With the potential of quite a few churches closing in the next few years (both UMC and GMC), have the annual conferences’ Board of Trustees started making plans for the added expense of the caretaking responsibility of the closed buildings?…” (Added 8-31-2023)
“Living Faith Community Church in Naperville, IL” via Northern Illinois WCA. “After Wheatland Salem UMC in Naperville determined that, despite a vote to disaffiliate, the congregation could not afford the costs involved, many of the congregational leaders determined that God was calling them to be done with the UMC’s denominational conflict and, instead, start something new.” (Added 8-31-2023)
Overheard: Bethesda UMC in Lexington, NC voted to disaffiliate on August 30. The vote was 145-15 in favor (91%). (Added 8-31-2023)
Post by Warren Latham via Facebook. “All of the 185 churches in the joint lawsuit in North GA have completed their votes at Church Conferences. 182 achieved a super majority to disaffiliate. The three that did not missed the required percentage by as few as 3 votes, all 3 just barely missed it. All 3 were heavily targeted by Stay UMC folks and AC officials. Now we have churches voting who did not participate in the lawsuit. Seven have already voted to disaffiliate…August 31 deadline.” (Added 8-31-2023)
Post by James Howell via WNCC-UMC Facebook Group. “I have to say I don’t mind the disaffiliation as much as when the disaffiliators say “We trust in Scripture.” My ugly side says they and many of their people aren’t great students of Scripture… AND: they do that “Some United Methodist somewhere said or did such and such – so therefore all United Methodists are like that” – a massive logical fallacy, that to me feels defensive and petty. (Added 8-31-2023)
Overheard: Sherman United Methodist Church, Illinois Great Rivers Conference, voted disaffiliation 84-28 (75%), and for joining the GMC 77-6 (92.8%). (Added 8-31-2023)
“Navigating the Waiting Space” by Jessica Brodie via UM Insight. “Many are waiting to see what happens at General Conference. Things are not over, and it’s going to be a long time before the waiting is done and things seem reasonably clear.” (Added 8-31-2023)
“Jury selection and attendee registration update available for upcoming trial” via Press Release. “The agenda will begin September 19th at 9am CST with jury selection at the Wespath Benefits and Investments headquarters…. The clergy jury pool represents all ten Conferences in the North Central Jurisdiction with 63% being persons of color and 61% being female. The clergy considered for the jury pool came from 45 nominees presented by all of the jurisdiction’s bishops.” (Added 8-30-2023)
“Leaders, scholars confront racism in the church” by Jim Patterson via UMNS. “The lack of action by the denomination to change the Cross and Flame United Methodist logo is also mystifying, Elford said. It is “a classic example of how we really don’t listen to our Black Methodist siblings and how they feel about things.” (Added 8-30-2023)
“Divided in Devotion: The Controversial Split of Dexter’s Methodist Congregation” by Traci Husse via The Sun Times News (MI). “The decision of Dexter United Methodist Church (DUMC) to disaffiliate from the United Methodist Church (UMC) over LGBTQIA+ inclusion has sent shockwaves through the congregation, eliciting heartfelt responses, challenging deeply-held beliefs, and prompting former members to share their stories and experiences in a bid for understanding and change.” (Added 8-30-2023)
“How The Methodist Church Yanked the Rug Out from Under Us” by BeBe Nicholson via Medium. [paywall] “A process that began in good faith has been marred by changing rules, threats, and punitive actions.” (Added 8-30-2023)
“The WCA Gets New Leadership” by Elizabeth Chryst via WCA. Scott Field named as new WCA President. (Added 8-30-2023)
“David Watson” by Carolyn Moore via Art of Holiness Podcast. “In this episode, we chat about an article David has written for Good News Magazine on holiness and what it means to be a Wesleyan Christian. We also talk to him about honor and humility in the life of Christ and in Christian culture.” (Added 8-30-2023)
“Coming Home the UMC” by Jenna DeWitt via Yet Alive! A self-described “sapphic aromantic asexual Methodist” describes how the UMC became her home for now. (Added 8-30-2023)
“LGBTQ+ Inclusion in Korean Methodism: Interview with Rev. Lee Dong-Hwan” via Yet Alive! “After blessing at the 2019 Incheon Queer Culture Festival, the Korean Methodist Church sentenced you to a two-year suspension. Now, you have filed a petition in secular court to make the decision of the church invalid. What convinced you to be the symbol for this new movement in the Korean Methodist Church?” (Added 8-30-2023)
Post by Aliyu Samaila via Facebook. Documents from a breakaway group in Nigeria prone to holding their own conference sessions without Bishop Yohanna present, claims loyalty to the UMC. (Added 8-30-2023)
“A Movement or an Institution?” by Jack Harnish. “The great irony is that in the same article where Jay Therrell called for a movement and not an institution, he went on to outline the Jurisdictional structure they are building in hopes of influencing General Conference in 2024.” (Added 8-30-2023)
“So Why Have the Sacraments Then?” by Dan Held. UM Clergy: “Different Scriptures, different Sacraments, different Creeds. Different interpretations of all. Such differentness is not dangerous. Rather, perhaps it is what best defines the comings and goings of God’s divinity and our own humanity in marriage between each other.” (Added 8-30-2023)
“Maryland church that left UMC must raise $4 million to keep property” by Michael Gryboski via Christian Post. “As part of the disaffiliation process, Oakdale Church has to pay the UMC mission shares for the current year plus one year in advance, any unfunded pension liability, and 50% of the assessed value of the property.” (Added 8-30-2023)
“Statement on the Appeal – August 28, 2023” via Oklahoma Conference (UMC). “We believe the lower court’s decision on Aug. 21 took away the rights of the Church of the Servant members who have twice voted to remain a part of the United Methodist Church, representing an unconstitutional intrusion into religious self-governance in violation of the First Amendment.” (Added 8-29-2023)
Press release by North Alabama Global Methodist Church. A press release on the recent annual conference session during which sixty-eight pastors were ordained. (Added 8-29-2023)
Post by Brooke Franklin James via Facebook: “My heart is absolutely breaking, more and more each day, as the future of my home church becomes uncertain…my hope is, by getting this out of my head and ‘journaling’, it will help ease the heartache, and years from now, I can look back and see how God was working all along, leading us all thru this storm…” (Added 8-29-2023)
Post by Jimmy Boone via Facebook. Lists upcoming special sessions of annual conferences: Holston (9/7/23), North Alabama (9/12/23), and Desert Southwest (9/16/23). (Added 8-29-2023)
“Owasso congregation votes to disaffiliate from United Methodist Church” by Art Haddaway via Owasso Reporter (OK). “Congregants of the Owasso church on Sunday, Aug. 27, voted 233-37 to separate from the denomination based on doctrinal and theological disagreements regarding human sexuality.” (Added 8-29-2023)
“Oklahoma Supreme Court blocks congregation’s vote to leave UMC” by Michael Gryboski via Christian Post. “The Oklahoma Supreme Court issued an emergency stay on Monday, deciding that the Church of the Servant of Oklahoma City can’t hold another vote until after the litigation with the UMC Oklahoma Conference is resolved.” (Added 8-29-2023)
“High Point church established before city’s founding votes to leave the United Methodist Church over LBGTQ+ policies” by Steve Doyle via WGHP. “One of the largest, oldest and most revered United Methodist churches in the western half of North Carolina will be leaving the denomination it has called home for the better part of two centuries.” (Added 8-29-2023)
“Short docket brings more church-exit questions” by Heather Hahn via UMNS. “Even with the denomination’s church-exit policy winding down, The United Methodist Church’s top court faces questions about disaffiliation procedures.” Fall Docket. (Added 8-29-2023)
“Diversity, or Not So Much” by Riley Case via Juicy Ecumenism. “Welcome to the world of diversity, where what looks good is often more valued than what works, and where diversity is defined more in terms of gender, race, and age rather than diversity of experience, distribution of spiritual gifts and different theological perspectives.” (Added 8-29-2023)
Tweet Thread by John Lomperis: “Double standards: #UnitedMethodist bishops threaten 2 expel against retired #UMC pastors who even temporarily preach in a #GlobalMethodist congregation. But liberal minister has been employed by Unitarian congregation since 2021, remains in good standing in New York Conference…” (Added 8-29-2023)
“LGBTQ issue raised by overseas-based Methodist Church at the Annual Conference | 29/8/23” via Fiji Village (YouTube). Communications Secretary Rev. Wilfred Regunamada: Methodists in Fiji discuss distancing themselves from British and UMC Methodism due to changing beliefs about marriage and human sexuality. (Added 8-29-2023)
“Bishop’s Decision of Law” via North Carolina Conference (UMC). Official responses by Bishop Shelton to Paul Stallsworth’s questions of church law related to the closure of Fifth Avenue UMC. See also Stallsworth 2023 Brief and Bishop Shelton’s 2023 Ruling on Stallsworth Questions. (Added 8-29-2023)
“Bishop Lanette Brings Hope to UM’s in Fargo and Watertown” via the Dakotas Conference. “”Bishop Plambeck willingly answered questions from the assembled group on a variety of topics, including her family, her background, and church disaffiliations. There were several questions on disaffiliations,” said Kay Braun, a member of Faith UMC in Fargo. “The group was attentive as the Bishop answered their questions. She was a calm presence.” (Added 8-29-2023)
“Wesley Memorial votes to leave UMC” by Jimmy Tomlin via The High Point Enterprise (paywall). “The congregation of Wesley Memorial United Methodist Church, one of the largest, most influential Methodist churches in North Carolina, voted Sunday to disaffiliate from the United Methodist Church denomination, a decision that disappointed and even angered some members of the congregation.” (Added 8-29-2023)
“Church of the Servant’s plan for Sept. 5 disaffiliation vote is quashed with court’s stay” by Carla Hinton via The Oklahoman (PDF Here). “The state supreme court’s stay means that Church of the Servant can not act on Oklahoma County District Court Judge Aletia Timmons’ recent ruling that the church be given an opportunity to have another vote to consider ending its affiliation with United Methodist Church.” (Added 8-29-2023)
“Exit signs: What we learned from testimony in two Oklahoma United Methodist civil cases” by Carla Hinton via The Oklahoman. (PDF Here). Gleanings from the testimonies heard at the OKC First and Church of the Servant Court Cases. (Added 8-29-2023)
“New church forms amidst Methodist rift” by Bob Bakken via DeSoto County News (MS). “According to founding pastor Stephen Sparks, First Global Methodist Church was launched officially on Aug. 20, but worshippers have been gathering for two months prior.” (Added 8-28-2023)
“Religion News Service offers the poignant story of Amarillo’s few good United Methodists” by Terry Mattingly via Get Religion. Critique: Religion News Service failed to cover both sides of the story. (Added 8-28-2023)
“Can They Do That?” by Chris Ritter via Team Caffeine. The pastor and administrative committees are suspended at LaGrange First and the finances are frozen by the North Georgia Conference following a disaffiliaition vote that fell just short of super-majority. (Added 8-28-2023)
Overheard: Central Church in Asheboro, NC voted 96% to disaffiliate on 8/27/2023. (Added 8-28-2023)
Overheard: On August 27, First UMC in China Grove, NC votes 94% to disaffiliate. 237 Yes, 15 no. (Added 8-28-2023)
Overheard: The disaffiliation vote at Central UMC in Meridian, MS was held at 5 pm on 8-27-2023 and resulted in 57.7% voting to disaffiliate. “It has been a contentious process and much harm has already been done.” (Added 8-28-2023)
Overheard: Wesley Memorial UMC in High Point (Western North Carolina Conference) voted 8-27-2023 to disaffiliate. 71.85% with 856 voting in hard-fought disaffiliation process. See also here. (Added 8-28-2023)
“9 to 5 Redistricting Webinar with Bishop Harvey” by Texas Conference UMC. A webinar about downsizing in the aftermath of disaffiliation. (Added 9-28-2023)
“The GMC In Spain – An Interview With Rev. Guillem Correa” by Jeffrey Rickman via Plainspoken Podcast (YouTube). An example of a group joining the GMC that was never part of the UMC. See also Facts on Methodism in Spain, Spain GMC Brief Report, and October Event. (Added 8-28-2023)
Overheard: Church on the Hill in Sugar Hill, North Georgia voted 216 to 8 to disaffiliate. (Added 8-27-2023)
Overheard: Mt. Hope UMC in Lansing, MI voted 172 votes to 16 to disaffiliate. (Added 8-27-2023)
Overheard: Mt. Pleasant UMC in Sherrills Ford, Western North Carolina voted today to 181-44 to disaffiliate. First UMC in China Grove, NC votes 94% to disaffiliate. (Added 8-27-2023)
Overheard: Due West UMC (Marietta, North Georgia) voted to disaffiliate by margin of 81% with over 500 voting. (Added 8-27-2023)
Overheard: The disaffiliation vote at McEachern Memorial UMC in Powder Springs, GA was 332 yes, 143 no, representing 69% of the 465 total votes. West Cobb County, North Georgia Conference. (Added 8-27-2023)
Post by Anonymous Participant via Friends of the GMC Facebook Group. A post and many comments about John Beyer’s suspension and the takeover of LaGrange First UMC in North Georgia. (Added 8-27-2023)
Letter by Susan Landry, SW District Superintendent over LaGrange First (GA). Rev. Dr. John Beyers is suspended and the administrative committees at LaGrange First have also been suspended. Church finances are frozen. See also. a tense worship announcement from SPRC Chair. For context on the recent and close disaffiliation vote, see here. A service of lament is planned at LaGrange First. (Added 8-27-2023)
TikToks by Rev Kelly , Central UMC, pastorinmouseears, badpastor, and Rev. J Tullos. (Added 8-27-2023)
“David Scott: Looking at autonomy and connection together” via UM & Global. “While it does not involve Paragraph 572, the current conversation around regionalism is about autonomy and connectionalism within The United Methodist Church. It will undoubtedly take a good deal of conferencing, consulting and time for The United Methodist Church to propose, test and refine theological and practical answers.” (Added 8-26-2023)
“Church Of The Servant Wins Dispute Against Oklahoma Annual Conference” Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast (YouTube). “This episode covers the broader story of churches and groups of churches seeking intervention from the state, we consult some scripture, and then I read through the transcript from the court in which Judge Timmons’ decision is pronounced and explained.” (Added 8-26-2023)
“Dividing the house of God: Ordained Iowa Methodist recounts why the church made them leave” by Zachary Oren Smith via Iowa Public Radio. “The Reverend Anna Blaedel didn’t look the part of a small-town pastor: Hair buzzed and fresh out of progressive Berkeley seminary, many were surprised when Blaedel accepted an appointment at a Methodist church in Osage.” (Added 8-26-2023)
“Asbury University sees largest incoming class in decades after weeks-long revival” via WKYT. “She says that before the outpouring, enrollment numbers were already up, but many students have shared that seeing what was happening at Asbury solidified their decision.” (Added 8-26-2023)
“Weekly Live Stream for August 25, 2023” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast. “A weekly show covering developments within the Wesleyan movement, focused in particular on the developments around disaffiliation from The United Methodist Church.” (Added 8-25-2023)
“Contrasting Views of Scripture” by Thomas Lambrecht via Good News. “The progressive tendency to downplay the reliability and authority of the Bible and elevate human wisdom and experience (“follow the science!”) has proven to be a blind alley throughout human history. The contrasting perceptions of Scripture are the real issue at stake in our Methodist separation.” (Added 8-25-2023)
Tweet by Reconciling Ministries Network: “Have you heard? RMN and partners have been working on a VBS curriculum coming your way in time for Summer 2024! Pre-sale begins this fall. Here’s a glimpse into our first pilot day in Olympia, WA.” [Photos] (Added 8-25-2023)
“IKEA Church of the GMC?” by Scott Field via Northern Illinois WCA. “…it might feel as if your “new church home” is like opening one of those boxes from IKEA: a lot of pieces, no written instructions, and some cartoon-like pages that are supposed to be adequate for putting the whole thing together.” (Added 8-25-2023)
“Chilmark Congregation Seeks To Leave the Methodist Church” by Emily Gajda via Vineyard Gazette (Martha’s Vineyard). “Earlier this year, the Chilmark church unsuccessfully asked to disaffiliate from the United Methodists. Soon after, the Island church filed a lawsuit in state Land Court on August 10 against the New England Annual Conference of the United Methodist Church, staking the Chilmark church’s claim to its church, parsonage and land. ” (Added 8-25-2023)
Post via North Carolina GMC Facebook Page. An update on Fifth Avenue UMC, the property of which was seized by the NC conference. (Added 8-24-2023)
“Lawsuit Resolution Update from the WNCC Board of Trustees” via Western North Carolina UM Conference. “The 36 plaintiff churches and The Western North Carolina Conference of The United Methodist Church have reached a resolution which resolves all litigation pending between them by mutual agreement. The churches will disaffiliate under Paragraph 2553 of the Book of Discipline and the Conference will work with them through the disaffiliation process so the churches have the opportunity to leave the United Methodist Church in 2023.” (Added 8-24-2023)
“A Kenya Primer for American Methodists” by Chris Ritter via People Need Jesus. Context on Kenyan Methodism as we await further clarity on the report that most of the churches there are leaving to join the GMC. (Added 8-24-2023)
Post by NC Gary via Facebook: “The 36 plaintiff churches and The Western North Carolina Conference of The United Methodist Church have reached a resolution which resolves all litigation pending between them by mutual agreement. The churches will disaffiliate under Paragraph 2553 of the Book of Discipline and the Conference will work with them through the disaffiliation process so the churches have the opportunity to leave the United Methodist Church in 2023.” (Added 8-24-2023)
“United Methodist Disobedience Takes Hold in South Central Jurisdiction” by John Lomperis via Juicy Ecumenism. A roundup of BOD violations in the South Central Jurisdiction of the UMC. (Added 8-24-2023)
Tweet by Mark Tooley: “There are 7 million United Methodists in Africa compared to fewer than 6 million in USA. Schism will be global.” (Added 8-24-2023)
Post by Francis Mallo: “Today 74 out of 91 Churches across Kenya, disaffiliated from The United Methodist Church and joined the Global Methodist Church due to United Methodist endorsement of Homosexuality practices within the church which is contrary to the bible.” (Added 8-24-2023)
“Bishop Wandabula Illegally Grants Freedom In Africa?” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast. “Leadership from a majority of the churches in Kenya-Ethiopia Annual Conference became clear that their latest conference session would mark a cessation from the UMC. Bishop Wandabula vowed that he would not entertain such a measure taking place. When the time came, the bishop bent, and he has allowed 58 churches go leave, directly contravening the edict from Tom Bickerton.” (Added 8-24-2023)
“Editorial: More Hopeful Than Ever” by Rob Renfroe via Good News. “Am I hopeful for the UM Church? I want to be. But I can’t be until I hear its leaders deal with the real reasons it has declined for the past fifty-five years, acknowledge that something went very wrong when 20 percent of its churches and five of its bishops felt compelled to leave the denomination, and admit that maybe, just maybe, they are part of the problem.” (Added 8-24-2023)
Post by Joe Rhea via Facebook. Praise the the West Ohio Conference disaffiliation process in the Friends of the GMC Facebook Group. (Added 8-24-2023)
“Maxie Dunnam: Revival on the Horizon” an interview with Steve Beard. “I’m excited about the Global Methodist Church because I believe it is a great expression of revival. I think the structures are too great and the interest groups are too firmly established in the United Methodist Church. It could be a fresh start for everybody. It will give us an opportunity to really be serious about how we, as a body, are going to preach and teach and experience the Holy Spirit. I believe we’re going to have a demonstrable revival.” (Added 8-24-2023)
“New Life for Fractured Churches” by Walter Fenton via Good News. “The high bar of 67 percent of a congregation’s membership must vote in favor of disaffiliation. What happens when local churches come up just short?” (Added 8-24-2023)
“The Challenge Before Us All” by JJ Mannschreck via Good News. “I was born and raised in The United Methodist Church, and I will always have a love for the people who introduced me to Jesus Christ. But there is an element inside the denomination that has been working overtime to smear the image of the emerging (GM) church.” (8-24-2023)
“Bishop Farr Calls 2023 Special Session of Annual Conference” via Missouri UMC Conference. “Churches that want to be considered for approval by the Annual Conference session should be in contact with their district superintendent and will have completed their town hall and charge conference by September 15, unless otherwise approved by Rev. Nate Berneking, director of finance and administrative ministries.” (Added 8-24-2023)
“United Methodist Church disaffiliation in US largely white, Southern & male-led: Report” by Liam Adams via USA Today Network. Liam Adams coverage in the Tennessean has gone national, shares conclusions by Lewis Center. (Added 8-24-2023)
“Taking Stock of Methodism’s Shift” by Thomas Lambrecht via Good News. “The average for the whole denomination is 21 percent. Both the Southeast and South Central experienced 28 percent of their churches disaffiliating. The North Central had 18 percent of its churches disaffiliate, the Northeast 11 percent, and the West 5 percent (see the chart on next page).” (Added 8-24-2023)
“Statement on Church of the Servant lawsuit — Aug. 21, 2023” via The Oklahoma Conference of the UMC. As shared by United Methodist News Service in their August 23 Daily Digest. (Added 8-23-2023)
Overheard: First United Methodist Church of Zephyrhills, Florida is having a Church Conference on September 17, 2023 to vote upon disaffiliation from the UMC and re-affiliation to the Global Methodist Church. The following was posted for church members: A Letter from Church Leaders, FAQs, and two Presentations from the summer of 2021 (before the final postponement of General Conference and the launch of the GMC). (Added 8-23-2023)
“Transcript of Church of the Servant’s Motion for Injunction” via PDF. Transcript of the District Court of Oklahoma County, OK ruling mandating another church conference for Church of the Servant (OKC). (Added 8-23-2023)
Tweet by Stephen Fife: “Hearing a report from a community where one Methodist Church split into two separate bodies. Both seem to be flourishing at the present. Both churches seem to have shown a renewed interest in evangelism, discipleship, giving, and growing. Mitosis can be a good thing!” (Added 8-23-2023)
“The Rise of the GM Church in the U.S. Northeast: A Conversation with Rev. Steven Taylor” by Walter Fenton via GMC. “In just 15 months the Global Methodist Church has welcomed 3,150 local congregations, launched 13 provisional annual conferences, and established two provisional districts. In the U.S., it is likely to launch four more provisional annual conferences and another provisional district by the Spring of 2024 as the total number of local churches climbs to 4,000.” (Added 8-23-2023)
“Clearer picture emerging of UMC’s future” by Cynthia Astle via Baptist News Global. Four trends discussed: Disaffiliations, decreased clergy health, inclusion, and regionalization. (Added 8-23-2023)
“Disaffiliation Votes Hold Special Risks for Rural Churches, United Methodist Pastors Say” by Sarah Melotte via Daily Yonder. “When a church splits in a tight-knit rural community, the pain can ripple throughout the entire town.” (Added 8-23-2023)
“Kenya-Ethiopia Conference Cancelled” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken. Reporting that an African conference was cancelled due to a majority desiring to leave the UMC. (Added 8-22-2023)
“Regionalization plan heads to General Conference” by Heather Hahn via UMNS. “The creation of the regional conferences around the globe requires amending the denomination’s constitution — a high bar. For ratification, amendments must receive at least a two-thirds vote at General Conference and at least two-thirds of the total votes from annual conferences, regional bodies consisting of voters from multiple congregations. The regional conferences planned under regionalization would each consist of multiple annual conferences.” (Added 8-22-2023)
“Regionalization legislation petitions submitted to General Conference” via Resource UMC. “During an August 19th meeting, The Standing Committee on Central Conference Matters unanimously approved a worldwide regionalism legislation for submission to General Conference. This legislation had also been supported for submission by the Connectional Table at its July 13th meeting.” (Added 8-22-2023)
“Queer Theology” by Mark Bauerlein via First Things Podcast. John Murawski joins the podcast to discuss his recent article “Queering Jesus: How It’s Going Mainstream at Progressive Churches and Top Divinity Schools.” (Added 8-22-2023)
“Korean American faith leaders discuss church future” by Thomas Kim via UMNS. “The Rev. Sang Won Doh of the Greater New Jersey Conference said that five of the 10 largest churches in his conference are Korean churches, and three of them have left the denomination.” (Added 8-22-2023)
“Announcement from Trey 8/16/23” via St. Paul Ocean Springs (MS) YouTube. Pastor Trey Skaggs encourages his growing congregation to vote for disaffiliation. (Added 8-22-2023)
E-mail via Oklahoma UMC Conference (PDF). “This is the second time Judge Timmons has ordered the annual conference to proceed with actions that conflict with the UMC Book of Discipline and documented church polity. The first ruling, which came on July 17 in the case of First UMC of Oklahoma City vs. the annual conference, has been stayed on appeal and is set for appellate hearing before the Oklahoma Supreme Court on August 29.” (Added 8-22-2023)
“Biblical Authority Calmly Considered” by Thomas McCall via Firebrand Magazine. “…we of the Methodist family would not be well-served by another internecine “Battle for the Bible.” I don’t think that we will be helped by attacks on the catholic account. But I do think that we should be patient and charitable where there are different understandings and even misunderstandings. We need to stand united in our confessional orthodoxy and commitment to gospel proclamation.” (Added 8-22-2023)
Post by Jeffrey Rickman via Plainspoken (Facebook): “The Kenya-Ethiopia Annual Conference is meeting right now and, against the will of Bishop Wandabula, the assembly is forcing a vote to leave the UMC… This after freezing their funds for over a decade because of Wandabula’s mismanagement, who lives in the US, by the way. Meanwhile, the Oklahoma Annual Conference got embarrassed in court again, this time in a suit brought by Church of the Servant in Oklahoma City…” (Added 8-22-2023)
“Judge says Church of the Servant’s exit attempt was in ‘chokehold,’ orders second vote” by Carla Hinton via The Oklahoman [PDF]. “In her ruling, Timmons said Church of the Servant’s efforts to consider disaffiliation were “tainted” by a conference leader whose bias against church exits amounted to him placing a “chokehold” on the process. She also said it didn’t seem to be a coincidence that a conference deadline imposed on churches hoping to disaffiliate in October would effectively prevent Church of the Servant from disaffiliating.” (Added 8-22-2023)
Tweet via Mark Tooley: “Very rare for United Methodist or other Mainline officials to address persecuted Christians, so kudos to Florida bishop.” [link] (Added 8-22-2023)
Tweet by Mark Tooley: Quotes: “I do not think we should build a new evangelicalism; I think we should build a new mainline. That mainline should be centered around the EPC, PCA, and ACNA with room for the possible addition of Lutheran, Methodist, or Baptist denominations, should denominations interested in this project emerge from those streams.” (Added 8-22-2023)
“Thoughts Upon Christian Orthodoxy (Or, Epistemology Can’t Save You)” by David Watson via Firebrand Magazine. “I think it’s a mistake to tie orthodoxy too specifically to a single epistemological proposal. In what follows I will talk a bit about the nature of orthodoxy, its development, and its relationship to various ways of securing religious knowledge.” (Added 8-22-2023)
“Mental health awareness; Dill pickle recipe; Methodist infighting; Aggies preview” by Ya’ll Show Podcast. Starting at about 34:00, a discussion of the Liam Adams article headlining that disaffiliation is mainly white, southern, a male-led. (Added 8-22-2023)
“Bishop Shelton Calls Virtual Special Session of the Annual Conference” via North Carolina UM Conference. On a newly announced 10/7 special session: “The Board of Trustees Report will include a list of the approximately 20 churches asking to disaffiliate and will be posted online at nccumc.org/scac2023 by the end of September.” (Added 8-22-2023)
“It’s a good, good season” by Daniel Bradley via Upper New York UM Conference. “Whatever side of the great divide you fall on—know this: God loves you with all that God has and God will continue to pour out God’s grace like the rain this summer and the warmth of the sun. It’s a good, good, season.” (Added 8-22-2023)
“Best of All God is With Us: Special Session Recap” by Doreen Gosmire via Dakotas Conference. “In the Dakotas, 58 churches have chosen disaffiliation representing a 25% decrease in the number of churches reported in 2021, and a decrease of 8,600 members or 25% reported in 2021. All data is self-reported annually be each congregation. View a list of the disaffiliated churches in the Dakotas Conference” (Added 8-22-2023)
“Carrollton First votes for disaffiliation from UMC” by Dan Minish via Times Georgian. “The final tally was 554 yes and 234 no for 70.3%, just over the required 66.67% for passage.” (Added 8-22-2023)
“Regional Chapter Changes Coming” by Jay Therrell via WCA. Leadership for four regional chapters announced, along with an effort to renew an amended Par. 2553. (Added 8-22-2023)
“Resource for UM Churches during their discernment process August 2023” by UMC North Georgia Conference (PDF). A 17 page document North Georgia district superintendents are giving to churches and asking pastors to email out before local church votes.
Post by Jay Allred via Facebook. Shares photos and another post reporting 230 in attendance at the launch of Wesley Methodist Church (GMC) in LaGrange, GA a week after a narrowly-failed disaffiliation vote at First UMC. Rev. Dane Wagner, a former associate pastor at LaGrange First UMC, is interim minister. (Added 8-21-2023)
“All In Campaign” via Oakdale Church. A Maryland congregation seeks to raise $4 million to disaffiliate from the UMC. (Added 8-21-2023)
Overheard: Clarkesville First UMC (North GA) voted 73.8% to disaffiliate. 286 ballots cast. Vote split was 211 to 75. (Added 8-21-2023)
“Estonian Methodist Church quits UMC over LGBT rights” by Mait Ots via ERR. “The reason we have decided to leave the United Methodist Church is that we have felt for a time that the UMC is going down a path that clashes with the church’s teaching as we understand it and indeed its own rules. We see that it is no longer possible for us to be part of the global United Methodist Church,” Robert Tšerenkov, superintendent for the Estonian Methodist Church, told ERR Monday. (Added 8-21-2023)
Overheard: Broken Arrow First UMC (OK) voted 95.1% to disaffiliate on 8/20/23. (Added 8-21-2023)
“Letter from the Future Generations” via Stay LaGrange UMC. “If this Church chooses to disaffiliate, it’s getting left behind. By choosing disaffiliation, you are choosing to send a message to one in five young people (not to mention all of the allies who support them) that they will not be valued, celebrated, or treated as equals in this place of worship.” (Added 8-21-2023)
“Special Session of Annual Conference” via Missouri Conference UMC. “Bishop Farr is calling a special session of the Missouri Annual Conference of The United Methodist Church to be held via GoToWebinar, an online meeting platform, on Saturday, November 18, 2023, beginning at 10 a.m.” (Added 8-21-2023)
Overheard: Carrollton First UMC (GA) voted to disaffiliate on August 20, 2023. 788 voted. 554 yes, 234 no. (70.3%). See church conference information here. See Pastor Robert Brown’s sermon the morning of the vote appealing for UMC unity here. (Added 8-20-2023)
“Tension over LGBTQ issues splits the Methodist Church locally, nationally” by Brad Hundt via Observer-Reporter (Washington, PA). Casts the current split in light of the 1840’s separation. (Added 8-19-2023)
“After losing churches over homosexuality stance, United Methodists pick up a new church in NKY” by Jack Brammer via North Kentucky Tribune. A feature on a new church plant comprised of disaffiliation refugees. (Added 8-19-2023)
“Another One: Surf City Targeted By UMC” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast (YouTube). “Valuable real estate with humble attendance are targeted by increasingly impoverished annual conference leadership within The United Methodist Church. As they speak platitudes about renewal and growth, they simultaneously disenfranchise local church communities to absorb them and profit off the assets they accrued over more than a century of ministry.” (Added 8-19-2023)
“Weekly Live Stream – August 18, 2023” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast (YouTube). “On today’s episode, we will cover the shifting sands of the UMC and the GMC. As the GMC is rising in structure, the UMC is notifying African UMs that they have to back away from financial support and commitment. We’ll cover developments in American culture and hopes that some have for a Christian resurgence.” (Added 8-18-2023)
“Fla. Conference of United Methodist Church Approves 46 More Disaffiliations” by Daniel Ritche via Roys Report. “There will likely continue to be a significant number of disaffiliations between now and the end of the year due to stipulations of disaffiliation rules laid out in 2019, which specify that congregations wishing to leave over “reasons of conscience” must do so before Dec. 31, 2023.” (Added 8-18-2023)
“Church in U.S. sees shift toward LGBTQ inclusion” by Heather Hahn via UMNS. “Altogether, 22 U.S. annual conferences passed resolutions supporting the removal of anti-LGBTQ language in the Discipline. That total does not include conferences that passed similar resolutions last year, but it does include conferences in the U.S. where the restrictions have received little pushback before.” (Added 8-18-2023)
“Centrist Misconceptions” by Thomas Lambrecht via Good News. “Some centrists appear to have the misconception that people who voluntarily unite under a banner of common theological commitments are somehow being “forced” into some type of artificial unity. Nothing could be further from the truth.” (Added 8-18-2023)
“An OKC church wants a second chance to vote on leaving United Methodist Church” by Carla Hinton via The Oklahoman [See also PDF]. “Church of the Servant, 14343 N MacArthur Blvd., is taking the Oklahoma United Methodist Conference to court on Friday hoping that a judge will order conference leaders to allow the church to hold a timely congregational disaffiliation vote, which is a key aspect of the exit process.” (Added 8-18-2023)
“The United Methodist Church split in the Dakotas could be about more than LGBTQ+ rights” by Oksana Kotkina via Sioux Falls Argus Leader. “Despite that, even though, as Spahr noted, a lot of the UMC members in the Dakotas do not understand the reasons behind the split as the region traditionally enjoyed more moderate to conservative pastors, the split touched even the Dakotas.” (Added 8-18-2023)
“Course of Study Welcomes Hundreds” by Ken Roach via Wesley Biblical Seminary. “When fall semester classes start on Aug. 13, 2023, at Wesley Biblical Seminary, they will include over 250 students who have been accepted in the Global Methodist Church Course of Study. The cohort includes students from 28 states.” (Added 8-18-2023)
“Wesley in His Own Words” by Robert Mayo via PDF. A retired elder in the Michigan Conference of the UMC provides excerpts from John Wesley on the authority of Scripture. (Added 8-17-2023)
“‘Making Room for Anybody’: Cullman church remains United Methodist while others depart” by Sean Dowling via WAFF (Alabama). ”I was thinking that the attendance numbers were dramatically reduced after the vote to disaffiliate. They’re smaller, but they’re not in any way as dramatic as I thought,” Hickman said. (Added 8-17-2023)
“Churches on either side of Methodist schism share much in common — but geographical and racial divides are stark” by Andrew Schwartz via Chattanooga Times Free Press. [paywall] (Added 8-17-2023)
“Season of Discernment” via Due West UMC. A church discernment page for a congregation in Marietta, GA anticipating an August 27 disaffiliation vote. (Added 8-17-2023)
“Methodist church split looms after LGBTQ vote” via The Dahlonega Nugget. [paywall]. The aftermath of the overwhelming August 6 disaffiliation vote in Dahlonega, GA. (Added 8-17-2023)
“Trust issues: Does Oklahoman United Methodist property dispute have historical basis?” by Carla Hinton via The Oklahoman. “This provision we call the trust clause is nothing new … so when a church says ‘I don’t want my property to be used for the United Methodist Church,’ that’s where the problem comes in,” Robinson said. PDF (Added 8-17-2023)
“United Methodist Church disaffiliation movement in US largely white, Southern & male-led: New report shows” by Liam Adams via The Tennessean. Sharing the Lovett Weems report, with response from Jay Therrell. (Added 8-17-2023)
Post by Jimmy Boone via Facebook. “Updated August 17, 2023: We are now at 6,244 a little under 21% of the 30,000 original total of U.M. Churches in the US.” (Added 8-16-2023)
“Science, Scripture, and Sexuality: The US United Methodist Church at Crossroads” by Lee Johnson and Barbara Luckert via Journal of Religion and Health. This article was shared via e-mail by Mainstream UMC, along with this video link. (Added 8-16-2023)
“Online Course: Life Together in the United Methodist Connection” via UMC.org. “What will happen at General Conference 2024? What is happening in the United Methodist connection now, and with the new Global Methodist Church? This session of the official U.M.C. polity course will include structural realities and principles affecting our annual conferences and local churches right now and in the future.” (Added 8-15-2023)
“Clarifying Conversations on the Future of Methodism” via Sun Creek UMC, Allen Texas. A local church information page. (Added 8-15-2023)
“Creating Lemonade From Lemons” via Drew Theological School News. “Todd and I knew there were a lot of United Methodists that wanted to stay United Methodist and be part of an open, affirming, and inclusive church in United Methodism,” said Jenn, who noted that that was not the norm in the Central Texas Annual Conference, which lost nearly half of their churches to disaffiliation. (Added 8-16-2023)
“Estonian Methodists leave global group after LGBT conflict” via CNE News. “During a church meeting, 97 per cent of the attending representatives indicated their support for leaving the United Methodist Church (UMC). The reason for their leave is the progressive course the UMC seems to be taking, Dagen writes.” (Added 8-15-2023)
“United Methodist Clergy Mental Health in Crisis” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast (YouTube). “This is a harsh critique of our culture as a whole, not just The United Methodist Church, and a warning about what the American church as a whole will experience if it does not quickly remember scriptural language around the purity of the church and the call to righteousness.” (Added 8-15-2023)
Overheard: With a full house present for voting, the members of Griffin First UMC in North Georgia opted to disaffiliate from the UMC (68%). (Added 8-15-2023)
“Mountainside Church leaves UMC conference” by Lewis Delavan via Hot Springs Village Voice. “We are no longer a part of the United Methodist Conference of Arkansas as we exercised the ‘Disaffiliation Clause’ in the 2019 UMC Book of Discipline,” the pastor says. “But we’re still the friendly, welcoming church that we have always been.” (Added 8-15-2023)
“Local Methodists feel the pain, confusion of a ‘forced divorce’ over LGBTQ+ issues” by Meredith Willse via York Dispatch (PA). “For Kristine Cousler, her congregation’s departure from the United Methodist Church felt like a “forced divorce.” (Added 8-15-2023)
“United Methodist Pastors Less Healthy, More Depressed Than a Decade Ago” by Bob Smietana via Christianity Today (RNS Story). “United Methodist clergy have been through the wringer in recent years, with a worldwide pandemic, a church schism, and the ongoing decline of one of the nation’s largest Protestant denominations.” (Added 8-15-2023)
Tweet via Global Methodist Church. “To date, over 16,000 copies of our catechism book have been sold! We can’t wait to hear how God meets with each of you as you use this resource in your church community.” (Added 8-15-2023)
“America! The Glory of the World for Religion” by Riley Case via Juicy Ecumenism. “America has sins and shortcomings but all this needs to be put in the context of the bigger picture… Is there a future for either the United Methodist Church or the Global Methodist Churches, or for Christianity itself?” (Added 8-15-2023)
“Disaffiliation vote fails at First United Methodist Church of LaGrange” by Tommy Murphy via The LaGrange Daily News (GA). “First Methodist’s vote to disaffiliate narrowly failed with 64.3% voting to leave the United Methodist Church. Although a majority of voters chose to disaffiliate, the decision needed to be approved by two-thirds of professing members present at the church conference for the vote. A total of 535 votes were cast on the decision.” (Added 8-15-2023)
“Transgender Community Living in Fear, Two Trans Pastors Testify” by Jeffrey Brumley via UM Insight. “The church is the single most oppressive force against LGBTQ people, and especially trans folks in the entire country.” (Added 8-15-2023)
“Methodist Federation for Social Action Funding Liberalism in Kenya” by Simon Mafunda via WCA. “It is my sincere hope that the African bishops, or at least the East African episcopal leaders will stand up and condemn this “brazen interference in the affairs of The United Methodist Church…” in Kenya- Ethiopia. If African bishops continue to treat such issues with favor and bias, the rift between them and the delegates will continue to grow making it a sure receipt for another ugly fight at GC2024, something we must avoid at all costs.” (Added 8-15-2023)
“Still united: Three Isle of Wight Methodist churches will stay with UMC amid denominational schism” by Stephen Faleski via The Smithfield Times (VA). “At least three Isle of Wight County congregations will remain affiliated with the United Methodist Church amid a growing national movement to split from the denomination.” (Added 8-15-2023)
Post via South Georgia Conference (GMC) Facebook. The South Georgia conference decides to set conference connectional funding at 0% and rely on generosity from churches. (Added 8-15-2023)
“The Revelations of Ashley” via UM Insight. “All religious scriptures are the words of humans about God, not God’s words to humans. They were written by humans no holier than you or I… People who claim to have been chosen by God to give final and definitive messages to humanity should not be trusted, especially with children.” (Added 8-14-2023)
Post by Jennifer Day Emery via Facebook. “His ways are not my ways. That was proven today, but I will nonetheless stay the course and continue to contend for the faith. Whether that will be at LaGrange First remains to be seen. I love my church family as I have said many times and will continue to love them as this is not about who we love or accept in the church, but I have lost faith in the UMC proper. In my two years of research and discernment, I have too many examples of how the UMC is not standing on or representing the biblical truths.” (Added 8-14-2023)
Overheard: The 8/13/23 contested disaffiliation vote at LaGrange First UMC in the North Georgia Conference fell just short of the required 66.6% threshold. “There were 344 votes in favor of disaffiliation which represented 64.3% of those members present.” (Added 8-14-2023)
Post by Chris Harris via Facebook. Shows an “Our God Reigns, We Will Remain” banner placed over OKC First UMC in midst of their legal battle with the OKUMC conference. (Added 8-14-2023)
“More churches are leaving The Florida United Methodist Conference over LGBTQ issues” by Susan Giles Wantuck via WUSF, University of South Florida. “But Shanks said he’s certain churches have many reasons for breaking away that they’ve prayed about and considered.” (Added 8-14-2023)
“Thousands of Methodist congregations, including in Western Pa., are breaking away amid LGBTQ rights. But it’s not an easy process” by Samuel Long via Post-Gazette. “University of Pittsburgh religious studies professor Paula Kane said the schism follows a larger cultural questioning of traditional patterns for marriage and church leadership.” (Added 8-14-2023)
“After split, more changes coming to Methodist community” by Jami Martin-Trainor via The Gazette (Iowa). “Jonathan Heifner, the recently-appointed lead pastor at St. Paul’s, said several new members have joined the church since the disaffiliation, and a number of people have come to visit the space when exploring where they want to worship.” (Added 8-13-2023)
Tweet by Mark Tooley: “Hypothesis: Post-schism traditional Methodist leaders have about 5 yrs to catechize their churches in Wesleyan belief & practice otherwise they’ll be largely lost to generic evangelicalism.” (Added 8-13-2023)
Post via Ulysis Ambucay via Facebook. “Chief Justice Reynato Puno (ret.), a prominent Filipino Methodist, said that one of the considerable MAJOR OPTIONS for Philippine Methodism is to join the Global Methodist Church (GMC) as we are true to our doctrine and principle against same-sex marriage!” (Added 8-13-2023)
“First United Methodist Church of LaGrange to vote on disaffiliation” by Tommy Murphy via The LeGrange Daily News. Local coverage of a contested 8/13/23 church conference vote in North Georgia: “The LGFUMC Church Council unanimously voted on Dec. 13, 2022, to request a Church Conference to vote on the issue of disaffiliation. Two weeks later, on Dec. 28, the North Georgia Conference paused all discussions and actions related to disaffiliation.” (Added 8-12-2023)
“Reclaiming & Safeguarding True Wesleyan Doctrine In The GMC – Interview With Rev. Dr. David Watson” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken. “In this conversation, we cover several topics, including the essential nature of Methodism that the world needs, optimism about the future, the balance needed with respect to church growth vs. church righteousness, charismatic Christianity, scriptural literalism vs. scriptural relativism, and many other pertinent and practical concerns when doing church, both on a local level, and on a denominational level.” (Added 8-12-2023)
“United Methodist Pastors Feel Worse and Worry More Than A Decade Ago” by Bob Smietana via The Roys Report. “United Methodist clergy have been through the wringer in recent years, with a worldwide pandemic, a church schism and the ongoing decline of one of the nation’s largest Protestant denominations.” (Added 8-12-2023)
“Defining the Church” by Tom Lambrecht via Good News. “Does disaffiliation mean a congregation is leaving ‘the church?'” (Added 8-11-2023)
“Weekly Live Stream – August 11, 2023” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast (YouTube). Talking of this week’s news in the UMC/GMC. (Added 8-11-2023)
“Black United Methodists strive for a better future” Commentary by H. Ward Greer via UMNS. “The Black church potentially faces three options: 1. To stay put, and hope that the denomination finally deals head-on with its institutional racism, white power and white supremacy; 2. Disaffiliate — though the denomination has essentially removed this option; or 3. Create its own future within the denomination…” (Added 8-11-2023)
“The GMC In Kenya – An Interview with Boniface Mukii” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast (YouTube). “Pastor Boniface Mukii is navigating the waters of building Methodism in Kenya. It turns out there are some pressures moving him and many others to the Global Methodist Church before the UMC’s General Conference next year.” (Added 8-11-2023)
“Thousands of Methodist Churches Flee Denomination Over LGBTQ Rift, Splinter Issues: What’s Going On?” via The Inside Story Podcast (Christian Post). Interview with Michael Gryboski: “What’s unfolding and why does it matter?” (Added 8-11-2023)
“Realignment Team to chart the future of The Florida Conference” by Joe Henderson via Florida Conference UMC. “As The United Methodist Church approaches the post-disaffiliation world, its leaders must make a clear-eyed assessment of where we are and, more importantly, where we want to go as a denomination.” (Added 8-11-2023)
“2023 Mississippi Annual Conference: June 27-30, Tupelo, Mississippi” via UMNS. “The worship service served as a reflective and healing time for members of the Mississippi Conference, as many were saddened by disaffiliation and the departure of brothers and sisters in Christ. Lewis preached a healing sermon during the service that reminded the Mississippi Conference that we must stand together and that we needed each other to survive.” (Added 8-10-2023)
“Moreland UMC prioritizes inclusivity” by Kandice Bell via Newnan TImes-Herald. While many North Georgia churches are looking for the exit, Pastor Sean Kilpatrick of Moreland UMC says his church never questioned whether to stay. (Added 8-10-2023)
“Study shows shift in disaffiliations” by Sam Hodges via UMNS. “Disaffiliation numbers have grown rapidly in 2023, and the new [Lewis Center] study finds the pool of departing churches is less dominated by the Southeastern and South Central jurisdictions.” (Added 8-10-2023)
Post by Lonnie Brooks via Facebook. Shares a 2004 DCA article from when separation was first openly discussed at General Conference, along with two new GC petitions allowing congregational disaffiliations and conference disaffiliations. (Added 8-10-2023)
Keeping the Heart Website . Disaffiliation information prepared for the people of St. Matthew UMC in Mississippi. (Added 8-10-2023)
“Next Steps 2 of 3: Clarity” by Stephen Cady via Mainstream UMC. “If you are looking for a denomination where everyone will be forced into lockstep about Scripture, about what discipleship looks like, about whose love is worthy of God’s blessing and whose is not, then disaffiliation from the UMC might be the right path.” (Added 8-10-2023)
“FUMC members gather for first service following judge’s ruling” by KAIT (YouTube). The Stay UMC group rededicates the building as they take over at Jonesboro First. (Added 8-10-2023)
“Weekly Live Video About United Methodist Issues and Christianity in General” by Matt Morgan (YouTube). The pastor of Community Brookside in Tulsa, OK talks about the attempted disaffiliation of First UMC, OKC. (Added 8-10-2023)
Report via CBN News (YouTube). Starting at 12:00 there is a report on churches leaving the UMC. Keith Boyette among the interviewees. (Added 8-10-2023)
Stay LaGrange UMC Facebook Page. Organized opposition to an August 13 disaffiliation vote in the North Georgia Conference. See also the church Moving Forward in Faith web page. (Added 8-10-2023)
Tweet by Jeremy Smith (Seattle): “More of the same: Disaffiliating #UMC churches are overwhelmingly white, more often led by male pastors who are not Elders, and reflect the antigay cultures they reside in. This winnowing of Methodism is working out alright on the UMC end and will help us be renewed faster! Bye!” (Added 8-9-2023)
“Updated Report on United Methodist Disaffiliating Churches” by Lovett Weems via Lewis Center for Church Leadership. “The Lewis Center has issued an updated report on the characteristics of churches disaffiliating from the United Methodist Church that covers more than 6,100 churches approved for disaffiliation through June 2023.” (Added 8-9-2023)
“Harambee! It is Not Yet Uhuru for African United Methodists: Amandla! Ngawethu!” by Lloyd Nyarota via UM Insight. United Methodist African Forum leader takes issue with the neo-colonialism of Mainstream UMC. (Added 8-9-2023)
“Mainline Seminaries All-In on ‘Queering the Divine’” by Rena Mainetti via Juicy Ecumenism. The [UM Duke Divinity] program “[examines the] intersections of gender with race, ethnicity, class, and sexuality, and asks what these questions mean for the church and for our common work.” …Last year, Duke Divinity School held a Pride worship service with prayers to “the Great Queer One.” (Added 8-9-2023)
“Melvin Talbert, first United Methodist bishop to officiate same-sex wedding, dead at 89” by Adelle Banks via Religion News Service. “In 2013, he officiated at the union of two men in Birmingham, Alabama, despite the urgings of the executive committee of the bishops’ council and the local bishop not to move ahead with the ceremony. He was the first bishop to take such action that broke the church’s official laws, making him the highest clergyperson to have done so.” (Added 8-9-2023)
“New Market church changes name: New identity reflects disaffiliation from United Methodist Church” via Journal Review (Crawfordsville, IN). “The name CrossWay recognizes both the belief that the cross symbolizes the way to salvation, and the fact that the church sits at New Market’s primary street crossing. The name Covenant honors our former sister church, Waveland Covenant United Methodist Church, which has recently closed.” (Added 8-9-2023)
“Seven Ways To Reintroduce Your Global Methodist Church Congregation to Your Community” by Chassity Neckers via GMC. “As faithful followers of Jesus, it is not enough to tell people what you are about, you have to show them as well. Global Methodist are committed to seeing lives transformed by Jesus through the power of His Holy Spirit – worshipping passionately, loving extravagantly, and witnessing boldly! A new name on a sign does not replace grace-filled and earnest evangelism.” (Added 8-9-2023)
“Two Oklahoma churches are in court to leave United Methodist Church” via The Oklahoman [paywall]. Further reporting on Church of the Servant and OKC First UMC. [PDF of similar posting] (Added 8-9-2023)
Post via North Georgia District of the GMC Facebook Page. “This graphic represents some of the new Methodist church plants in North Georgia throughout the past year. These Wesleyan faith communities are all in various stages of development – some are in the process of being approved as church plants, some are official GMC church plants, and others have officially become GMC churches.” (Added 8-9-2023)
Post by Great Lakes Provisional GMC Conference via Facebook. Promotes an August 22 Webinar entitled “GMC and Wespath: Looking Forward” that will cover GMC benefits. (Added 8-9-2023)
“Florida Provisional Annual Conference of the Global Methodist Church to Form on September 1, 2023” via Florida TCAT of the GMC. “By the first quarter of 2024, the Florida Conference expects to include between 125 – 140 churches.” (Added 8-8-2023)
“Episode7: Wybra Price of the Louisiana Conference” via The Mindful Leader (Podbean). “Wybra had by virtue of his role on the Louisiana Conference Cabinet a particular perspective to disaffiliation in the UMC.” (Added 8-8-2023)
“Is The UMC really…? Part 12: Where are we now?” via UM Communications. “This means about 20.4% of U.S. congregations have been approved for disaffiliation. This baseline is official. The actual disaffiliations total, however, is not. And it may not be for some time. The General Council on Finance and Administration is responsible for collecting, collating and reporting the official statistics of The United Methodist Church.” (Added 8-8-2023)
“2023 Kivu Annual Conference, June 15-22, Goma, Congo” via UMNS. “There were no church disaffiliations or closings, but there were a large number of churches in districts such as Goma, Beni, Uvira, Tanganyika, Bukavu and Fizi that have been unable to bring together all their members during Sunday worship because of the growing insecurity in these regions with armed conflicts.” (Added 8-8-2023)
Tweet via Reconciling Ministries Network: “We’re thrilled to announce the release of Theology, Identity, & Me! TIM is a deep exploration of Christian thought, natural sciences, and Church history. Through August, you can purchase this series for 50% off here: https://courses.lakelandsinstitute.com #faithfullylgbt #lgbtq #umc” (Added 8-8-2023)
“Top 25 Churches in Order by Size according to Attendance” via Christ Church Tulsa. Shows how many of the top churches have left or are in the process. This is part of the congregation’s Disaffiliation Discernment Page. (Added 8-8-2023)
“What we know about Oklahoma United Methodist disaffiliation court cases” by Carla Hinton via The Oklahoman. A compilation of information about UMC litigation ongoing in OK. [PDF] (Added 8-8-2023)
“Left behind by disaffiliations, Texas town’s United Methodists charter a new church” by BeLynn Hollers via Religion News Service. “After all seven United Methodist churches in this city in the Texas Panhandle voted to leave the country’s second-largest Protestant denomination, an 83-year-old UMC minister became determined that the UMC wouldn’t become extinct in Amarillo.” (Added 8-8-2023)
“Commentary: Grace abounds even in a season of discord” by Joe Henderson via The Florida Conference (UMC). “The demonization of either side is not the answer, even in these times of separation. For those churches choosing to leave, Bishop Berlin wished them Godspeed.” (Added 8-8-2023)
“How Big is the United Methodist Split So Far?” by John Lomperis via Juicy Ecumenism. “The United Methodist split has already become so big that there is no option to simply remain united with everyone who had been in the UMC. Deciding between the increasingly liberalized post-separation United Methodist Church vs. the Global Methodist Church is a choice between which parts of the previously unified UMC you would want to remain connected to, now that it is no longer possible to stay together with everybody.” (Added 8-8-2023)
“The Disaffiliation Process, Labeling and the Mis-Measure of the Church” by Kenneth Collins via Firebrand Magazine. “So then, if the whole matter of revisionists declaring traditionalists schismatic is both inappropriate and problematic (as if revisionists themselves were not involved in this larger process at all!), then what would be a better, more accurate, and fairer description of what is currently taking place in the disaffiliation process?” (Added 8-8-2023)
“The Bible and Revelation: Another View” by Thomas McCall via Firebrand Magazine. A response to David Watson’s article on the authority of scripture in which this Asbury professor offers the Roman Catholic view as an option for Methodists. (Added 8-8-2023)
Post by Jay Therrell via Wesleyan Covenant Association Facebook: “It is bittersweet that I share the news with you that I have informed our Global Council that I will be resigning as president of the Wesleyan Covenant Association effective September 1, 2023. On that day I will become the President pro tempore of the new Florida Provisional Annual Conference of the Global Methodist Church.” See also here. (Added 8-8-2023)
Overheard: Jay Therrell to leave his post as WCA President to become president pro tempore of the Florida Conference of the GMC. (Added 8-8-2023)
“Local church finds revival” by Ginni Clark via The News (Kingstree, SC). “Pastor Mary Seth Luoma came to the SET Charge (previous Trio United Methodist Charge) in February of 2022. She’s been an inspiration to all three churches. Once the issue of disaffiliation with the South Carolina United Methodist Conference (SCUMC) became evident, she guided its members through this procedure in God’s Grace.” (Added 8-7-2023)
“Jonesboro Methodists hold services in new locations” by Alejandra Hernández via KAIT. “Sunday marked the beginning of a new chapter for two Jonesboro churches. First Methodist Church and First United Methodist Church celebrated services in new locations.” (Added 8-7-2023)
“Church Litigation – An Interview With Lloyd Lunceford Esq.” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast (YouTube). “Lloyd Lunceford, Esq has been working in church disaffiliation law in the US for decades. Now in semi-retirement, he took the time to visit with me and help me to understand some of the basics of this area of law that most people don’t understand. If you and your church have been interested to learn more about litigation against hostile conference entities, this will almost certainly be helpful for you to consult.” (Added 8-7-2023)
Post via Friends of the Global Methodist Church Facebook Group. Shares a letter from a DS alleging that GMC “operatives are organizing in United Methodist churches under the pretext of Town Halls, and the discernment process.” (Added 8-7-2023)
“Handful of Lakelands churches leave UMC as part of split” by Lindsey Hodges via Index-Journal (SC). Shows church signs altered to remove “United” and the UMC flame. (Added 8-7-2023)
“Unintended Consequences” by Warren Lathem via Facebook. “One of the possible unintended consequences of the above is the planting of new congregations by both the Global and United Methodist Churches. Not all will be successful, but some will and new people will be reached with the gospel.” (Added 8-7-2023)
Tweet by Drew McIntyre: “It is not surprising that many of those on the furthest ends on the spectrum of the #umc family spat over the last decade left for the UCC or to become (conservative) nondenominational. Some who remain would probably better fit those contexts theologically & ecclesially.” (Added 8-7-2023)
“Pope says Church open to everyone, including LGBT people, but has rules” by Phillip Pullella via Reuters. “The Church is open to everyone but there are laws that regulate life inside the church,” he said. (Added 8-6-2023)
Post by Brad Elrod via Arkansans Staying United Facebook Group. “1st UMC Jonesboro reports 455 in their first service back in the FUMC Jonesboro building! 1st Methodist Church Jonesboro reports over 900 in their services at the campus of A State! Sounds like both groups are now thriving! Thanks be to God!” (Added 8-6-2023)
“Main Street Methodist Church Of Dillon Disaffiliates From UMC” via The Dillon Herald (SC). “However, many UMC Bishops were openly in defiance of this governing book and the ongoing inconsistency cast doubt on the fundamental beliefs held by the people called Methodists.” (Added 8-6-2023)
“‘I’m no longer fighting any battles’ Tuscarawas Co. churches leave United Methodist Church” by Jone Baker via The Times-Reporter (Yahoo News). Feature: “He believes orthodox Christianity is life-affirming, powerful and points people to God. However, he also thinks the leaders of the United Methodist denomination were taking the church in a direction that was not in accordance with the Bible.” (Added 8-6-2023)
Post by Sara Massee Ball via Facebook. “368 was the number necessary to disaffiliate from the UMC on Monday night in Madison, Ga. We had 342 “yeses.” So we started a new Global Church Plant (Madison Methodist Church) & had 367 in attendance today – plus the Holy Spirit! God is in all things!! Every detail.
It was an incredible morning of worship!” See also this post with photo from Ashley Nelson Brown. (Added 8-6-2023)
Post by Steve English via Facebook. [Photo] “Our churches in Spain have officially changed their names to “Iglesia Metodista Global” and we’ve been assigned our presiding bishop: Mark Webb. PRAISE THE LORD!” (Added 8-6-2023)
“Florida Annual Conference approves 46 churches for disaffiliation” by Florida Conference (UMC). “The vote by lay delegates was 96% to proceed with disaffiliation (786 in favor and 30 opposed). The separation is pending the completion of financial obligations that are part of the process of leaving the Conference.” (Added 8-5-2023)
Post by by Jeremy Rebman via Florida WCA Facebook Page. “I would like to sincerely thank Bishop Berlin and his Florida annual conference leadership team for their successful efforts in shepherding through the approval of 46 traditional churches in the disaffiliation process. We celebrate the overwhelming support offered by the Florida Annual Conference at the August 5, 2023, virtual special conference. These 46 churches have discerned that their calling would be better served by not continuing in the United Methodist Church. Bishop Berlin honored these requests…” (Added 8-5-2023)
Post by Jimmy Boone via Facebook. “Updated August 5. 2023. We are now at 6,232 a little over 22% of the 30,000 original total of U.M. Churches in the US. I have alphabetized all 2023 Disaffiliations
except the most recent.” (Added 8-5-2023)
Post by Amy Smith Harper via Facebook. “Today at the special [Florida] annual conference session the vote to allow 46 churches to disaffiliate was approved by a vote of 96% for and 4% against. We (First Zolfo) are one of the churches included in today’s vote. This means that once we fulfill our obligations, on September first we will no longer be part of the United Methodist denomination.” (Joining GMC) (Added 8-5-2023)
“Hamilton & The Rejection Of Traditional Beliefs” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken (YouTube). “Adam Hamilton pastors the largest church in The United Methodist Church, Church of the Resurrection in Leawood, KS. He has spoken several times on the floor of General Conference, and he has filmed segments representing the denomination’s position on theological issues. He is very much in the mainstream with respect to the average UM pastor’s theology.” (Added 8-5-2023)
Tweet by Stephen Fife: “So someone in @arkansasumc please help… @RitterChris @TaylorLoy Since the UMC has retaken Jonesboro First through the courts (not sure what those court costs were), who now owes the 5.2 Million in debt?” (Added 8-5-2023)
“Methodists, Come Home” by Mac McGregor via The Deming Headight (NM). “Come with us in this terrible time. Show the city of Deming that we are and will always be here to serve all with open arms and love. Let’s quit putting Jesus back on the cross daily because we do not want to live a godly life.” (Added 8-5-2023)
“First Church Jonesboro (A Methodist Congregation)” Website: “We are on the move to keep putting Jesus first in our lives!” “We are excited about our new move to the [ASU] Fowler Center and the Cooper Alumni Center! We will begin services at the Fowler Center on Sunday, August 6th. All Sunday services will be held in the Fowler Center in Riceland Hall and the Drama Theatre.” (Added 8-5-2023)
“United Methodist loyalists back in church building in Jonesboro” by Frank Lockwood via Arkansas Democrat-Gazette. “After meeting elsewhere for months, denominational loyalists took possession Monday of First United Methodist Church in downtown Jonesboro.” [PDF] (Added 8-5-2023)
“Post-disaffiliation grants available” by David Burke via Great Plains Conference (UMC). “Backed by $500,000 from the Great Plains Conference Council on Finance & Administration, grants will soon be available to churches in Kansas and Nebraska dealing with the aftershocks of disaffiliation.” (Added 8-5-2023)
“Host jurisdiction identified for upcoming trial” via Press Release. “Presiding Officer Bishop Alfred Gwinn announced today that the jurisdictional trial in which Bishop Minerva Carcaño is Respondent will be held in the North Central Jurisdiction of The United Methodist Church. Wespath Benefits and Investments headquarters in the Chicago suburb of Glenview, Illinois has been announced as the location by Bishop Frank Beard, President of the North Central Jurisdictional College of Bishops.” (Added 8-5-2023)
“Jacksonville congregations want to break from United Methodist Church over LGBTQ stances” by Steve Patterson via Florida Times-Union. “The futures of 10 Methodist congregations in Northeast Florida — and dozens statewide — hang on a vote Saturday about separating from the United Methodist Church, a multimillion-member denomination shrinking nationwide.” (Added 8-5-2023)
“Weekly Live Stream – August 4, 2023” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken (YouTube). Includes a discussion of Mark Holland’s recent article. (Added 8-5-2023)
“Centrists Describe Future UMC” by Tom Lambrecht via Good News. “By our calculations, the delegate count would have been very close in 2020, although still slightly favoring traditionalists. Since that time, however, almost 6,200 U.S. churches have disaffiliated, including a number of traditionalist delegates to General Conference. This year, many U.S. annual conferences elected replacement delegates for those who resigned or died since 2019, meaning the delegation will skew even more toward the progressive end.” (Added 8-5-2023)
“Will Non Denominational Surge Lead Courts to Review More Intra-Church Disputes?” by Jason Chahyadi via Juicy Ecumenism. “The answer unfortunately perhaps is an increased frequency of civil courts stepping into the theological ring and as a result, blurring the lines between adjudication of disputes and establishment or endorsement of religious doctrine.” (Added 8-4-2023)
“14 Cecil County churches disaffiliate from United Methodist denomination” by Jane Bellmyer via Cecil Whig (Elkton, MD). “The United Methodist Church Peninsula-Delaware Conference recently passed resolutions allowing 14 Cecil County churches under the UMC banner to leave the denomination.” (Added 8-4-2023)
“Mini-Bible Lesson #69: Leaving the UMC” via Ebenezer UMC (Granite Falls, NC). Scroll down for extended arguments for leaving the UMC. (Added 8-3-2023)
“Update on Fifth Avenue Lawsuit” via North Carolina Conference (UMC). “The Conference recently requested the Court to dismiss the lawsuit for several reasons, including our belief that The Book of Discipline of The United Methodist Church gives Conference officials and the assembled members at the annual conference session wide discretion to close a UMC church that is declining and no longer effectively participating in the United Methodist mission to make disciples for Jesus Christ, and the First Amendment precludes courts from second-guessing church closure decisions made by Conference officials in accordance with the Discipline.” (Added 8-3-2023)
“New ruling in conference dispute with SMU” by Sam Hodges via UMNS. “A Texas appeals court recently ruled in a lawsuit between Southern Methodist University and the South Central Jurisdictional Conference of The United Methodist Church. The appeals court largely sided with the conference in its battle to retain some governance over SMU.” (Added 8-3-2023)
“UPDATED: Judge orders Oklahoma to redo special session” by Heather Hahn via UMNS. “Editor’s Note: The Oklahoma Supreme Court on Aug. 2 granted the Oklahoma Conference’s request for an emergency stay on a judge’s order to hold a special session, pending the outcome of the conference’s appeal. The stay means the conference can cancel the special session that was planned for Aug. 5.” (Added 8-3-2023)
“Mississippi Conference Trustees 2549 Process for 2024” via Mississippi Conference (UMC). Q&A with. a video. (Added 8-3-2023)
“Wbg. church seeks resurrection, divorce from denomination” by Thom Randall via Sun Community News (Warrensburg, NY). “These are the rules and laws of the United Methodist Church, and we would like to stay with what is written, but our church’s conference is going to change it,” Haggerty said. “It will become very liberal, and we tend to be very conservative — we follow the Bible.” (Added 8-3-2023)
“Lakeland-based Methodist Conference to vote Saturday on departures of 46 congregations” by Gary White via Lakeland Ledger. “For the second time this year, the Florida Conference of the United Methodist Church will convene Saturday to consider requests for separation from dozens of congregations.” (Added 8-3-2023)
“Future for First Church uncertain after Oklahoma Supreme Court grants emergency stay” by Carla Hinton via The Oklahoman. “Ross Plourde, the conference’s attorney, also said First Church would not be harmed by waiting for the state Supreme Court to resolve the matter because the congregation has until Dec. 31 to have its request to sever ties considered under a special provision in the Book of Discipline” [PDF] (Added 8-2-2023)
“My Long Farewell to Traditional Religion (and What Remains)” by Martin Thielen via UM Insight. “Although I often recited the Apostles’ Creed in worship on Sunday mornings, I had severe doubts about many of the affirmations.” (Added 8-2-2023)
“Understanding Our Differences” by Greg Weeks via UM Insight. “So, this is big reason why we just can’t get along. We are evolutionarily-proned to view life in certain ways and orient ourselves, accordingly. Additionally, Dr. Haidt concludes that, overall, liberal-proned people have an uphill battle in their conflict with conservatives.” (Added 8-2-2023)
“BREAKING NEWS: Bishop’s Trial to Change Venue, Dates” by Cynthia Astle via UM Insight. “The trial will be the first time in UMC history that an active bishop has faced a church trial on charges that will be described when the trial convenes. Bishop Carcano has been suspended from active ministry since March 2022, an unprecedented length of time for a suspension.” (Added 8-2-2023)
Postponed Special Conference via Oklahoma WCA. “The Chief Justice of the Oklahoma Supreme Court has stayed the district court’s ruling until further arguments can be presented on August 22nd and considered by the Court. We are disappointed that the annual conference will not occur on Saturday. That said, First Church remains resolute and looks forward to vindicating their property rights.” (Added 8-2-2023)
“What has Natalie Justice learned? 4 things from her video series” via Holston Conference (UMC). “I was pretty discouraged about disaffiliation and the turmoil on both sides and several other things,” Justice explains. “Then God just laid this on my heart. I really feel like it’s a calling.” (Added 8-2-2023)
“First Church OKC: Examining The Judge’s Ruling” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast. “What I should’ve done is what I did today, which was walk through the text of Judge Aletia Haynes Timmons’ ruling pertaining to the whole trial. She was much better than I have been at being simultaneously insightful and amusing. So in this piece, I correct some unintentional misinformation I gave yesterday up front, then I walk through her ruling with minimal commentary because it really isn’t needed.”See also “Attempt to Reason on First Church OKC Votes” (Added 8-2-2023)
“Trial to be moved to new jurisdiction, location and dates pending” via Western Jurisdiction. “The Jurisdictional Trial in which Bishop Minerva Carcaño is respondent will be moved to a yet-to-be-determined jurisdiction other than the Western Jurisdiction.” (Added 8-2-2023)
“Next Steps (1 of 3): Honesty” by Mark Holland via Mainstream UMC. “The disaffiliations gave us even more “compatibilist” delegates. The number of delegates per conference was already set, so when traditionalists left, centrists and progressives were elected to replace them. Now, what was 80% of the US church, likely has more than 90% of the US votes. We do not yet have 2/3 for regionalization, but we are very likely to have a majority. If we do have a “compatibilist” majority, there is NO scenario where, after suffering significant membership losses in the US, we do not vote to change the language at this upcoming General Conference…. We may lose Africa and the Philippines.” (Added 8-2-2023)
“Church separation takes center stage in Liberia” by E. Julu Swen via UMNS. “An executive meeting of the Liberia Annual Conference was held for advocacy groups with differing views on The United Methodist Church’s future to discuss what the conference would do after the 2024 General Conference.” (Added 8-2-2023)
“Flames removed from Methodist church cross after denomination split” by Taylor Vidmar via Herald & Review (Decatur, IL). “For the church’s congregation, the flame’s removal signaled much more than just an aesthetic change.” (Added 8-2-2023)
“Attempt to Reason on First Church OKC Votes” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast. “The first block is my legal analysis thanks to a lawyer taking pity on me. The middle block is the document. The last block is my moral analysis. I’m hoping that delegates who don’t really know what is going on will take the time to learn what both sides are saying and consider the veracity and weight of each party.” (Added 8-2-2023)
“FAQ’s and Court Documents” via First Methodist, Oklahoma City. A repository of information about First Methodist Church OKC’s legal battles with the Oklahoma Conference for disaffiliation. (Added 8-2-2023)
“Annual Conference Aug 5 Special Virtual Session” via Florida Conference (UMC). Forty-six churches will be considered for disaffiliation at a special session on August 5. (Added 8-2-2023)
“Pause to Meditate: A Church in Flux” by Jon Klaus via the Bloomfield Democrat. “The United Methodist Church denomination is currently in flux. This is a nice way of saying that a decision to change or remain the same has landed (or will soon land) on the doorstep of every local UMC church in America to some degree.” (Added 8-2-2023)
“Letter: Hard decision for church to disaffiliate” by Marjorie Bayes via the Tribune-Star (IN). “I feel the word “ban” was a little harsh regarding the disaffiliation of churches from the United Methodist Conference. We are not banning anyone from our church. As a matter of fact, we welcome everyone to come visit and we will demonstrate God’s love.” (Added 8-2-2023)
“Madison’s First United Methodists to stay united, despite majority vote to split” by Tia Lynn Ivey via Morgan County Citizen (GA). “Last Tuesday evening, more than 550 members of The First United Methodist Church (FUMC) of Madison flocked to the historic sanctuary for “the big vote” to decide whether or not to split from the denomination.” (Added 8-1-2023)
“Special United Methodist disaffiliation meeting to go on after judge refuses to halt order” by Carla Hinton via The Oklahoman. “A special United Methodist disaffiliation meeting is still on after a judge refused to stay her ruling in a local church’s exit dispute.” PDF (Added 8-1-2023)
“SMU attempt to split from Methodist Church hits legal snags on appeal” by Michael Carroll via Southeast Texas Record. “A Texas appeals court has chipped away at some of the legal arguments Southern Methodist University (SMU) has used to cut its ties to the United Methodist Church after the church barred same-sex marriage ceremonies and LGBTQ clergy.” (Added 8-1-2023)
“As churches shrink and pastors retire, creative workarounds are redefining ministry” by Elizabeth Evans via The Washington Post. “There is a lot of effort and emphasis on equipping people to do alternative forms of new faith communities that are localized, often led by laypeople,” [former Dean of Duke Divinity School, Elaine Heath] said.
“Jesus Won’t Let me Hate” by Jay Therrell via WCA. “You can hate me. I hope you don’t. It’s not what Jesus wants for you. And because it’s unlikely that I’m going to change your minds, I sincerely and honestly wish for you the peace of Jesus Christ. Would you sincerely and honestly do the same for me?” (Added 8-1-2023)
“160: No Thanks: A Response to Some Theses on Anglican Reunification” by Matt Kennedy via StandFirm Podcast. Before the UMC/GMC schism, there was the Episcopal/Anglican divide. Three Anglican pastors respond here to recent calls for reconciliation… with a firm “no thanks.” (Added 7-31-2023
“Highly Unusual” by Chris Ritter via PNJ’s Team Caffeine. Why Methodist insiders are talking about special session of the Oklahoma Conference on August 5. (Added 7-31-2023)
“UMC conference challenges court ruling in favor of church blocked from disaffiliating” by Aungrah Kumar via The Christian Post. “A significant dispute within the Oklahoma United Methodist Conference is escalating, as the First United Methodist Church of Oklahoma City challenges a local court’s ruling over its disaffiliation request. The regional body is appealing the ruling to the Oklahoma Supreme Court, citing a violation of their First Amendment rights.” (Added 7-31-2023)
“What Every Southeastern United Methodist Needs to Know” by John Lomperis via Juicy Ecumenism. “Even the previously conservative-leaning United Methodist Southeastern Jurisdiction has now crossed the lines of official commitment to LGBTQIA+ liberationist ideology, systemic exclusion of theologically orthodox believers from leadership, a transgender activist minister in the itinerant appointment system, and other liberal extremism.” (Added 7-31-2023)
“Our “Father/Mother” Which Art In Heaven” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast (YouTube). “Recently a United Methodist Church in Birmingham Alabama decided to use more “inclusive” language when saying the Lords Prayer. When confronted by a member of another church, the pastor (Stephanie York-Arnold), explained why they chose to do so, and later produced a video to explain to everyone. In this video we examine that explanation and breakdown the issues from a conservative perspective.” (Added 7-31-2023)
“Empower Your Church’s Future Outside of the UMC with Cutting-Edge Ministry Technologies” via ACSTechnologies. Lawyers are not the only group marketing to disaffiliating churches: “Trust in our dedicated team for expert guidance & unwavering support as you find your independence. Experience seamless administrative processes with our user-friendly software.” (Added 7-31-2023)
Post by Sky McCracken via Facebook. On a David Watson article in Firebrand that offers a more complex view of biblical authority than some might assume: “Before someone files church charges on me, know that this is not the work of “liberals,” but rather Methodist Evangelicals on the most orthodox “side” of Methodism. How we view – and how we DON’T view scripture – matters. A very good read, but not one that will make everyone happy.” (Added 7-29-2023)
“BREAKING: Christ Chapel UMC in Kenya Becomes Second African Reconciling United Methodist Church” via Reconciling Ministries Network. “Christ Chapel United Methodist Church (UMC) in Oyani, Kenya, became the second African Reconciling Church to join the global Reconciling movement for LGBTQ justice and inclusion in The UMC by affiliating with Reconciling Ministries Network.” (Added 7-29-2023)
“Oklahoma Annual Conference fights Court Overreach, Nullification of Church Law” by Jeremy Smith via Hacking Christianity. “If this decision is upheld then it would be open season on ecclesiology of every local church and mainline denomination, saying church processes are subject to revision and approval by civil law.” (Added 7-29-2023)
“A Look at Other Court Cases” by Heather Hahn via UMNS. A round-up of the status of court cases in 12 annual conferences. (Added 7-29-2023)
Post by Gloria Denton via Facebook. Sharing an image encouraging Oklahomans to vote “no” on August 5 as a statement about UM self-governance elicits a comment by Sean Walker, Trustees Chair at First Church OKC. (Added 7-28-2023)
Tweet by John Lomperis: “Liberal #UnitedMethodist group helpfully admits: “Traditionalists have long believed that with regionalization, the United States and Western Europe would allow ordination and marriage for LGBTQ persons. And they are right.” #UMC” (Added 7-28-2023)
“The Changing Shape of Methodism” by Tom Lambrecht via Good News. “Although exact numbers are not available at this point, it appears that at least 80 percent of disaffiliating congregations are aligning immediately with the Global Methodist Church (GMC).” (Added 7-28-2023)
“When Jesus Prays for Unity” by Carolyn Moore via Good News. “The nature of spiritual unity is agreement in Christ. Christian unity is rooted in Jesus. In other words, Jesus teaches us that the way to true spiritual unity is to gather at the foot of the cross and find our unity in all that Jesus died for.” (Added 7-28-2023)
“Weekly Livestream: July 28, 2023” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast (YouTube). “I set aside an hour or so each week to digest Methodist/Wesleyan-related developments from the previous week. I also like to hear what the folks who support PlainSpoken are thinking about and connect with them for a bit. PlainSpoken is a fun project because it intersects with something so many wonderful people care about. Spend some time with me to learn, grow, and pray a bit together.” (Added 7-28-2023)
“Commentary: Our Side of the Street” by Rob Renfroe via Good News. “So, to clear up the misinformation, will the UM Church change the Articles of Religion any time soon? No. Will the UM Church and its bishops who are charged with upholding our doctrines enforce the Articles of Religion in the future? If they didn’t do so before the traditionalists left, it’s hard to believe they will do so in the future when most of us are gone.” (Added 7-28-2023)
“What the Regionalization Agenda Tells Us about the Future of the UMC, Part 2” by Thomas Lambrecht via Good News. “They want to impose “unity” and the “One Church Plan” by making it impossible to disaffiliate. Now they want to impose regionalization as the way to implement the “One Church Plan.”” (Added 7-28-2023)
“2023 North Katanga Annual Conference” via UMNS. ““It is true that disaffiliation of local churches is happening globally, and individuals leave locally. People are free to leave, (but) I do not allow global allies to start their outreach within the North Katanga Annual Conference,” Muyombo said, referring to allies of the Global Methodist Church.” (Added 7-28-2023)
“Judge orders Oklahoma to redo special session” by Heather Hahn via UMNS. “The judge specifically called on the conference to bring back voters who are no longer United Methodist. The conference says the order is an unconstitutional intrusion into a church dispute.” (Added 8-28-2023)
“SMU Attempt to Split With Founders Loses Ground on Appeal” by Adolfo Pesquera via Texas Lawyer. “Southern Methodist University suffered setbacks on appeal in its effort to divorce itself from the conference that has controlled its fate for over a century…On issues where the court ruled against SMU, and there were many, Goldstein began by stating the trial court erred in dismissing the conference’s claims for lack of standing.” See 83-page ruling here. (Added 7-28-2023)
“Reflections On The Growth Of The Global Methodist Church” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast (YouTube). “In just over a year the GMC has grown to over 3100 congregations and 3400 clergy. A recent article by Rev. Keith Boyette examines this growth and the hopes for the GMC, in this video Jeffrey breaks down the article and gives his own reflections on the development within the Global Methodist Church.” (Added 7-28-2023)
“Changes to District Office Administrative Support” via Western PA Conference (UMC). “Additionally, with the disaffiliation of Faith Delmont UM Church, the Greensburg district office has been moved to Community UM Church in Irwin.” (Added 7-28-2023)
“Sheldon United Methodist Church splits from UMC” by Aleisa Schat via nwestiowa.com. Gingerich will step behind the same pulpit each Sunday, but all signs of the United Methodist logo — a red cross and flame — have been removed from the sanctuary. The logo also has been removed from the red brick exterior, although the outline of the flame remains visible in the discolored limestone. Out front, a new black-and-white sign reads “Faith Community Church.” (Added 7-28-2023)
“What is the Methodist schism impact on Millsaps College? It’s more than money” by Ross Reily via Clarion-Ledger. “During the more than 130-year partnership, which has specifically been with the UMC since 1968, the Methodist financial support for the liberal arts college has dwindled as Americans, and Mississippians specifically don’t give to religious organizations (such as the UMC and the regional conference and some churches) as much as they once did.” (Added 7-28-2023)
“Texas UMCs Team Up after Disaffiliation Heartbreak” via UM Insight. Stay UMC is joining with La Trinidad UMC and Wesley Harper UMC at 10:30 a.m. on Aug. 6 in La Trinidad’s sanctuary to celebrate communion together and be a witness to the denomination’s slogan, “Open Hearts, Open Minds, Open Doors.” (Added 7-28-2023)
“Powell Chapel Church thriving after UMC disaffiliation, pastor says” by Kandice Bell via Newnan Times-Herald.The disaffiliation of a North Georgia congregation is featured. (Added 7-28-2023)
“Citing jurisdiction, Oklahoma United Methodist Conference appeals First Church ruling” by Carla Hinton via The Oklahoman. “Oklahoma United Methodist Conference leaders said their First Amendment rights were violated when a judge ruled that they intentionally prevented First United Methodist Church of Oklahoma City from disaffiliating in April alongside 55 other churches. They are asking the Oklahoma Supreme Court to overturn the judge’s ruling.” (Added 7-28-2023)
“Walking in the Truth (and through disaffiliation)” by Michael Roberts. “Walking in the truth starts with self-examination (Psalm 51:6; Matt 7:1-5; II Cor 13:5-10). We all have our biases. None of us see the whole on our own. We all engage in what is unnatural for us, used by Paul as an illustration, not as a justification for judgement.” (Added 7-27-2023)
Post via First UMC Jonesboro, AR. A letter from the UMC congregation slated to take over the building that they intend to keep the Early Learning Center open. (Added 7-27-2023)
“Second Anglican Parish Heads for Episcopal Church” by Jeffrey Walton via Juicy Ecumenism. “As I’ve previously noted, for such a small slice of the American religious pie (approximately 125,000 members), the ACNA sits on a heavily transited parcel of ecclesial real estate. Our denomination is often a waystation for Christians traveling from – and moving on to – a variety of destinations.” (Added 7-27-2023)
Post by Good News Methodist Church, Philippines via Facebook. “The province of Aklan has six Methodist churches and almost 90% of it are in support of the Global Methodist Church. Most of the members’ reason in moving is about how the GM church is consistent in doctrine; saving the Good News of Jesus. After Aklan Methodist Churches decided to join the GM Church, there is an increasing amount of returning members who left the church before—that is a miracle!” (Added 7-27-2023)
“Called Special Session of the North Alabama Annual Conference” via North Alabama Conference. “This [9/12/23 session) is the final of three special sessions (December 2022, May 2023 and September 2023) of the North Alabama Annual Conference to vote on disaffiliations for churches who, after going through our discernment process…” (Added 7-27-2023)
“Becoming a lighthouse congregation” by Phillips Brooks via UM Communications. Lists annual conferences with lighthouse networks for UM’s displaced by disaffiliation. (Added 7-27-2023)
“Methodist splintering: Some stay, some break away” by Mary Jane Epling via The Daily Independent (Ashland, KY). “Nearly half of United Methodist Church congregations in Kentucky have elected to split from the denomination, and some area church representatives say it’s been a long time coming due to more than just polarizing social topics.” (Added 7-27-2023)
“The Use and Misuse of Numbers” by Bob Phillips via PeopleNeedJesus.net. “How can a new GMC and a renewed UMC leverage numbers to empower and enhance ministry, rather that inhibit or derail it?”(Added 7-27-2023)
Motion to Dismiss by Baltimore-Washington Conference via Anne Arundel County Circuit Court (PDF). Memoranda of points and authorities in support of defendants’ motion to dismiss the lawsuit by exiting churches. (Added 7-26-2023)
“A Post-separation South Carolina Conference: Now What?” by Jessica Brodie via UM Insight. “As for what’s next, Bishop L. Jonathan Holston has repeatedly called for United Methodists in South Carolina to join him in prayer as the church waits for General Conference, slated for May 2024 in Charlotte.” (Added 7-26-2023)
“Mississippi UMC Extends Disaffiliation Deadline…Maybe” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast (YouTube). “Mississippi and many other UMC annual conferences are increasingly using Paragraph 2549.3.b to supplement or replace Paragraph 2553. Some, including Mississippi, are so bold as to say that they will use it to extend the ability of local churches to disaffiliate.” (Added 7-26-2023)
“Five Challenges to Regionalization” by Mark Holland via Mainstream UMC. “Not a single annual conference in Africa has publicly voted to support regionalization. African delegates comprise 1/3 of the votes at General Conference and delivered 60% of the votes for the Traditional Plan in 2019. There will be no regionalization without their approval.” (Added 7-26-2023)
E-mail by Oklahoma Conference (UMC). “We are writing to you today with information regarding a special called session of Annual Conference which will take place on Saturday, August 5 at 10 a.m. in OCU’s Kirkpatrick Auditorium. This is an extraordinary session of our conference called in response to the ruling of a district court judge in the lawsuit filed against the conference by First UMC, OKC. More information can be found in the attached Pre-Conference Workbook.” (Added 7-26-2023)
“Congregations leave United Methodist Church over defiance of LGBTQ bans” by Jason DeRose via WAMU. “More recently, [The Fount] voted unanimously to leave the United Methodist Church because of what Haworth describes as a drift from traditional biblical teachings on morality. “Most recent and probably most prominent is the differences of opinion we have with regard to homosexuality, marriage in general, the sexual ethic,” he says. “And we believe, as do many Christians, that the Bible is very specific in that teaching.” (Added 7-26-2023)
“Efforts for regionalization move forward” by Heather Hahn via UMNS. “The Connectional Table, meeting online on July 13, and the Standing Committee on Central Conference Matters, meeting online on July 22, each unanimously affirmed the work so far on a regionalization proposal for the global denomination.” (Added 7-26-2023)
“Manchester Methodist disaffiliates from United Methodist Church” by Daniel Charland via Manchester Press. Iowa local coverage. (Added 7-26-2023)
“Slavery, Homosexuality, and United Methodist Regionalism” by Riley Case via Juicy Ecumenism. “This article proposes to compare our present situation with what the Methodist Episcopal Church faced in the 1840s over issues around slavery, regionalization, and unity.” (Added 7-26-2023)
“Watch Us Grow” by Keith Boyette via GMC. “Fifteen months from its launch, the Global Methodist Church continues to grow and mature. Much has occurred in this 15-month period, fueled by an army of dedicated, passionate, committed Christ followers. And we are only just beginning! The numbers only tell part of the story. We now have 3,100 congregations and 3,400 clergy aligned with the GM Church with more added weekly.” (Added 7-26-2023)
“Focusing on the Future: Standing with Those Who’ve Stood with Us” by Jay Therrell via WCA. “For years, our African and Filipino friends in the faith have stood by our side helping to maintain the orthodoxy of The United Methodist Church. We have worked together at General Conference to prevent progressives from watering down the Good News of Jesus and the doctrine and theology of John Wesley. We owe them much.” (Added 7-26-2023)
“Commentary: Looking at autonomy and connection together” by David Scott via UMNS. “Like annual conferences in the United States, some European conferences are struggling with conflicts, particularly over sexuality in the church. Some have chosen to become autonomous, while others have chosen disaffiliation.” (Added 7-25-2023)
“First Church OKC Order Granting Plaintiff’s Motion” via PDF. Signed order by Judge Aletia Haynes Timmons ordering Bishop Nunn to call a special session of the Oklahoma Conference to consider the disaffiliation of First UMC, Oklahoma City. (Added 7-25-2023)
“Today’s Southern United Methodism: Non-Celibate Gay Clergy, Weddings Already Here” by John Lomperis via Juicy Ecumenism. “The Discipline’s standards remain the same on paper, yet the de facto reality is already that even in previously conservative Southern areas, the United Methodist Church is now one of those liberal denominations that has gay weddings and same-sex-partnered ministers.” (Added 7-25-2023)
“Same-sex marriage, LGBTQ+ clergy inclusion causing division within United Methodist Church” via ABC9 (Tampa) Youtube. “Before someone even walks into Allendale United Methodist Church in St. Petersburg, they already know it’s an accepting place. A welcome message displayed at the entrance explains how Allendale is a “sanctuary for all.” And all means all—regardless of race, ethnicity, economic situation, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, background or belief, age, physical condition or marital status.” (Added 7-25-2023)
Overheard: An Anne Arundel County case search indicates the first hearing in the Baltimore-Washington Conference case is scheduled for September 18, 2023. (Added 7-25-2023)
“The legal issues local churches should consider and address to avoid problems in the future.” via Dalton & Tomich (YouTube). Five things to consider once a church has disaffiliated. (Added 7-25-2023)
“A welcoming place: Inside LGBTQ+ inclusive churches of Wilmington” by Brenna Flanagan via Port City Daily (Wilmington, NC). “The UMC has undergone changes in recent years, and after a period of reflection, the congregants at Fifth Avenue felt that the UMC no longer met their needs,” Fifth Avenue’s attorney Gavin Parsons told Port City Daily. (Added 7-25-2023)
“Western Jurisdiction College of Bishops: Our request for transparency as we approach the jurisdictional trial” via California-Nevada Conference, UMC. “We have requested that the trial be live-streamed, pending the consent of the complainants and the respondent. We have also requested public disclosure of the charges at a time deemed appropriate by Bishop Gwinn and also agreed to by the complainants and the respondent.” (Added 7-25-2023)
“Five steps for congregational healing” by Laura Buchanan via Resource UMC. “Whether this is because of a tense discernment process regarding disaffiliation or division caused by a close disaffiliation vote, providing intentional opportunities for healing will help the local church move forward. Both clergy and lay leaders can begin the healing process with these steps…” (Added 7-25-2023)
“A “Pain in the Brain”: Is the Bible Divine Revelation? [Firebrand Big Read]” by David Watson via Firebrand Magazine. The Academic Dean of United Theological Seminary, a GMC clergy, discusses the divine revelation of scripture via the work of Billy Abraham and I. Howard Marshall. (Added 7-25-2023)
“Are Disaffiliators Promoting White Supremacy?” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken (YouTube). “Bishop Forrest Stith published a lengthy article leveling the charge of systemic racism against those who have disaffiliated from The United Methodist Church. I submit that Stith presents false information to promote racial hatred and separation, that the institution of the UMC might continue to benefit from black people who would otherwise separate themselves.” (Added 7-25-2023)
Post by Bishop Scott Jones via Facebook. Sharing a summary of the Eastern Texas GMC Conference by Burt Palmer. (Added 7-25-2023)
Post by Lauren Porter via Facebook. Sharing the Mississippi Conference’s extension of the disaffiliation process. See also here. (Added 7-25-2023)
“The disunited Methodist Church” by Ray Rooney via American Family News. “By far and away the issues of the United Methodist Church are nestled in and emanating from its leadership and seminaries. You cannot fix sin.” (Added 7-25-2023)
“Disaffiliation Information Meeting | July 15, 2023” via First UMC, Broken Arrow, OK (YouTube). The bishop, DS, and a conference officer lead a disaffiliation information meeting. (Added 7-25-2023)
“Major issue affects many Protestant churches in North America” by John Longhurst via The Free Press. “This current battle over LGBTTQ+, Tickle said, would be “the bitterest, because once it is lost, there are no more fights to be had” over how people read the Bible — whether it is to be taken literally as a black-and-white book of rules, or if it should be seen as a product of its time that can provide only inspiration for current belief and behaviour. (Added 7-24-2023)
“Methodist Split & Post-denominational USA” by Mark Tooley via Juicy Ecumenism. Introduces a longer article by Tooley in World. (Added 7-23-2023)
“The Stories We Tell: Grace Methodist Church | Winnie, TX” via Eastern Texas Conference GMC. “This is what happens when a committed group of laity decides it’s time to plant their own church.” (Added 7-23-2023)
“Whither the United (?) Methodist Church” via The Democratic Underground. “Regardless of the cause or the outcome, in my little county four churches have removed the word “United” from their signs, leaving only “Bethany Methodist Church”, etc. My church has not even thought of LGBTQ issues, no one is interested in disaffiliation, and we have picked up a few members from the local disaffiliated churches. Meanwhile, we have no pastor so we lay members are filling in …” (Added 7-23-2023)
“Distillations from The United Methodist Church” by Nate Nims via Substack. “This loud and vocal minority of The UMC has dictated the narrative of our church for far too long, and even as they exit, they continue to amplify a message that too many, myself included, don’t think sounds like Christ.” (Added 7-23-2023)
“Letter to Western Jurisdiction Bishops” by General Commission on Religion and Race (UMC). “Now that the matter is a judicial process, we reiterate our call for disclosure of the nature of the charges. As we said in our April 27th letter, the Book of Discipline ¶ 2701.4c, allows such a disclosure when there has been “significant disruption to the … annual conference, or the context of ministry by the judicial matter.” As you well know, this matter has been and is causing significant disruption to the annual conference and the entire denomination.” (Added 7-22-2023)
“Email sheds light on what’s next for First Church and Oklahoma United Methodist Conference” by Carla Hinton via The Oklahoman. “The Oklahoma United Methodist Conference, led by Bishop Jimmy Nunn, sent emails to conference members on Friday outlining tentative plans for a special disaffiliation meeting on Aug. 4 or Aug. 5 at Oklahoma City University.” (Added 7-22-2023)
“‘Should I stay or should I go?’ Area Methodist pastors discuss UMC divide” by Grant Bromley via Cleveland Daily Banner. “There are other concerns as well, such as a perceived shifting in interpretation of Scripture, but the “human sexuality” debate has often been the primary focus of media coverage.” (Added 7-22-2023)
“Problems in the Eastern Pennsylvania UMC Annual Conference (Part 3)” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast. “Part 3, the final part, of our coverage of the Easter Pennsylvania Annual Conference that happened earlier this year. We discuss a few more clips of the issues that happened in this contentious meeting and hope it helps us reflect on how those who have left the UMC should act in their new denominations.” (Added 7-22-2023)
“United Methodist Church disaffiliation over LGBT rights has little impact in Northwest Colorado” by John Chalstrom via Steamboat Pilot. “The Heart of Steamboat has demonstrated that it is an inclusive church by opening its doors to members of other faiths for the conduction of services. Most notably is the Heart of Steamboat’s allowance of members of the local Jewish and Buddhist communities to use the church for religious services.” (Added 7-22-2023)
“Even in the South, the United Methodist Church Has Changed” by John Lomperis via Juicy Ecumenism. “However, recent developments have shattered illusions that any region can remain safe from the aggressive new liberalism now dominating what’s left of the UMC.” (Added 7-22-2023)
“The Story’s Story with Eric Huffman” by Andy Miller III via More to the Story Podcast. “Pastor Eric Huffman is the founder and lead pastor of The Story Church [a former UM church], host of the Maybe God Podcast, and author of “40 Days of Doubt” and “Scripture and the Skeptic.” Pastor Eric’s passion is to lead new generations to ask their questions, to doubt their doubts, and to know the truth of God through Jesus Christ.” (Added 7-21-2023)
“What the Regionalization Agenda Tells Us about the Future of the UMC, Part 1” by Tom Lambrecht via Good News. “The larger implication from this difference of perspective is that the future UM Church is more likely to adapt to the surrounding culture than live differently, no matter what Scripture says.” (Added 7-21-2023)
“United Methodist Crisis Goes Critical” by Mark Tooley via World. “The UMC split carries big lessons for American Christianity.” (Added 7-21-2023)
Post by Jimmy Boone via Facebook. A listing of the five special sessions scheduled for Aug/Sept: Florida, Dakotas, Holston, North Alabama, and Desert Southwest. (Added 7-20-2023)
“The Formation & Fall of the ELCA – A Conversation With Rev. Dean Wheeler” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast (YouTube). “In this conversation, Rev. Wheeler details how it is that he experienced the time of theological corruption and decay, as well as what lessons he learned as he finds himself outside of the conflict today. Methodists would do well to learn lessons from other traditions, as we can often be too close to our own circumstances to see them for what they are.” (Added 7-20-2023)
“Devouring Widows’ Houses: Pharisees, Sadducees, and Bishops” by Joe DiPaolo via PeopleNeedJesus.net. “I could not help but think of the behavior of some of our institutional leaders – especially when I saw clips from the Cal-Pac annual conference session in June.” (Added 7-20-2023)
Post via Glendale UMC (Facebook). [photos] “This cinder block: used as a physical, tangible sign of hate thrown through our sanctuary window. Our own Sophie Dukes felt the call to take it home to transform it to reveal the beauty of God’s inclusive + affirming love for ALL people. THIS is our mission at Glendale. Hate, violence + bigotry never have the final word. #FindYourPeople #GodIsLove #BeUMC #GlendaleUMC” (Added 7-20-2023)
Post via Ken Pearson via Arkansans Staying United Facebook Group. “Last night I spoke for the 6th time at a disaffiliation listening session. After the session I was asked an “old” question in a new way. The person began with “I (I assume that was intended as “we”) have paid for this church. Why do we need a trust clause? I think the question belies a number of deeper positions, but I am going to keep my comments here to the direct question.” (Added 7-20-2023)
Post via East Texas Conference Facebook Page. “Welcome to Annual Conference! We will see you shortly. Lord, come meet with us through the power of your Holy Spirit. #ETXGMC #ETXGMCstories” See also Pre-Conference webinar via YouTube. (Added 7-20-2023)
“Rev. Keith Boyette” via Thrive (Asbury Seminary). “Reverend Keith Boyette said “yes” at key junctures of his life when he sensed a call from God to move into a new role. Each “yes” launched him into utilizing his gifts and heart for the kingdom. He is now the Transitional Connectional Officer of the Global Methodist Church. Yet Reverend Boyette’s journey began with his being an atypical seminary student.” (Added 7-20-2023)
“Church sees signs of renewal even as exits rise” by Heather Hahn via UMNS. But for now, about 80% of U.S. United Methodist congregations — or eight in 10 — remain in the denomination, and many longtime church observers see reason to hope that the tide of disaffiliation is starting to ebb. (Added 7-19-2023)
“UMC conference can’t stop church from pursuing disaffiliation, judge rules” by Michael Gryboski via Christian Post. “Timmons ruled that the Oklahoma United Methodist Conference committed several actions that prevented the congregation from joining 55 other churches in disaffiliating during a meeting in April. He ordered the conference and delegates to consider and vote on the church’s disaffiliation.” (Added 7-19-2023)
“Disaffiliating from Disaffiliation” by Richard Bryant via UM Insight. “If disaffiliation is going to happen, it will occur without me. Physically, I am exhausted. Emotionally, I am unable to cope. Spiritually, I am empty. Disaffiliation has robbed me of my ability to function in the only work I have ever known.” (Added 7-19-2023)
“Popular downtown Oklahoma City church allowed to leave denomination, judge rules” via KOCO. “While the First United Methodist Church celebrated their legal win, the Oklahoma Methodist Conference said they are appealing the ruling.” (Added 7-19-2023)
“Pastor Jeffrey Rickman’s Caution to Disaffiliated Methodists” via Juicy Ecumenism. “I’m asking that we resolve to learn to fight well. To be fair, but to be firm. Let’s build something worth protecting upon the foundation of Christ himself, something that stands the trying fires of history and lasts to all eternity…” (Added 7-19-2023)
“‘Break Camp . . . Go Forward’” by Bishop Scott Jones via GMC. Report on the official launch of the GMC in the Philippines. (Added 7-19-2023)
“SIE27: We’re All Incompatible with Jason Micheli” via Bar of the Conference Podcast. “Jason shares his journey as a follower of Jesus, pastor and theologian. His love for the local church and transparency about the big conversations in the UMC are a gift to us.” (Added 7-19-2023)
“We get to write United Methodism’s next headline, together” by Patrick Scriven via Pacific Northwest Conference. “I think The United Methodist Church is in a better place after losing 20 percent of its churches because we have never been clearer in what we believe than we are right now (which isn’t to suggest there isn’t room to grow here).” (Added 7-19-2023)
“First Church OKC Victorious Against Oklahoma Annual Conference in Court” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast. “They saw their day in court, and a state judge has ruled in favor of the local church, mandating that the conference comply with very strict and unprecedented stipulations. This segment details what was said in these court proceedings, what the particulars of the judge’s ruling are, and what might happen from here.” (Added 7-19-2023)
“Clergy Bill of Rights” via Minnesota WCA (PDF). “It appears that we are witnessing a UM Inquisition by the bishops and their boards of ordained ministries, not to torture or kill, but to restrict and purify the UM church from both retired and active clergy who threaten their influence. A council of religious leaders similarly mistreated Jesus and his apostles to preserve their institution and influence.” (Added 7-19-2023)
“Meet Bishop Cedrick Bridgeforth” via Get Your Spirit in Shape Podcast, UM Communications. An interview with the UMC’s second openly gay bishop. (Added 7-19-2023)
Transcript of Ruling – PDF from District Court of Oklahoma County, OK. The 7/17/2023 ruling requiring the Oklahoma Conference to hold a special session to consider disaffiliations. (Added 7-19-2023)
“New United Methodist Community Sprouting in Ruston” via Louisiana Conference (UMC). “The irony is not lost on the Ruston Remnants, a group of United Methodists whose former congregations, Grace and Trinity churches in Ruston, voted to disaffiliate. Even the name the group chose for itself evokes disparate emotions of humor and sadness, but that’s more a statement of reality than self-pity.” (Added 7-19-2023)
“How ALL United Methodist Bishops Fail the Discipline” by John Lomperis via Juicy Ecumenism. This theological anarchy represents a major dereliction of the duty of United Methodist bishops to uphold the Discipline. Per Discipline Paragraph 403.1, central to the job description of a bishop is to “guard the faith, order, liturgy, doctrine, and discipline of the church.” (Added 7-18-2023)
“Arkansas Conference UMC to go down one district” by Lewis Delavan via Hot Springs Village Voice. “Saline County United Methodist churches are in the Arkansas Conference’s central district. Garland County churches — along with those in Hot Spring and Montgomery counties — join the central district on July 1, 2024.” (Added 7-18-2023)
“Judge rules for First United Methodist Church of Oklahoma City in disaffiliation dispute” by Carla Hinton via The Oklahoman. No paywall. “”The ruling today blatantly interferes with what is and should be an internal church process protected under the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment of the United States Constitution,” the conference said in a prepared statement.” (Added 7-18-2023)
Post by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken: “Oh wow, the judge finally ruled in the case of First Methodist of Oklahoma City. She has mandated that the conference hold a special conference to ratify their disaffiliation by August 6. Reps from the 55 churches that disaffiliated already in April will be able to vote. This is unprecedented.” (Added 7-18-2023)
“Windshields are Bigger than Rearview Mirrors” by Jay Therrell via WCA. “First, we want to help our churches move from an attractional model to a missional model.” (Added 7-18-2023)
Post by Warren Lathem via Facebook. “There continues to be some in this group who question the role of women in ministry. The GMC has stated unequivocally it’s support for women in ministry and has demonstrated it in fact in the leadership of the GMC in every area…” (Added 7-18-2023)
Opposition Memorandum via Google Drive PDF. The National Center of Life and Liberty representing exiting Baltimore-Washington Conference churches files opposition to the BWC’s motion to dismiss. (Added 7-18-2023)
“A Gospel of Power: Reclaiming Pastoral Identity for Clergy Leaving the UMC” by Adam Roe via Firebrand Magazine. “As we navigate new paths forward, it is critically important that we embark on this journey equipped not only with our convictions about biblical teachings, but with a renewed understanding of what it means to serve faithfully under the authority of the Bible. It is also a fitting time to repent of our own lapses where warranted.” (Added 7-18-2023)
Tweet by John Meunier: “I wonder how we would build annual conferences from scratch with the resources we expect to have if we were starting with a blank slate. #umc Cutting a structure built with a larger resource base is not the best way to accomplish the mission, is it?”(7-18-2023)
“Many reasons for church disaffiliations” by Joe McCollough via Times-Observer. Warren, PA Commentary: “The real issue is between progressives in the church and conservatives who believe in traditional John Wesley (founder of the Methodist Church) teachings and beliefs.” (Added 7-18-2023)
“Moving Membership to The Florida Annual Conference” via Florida UM Conference. “Lay persons wishing to move their membership to a new church should do so before the disaffiliation of their current church. Disaffiliation dates for 2023 are: June 1, September 1, and December 31. Those persons wishing to remain United Methodist but are uncertain of their new church home can offer their names to the General Church Roll for one year as they discern next steps.” (Added 7-18-2023)
“UMC rapidly loses churches over defiant LGBT clergy” by Grant Haun via The Sentinel. “Disagreements about theology, sexuality, and the ordination of self-identified LGBT clergy have led many UMC churches to disaffiliate from the denomination.” (Added 7-18-2023)
“United Methodists going separate ways” by Jordan Smith via Casper Star-Tribune (Wyoming). “Part of coming out of disaffiliation is for both groups, passionate people, to sort of settle in a direction that is in alignment with their practice of theology,” he said. (Added 7-18-2023)
Post via Great Lakes Provisional Conference of the GMC Facebook Page. An October 27-28 save-the-date for the convening annual conference. (Added 7-17-2023)
“Launchpad 2023: Regrouping in the Wake of Disaffiliation” via Discipleship Ministries of the UMC. “Launchpad 2023 is specialized around the challenges of forming new churches and fellowships arising from the disaffiliation crisis in the UMC. It is being offered digitally to enable ease of participation without travel, to as many persons as possible, at a minimal cost ($395 for a team of up to five).” (Added 7-17-2023)
Overheard: U.S. Conference-based chapters of the Wesleyan Covenant Association will soon give way to chapters based on the U.S. jurisdictions due to the migration of leadership to the GMC. (Added 7-17-2023)
“Spring City Methodist Church changes affiliation” via The Herald-News. Tennessee reporting on a church joining the GMC. (Added 7-17-2023)
“First Church-OKC exit case continues with focus on mission, members and mixed messages” by Carla Hinton via The Oklahoman. Paywall. (Added 7-17-2023)
“Separation was painful for UMC, but our Christian identity is now stronger” Opinion by Bishop Ruben Saenz, Jr. via Dallas Morning News. “Although separation can be painful and bring sorrow, it ultimately helps to clarify and strengthen our Christian identity and witness in the Wesleyan tradition as United Methodists. Our commitment to our historic doctrines remains steadfast, and we strive to unite our personal holiness with God’s vision for a just society.” (Added 7-16-2023)
“Beliefs Matter: GMC Webb” via Maxie Dunnam. A podcast episode featuring Bishop Mark Webb of the Global Methodist Church. (Added 7-16-2023)
“First Church-OKC exit case continues with focus on mission, members and mixed messages” by Carla Hinton via The Oklahoman. “Did regional United Methodist Church leaders plot for months to seize the property of a historic local church and evict its congregation — all in an effort to keep a United Methodist presence in downtown Oklahoma City?” (Added 7-16-2023)
“Problems in the Eastern Pennsylvania UMC Annual Conference (Part 2)” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast. “This segment covers Day 2, during which Bishop Schol strong-armed two initiatives through the body. There are a few bold people in this conference who tried to take the bishop to task! Even so, he seems to have carried the day.” (Added 7-15-2023)
“Can These Bones Live? A Reflection on Methodism Today” by Bishop Forrest Stith via UM Insight. One of my spiritual mentors said, “they are not angry about what they say they’re angry about.” (Added 7-15-2023)
“Additional details set for trial of Bishop Minerva Carcaño” via Western Jurisdiction. “Bishop Alfred W. Gwinn, a retired bishop from the Southeastern Jurisdiction, will preside over the trial. Rev. R. Preston Price, a retired elder in the California-Pacific Annual Conference, will serve as secretary.” (Added 7-15-2023)
“Summer Message from Bishop Laura Merrill” via Arkansas UMC Conference. “I give God thanks and praise for the stories of churches impacted by disaffiliation who are making new, vital, hopeful strides forward.” (Added 7-15-2023)
“Breakaway Methodist congregation in Fayetteville set to hold services at temporary home” by Frank Lockwood via Arkansas Democrat Gazette. “Eventually, the congregation will meet at the Northwest Arkansas Mall in space once occupied by a Sears store, Vaughan said. “We have a remodel team that we’ve put together. We’ve hired an architect, hired a general contractor and are about to begin renovating the Sears property,” he said. (Added 7-15-2023)
“Wyoming churches disaffiliate over disagreements about LGBTQ+ issues” by Jordan Smith via Casper Star Tribune. “Jimmy Crisawn, pastor of Abundant Grace, told the Star-Tribune his congregation was unanimous in its decision to disaffiliate, citing contention with the denomination’s stance on some issues of human sexuality. A layperson from the Pavillion church, who identified herself only by her first name, Suzanne, told the Star-Tribune that the church felt as if the denomination didn’t fully value local churches.” (Added 7-15-2023)
“Beacon of light: First United Methodist Church staying strong in times of unrest” by Bred Doutz via Salisbury Post. “This has caused people all over the country and the world to have to choose between their church and their faith. When first confronted with the idea to disaffiliate, Conforti and the church didn’t think twice about staying with the UMC.” (Added 7-15-2023)
Judicial Council Docket and Timeline fall session via Resource UMC. The docket will be released July 29. (Added 7-14-2023)
“Forecasted trickle of disaffiliations became a ‘wave’” by Steve Jordahl via AFA.net. “Bishops repeatedly – especially a couple of years ago – would say, ‘Oh, it’s just going to be a few hundred churches that are going to disaffiliate.’ And we knew that that was not going to be the case,” Therrell tells AFN. (Added 7-14-2023)
“Surf City Disaffiliation or Eviction?” via Good News. “The Los Angeles Times recently published a comprehensive 2,000 word piece about the excessively costly disaffiliation process for traditionalist United Methodist congregations in Southern California. It is worth reading to gauge the level of turmoil and pain within the denomination-wide schism.” (Added 7-14-2023)
“United Methodists finding their voices as church weathers disaffiliations, ideological crisis” by John Tures via Savanna Morning News. This commentary is written by John A. Tures, a professor of political science at LaGrange College. (Added 7-14-2023)
“United Methodist Church loses 20% of US parishes in ongoing schism” by JP Mauro via Aleteia. “As far back as 2014, Aleteia has reported on the Methodist church in Africa’s fidelity to traditional Christian teaching on sexual behavior, with marriage recognized only as a union between one man and one woman.” (Added 7-14-2023)
“Opinion: Methodist split is sad hour for worldwide organization” by Mac Gordon via Clarion Ledger via Yahoo! News. “A large majority voted to disaffiliate from the old church’s worldwide organization and to go Global. They/Global won. We/United lost. As they say in baseball, you win some, you lose some.” (Added 7-14-2023)
“Liberal UMC bishop faces trial after being placed on leave over complaints” by Michael Gryboski via Christian Post. Summary coverage. (Added 7-14-2023)
“Slouching Toward Disaffiliation” by Richard Bryant via UM Insight. “This struggle is not about us, our buildings, our land, the idolatry of the Book of Discipline, or a denomination called the United Methodist Church. It’s about love. God is about love. That’s the only message to stop the bleeding and save our lives.” (Added 7-14-2023)
“A Pilgrim in a Strange Land: How One United Methodist Found a Home in Moderate Baptist Life” by Justin Addington via UM Insight. “It is no secret that The United Methodist Church is in chaos. Churches are voting to leave the denomination left and right, once healthy congregations are now divided, longtime relationships are being damaged, and good people are being hurt.” (Added 7-14-2023)
“First United Methodist Church splits” via The Pratt Tribune. “Opinions on the present state of Pratt United Methodist Church after a close disaffiliation vote and the state of the congregation’s future all depend on whom you ask.” (Added 7-14-2023)
“Four churches split from United Methodist Church over leftist leanings” by Sarah Grunau via Galveston County Daily News. “Most United Methodist Churches are choosing Global Methodist because there is some structure there that feels like home and what they signed up for,” Hudson said. (Added 7-14-2023)
Tweet via E Julu Swen. “Bishop Samuel J Quire, Jr. sets up a Special Committee to design separation actions for the #UMC Liberia ahead of 2024.” (Added 7-13-2023)
“Congregation Evicted from Jonesboro Church Building – Rev. John Miles” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast. “In this segment, John and I speak about what has transpired, how he would counsel other churches looking at the option of litigation, and how it is that we might be able to pray for his flock.” (Added 7-13-2023)
“Thinking about Mainline Religion” by John Hawthorne via Substack. “At one point in the book, they argue that Methodists are the “mainline of the mainline”. Certainly their analysis of the moderate Protestants rings true with the recent history of the United Methodist Church.” (Added 7-13-2023)
“A Dream of the Future Global Methodist Church – Rev. Beth Caulfield” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast. “Rev. Beth Caulfield has been a leader in the Wesleyan Covenant Association and the Global Methodist Church, even helping to draft a portion of the Transitional Book of Doctrines and Discipline. She has published a whistleblower’s account of the inner working and dynamics of The United Methodist Church in the Greater New Jersey Annual Conference. She is programmatically gifted and finds herself engaged in a mission field that very few pastors have attempted.” (Added 7-13-2023)
“United Methodist Church seeing flood of departures” by Father Joseph Wallace. “Such issues concerning inclusion or exclusion in the name of Christ are causing great consternation in numerous Christian denominations, including our own. But it seems the Holy Spirit is moving the faithful toward settling these issues. Dialogue and discernment, such as the Synod on Synodality in our own denomination, will lead us to greater unity and love.” [Note: some are describing the Synod on Synodality as a regionalization effort in Roman Catholicism.] (Added 7-13-2023)
“It’s time to move forward” via Mainstream UMC. A fundraising letter mentioning WCA, Good News, and IRD. (Added 7-13-2023)
“Beyond the headlines, United Methodists muster new energy for doing good” by Cynthia Astle via Baptist News Global. “What the articles typically don’t tell are the ways in which remaining United Methodists are regrouping, rededicating and forging ahead with ministries that heal themselves and sustain their surrounding communities.” (Added 7-12-2023)
“Why Machen Is Important for the Church Today: A Reflection on Ch. 7 of Christianity and Liberalism (Part 2)” by Gregg Allison via The Aquila Report. “Still, this future of financial/property loss for conservative churches is not set: while decisions about church properties are still a year off in the United Methodist Church, some early signs point to broad (even financial) support for the new GMC.” (Added 7-12-2023)
“Area Churches Make Bold Move: Exodus from United Methodist Church” by Charlotte Reames via Valley Times News. Alabama coverage. (Added 7-12-2023)
“Former United Methodist churches break from denomination” by Kalen McCain via Southeast Iowa Union. “We were just after having more local control over what we can do as a church and where our mission money goes to,” he said. “Through COVID, they told us we couldn’t come to church, and that was really controversial to some people. I think that may have really pushed us in this direction, to where we have that say, not somebody in an office somewhere.” (Added 7-12-2023)
“Progressive, traditionalist link arms” by Sam Hodges via UMNS. “Merrick and Zilhaver…have recently been part of the conference’s Intentional Missional Alignment Process Task Force, an effort to create progressive, traditional and blended “households” for churches and clergy to be part of.” (Added 7-12-2023)
“The July 2023 post Annual Conference season update of the United Methodist Church” by Dalton & Tomich, PLC (YouTube). States the 20% of the churches that left represent over 70% of the UMC’s income. [Editor’s note: I have not heard this number before. I will share documentation if it becomes available.] (Added 7-11-2023)
“Why All the Secrecy Around Church Complaints?” by Jerry Eckert via UM Insight. “In Bishop Carcaño’s case, both sides have done an amazing job of keep things confidential. If anything like it occurred before, it was so successful that I never heard of it in my forty plus years of observing personnel practices.” (Added 7-11-2023)
“Why Did I Leave The Church I Love?” by Herb Flanders. “It was never my desire to leave. In fact, I really wanted a brass Circuit Rider clergy grave marker on my tombstone one day. Not any time soon, mind you, but some day. And I tried my best to be faithful to my vows as both a member of The United Methodist Church and as a clergy person.” (Added 7-11-2023)
“Wisconsin’s oldest Methodist congregation closes due to high bills, low turnout. It’s a familiar story nationwide.” by Sophie Carson, Milwaukee Journal Sentinel (Yahoo! News). Overheard about this: “This article is about a long-time liberal activist congregation in downtown Milwaukee that is closing. I’m not sure it is really Wisconsin’s oldest Methodist congregation. Milwaukee has long been the place where theologically liberal pastors were assigned, and many of the churches have closed or are in severe decline.” (Added 7-11-2023)
“INTEL FROM THE IVORY TOWER: United Methodists, Better Together” by John Tures via Pagosa Daily Post. “No, my marriage is fine… as well as those of my relatives. As for my church family, it’s another matter. But there are some recent encouraging signs that show there’s hope for many in the United Methodist Church.” (Added 7-11-2023)
“Sorting Out America’s Religious Climate” by Riley Case via Juicy Ecumenism. “Our nation, more than ever before, needs strong churches. Many of us who live both in the evangelical world and in the mainline world pray for revival.” (Added 7-11-2023)
“Pastor warns churches hoping to leave UMC over ‘errant theology’ face ‘draconian demands’” via Christian Post. “A California pastor says his church — one of many churches looking to disaffiliate from the United Methodist Church due to its ongoing debate over homosexuality — could end up being evicted or forced to pay millions to keep their building.” (Added 7-11-2023)
“A Mission is Not a Mausoleum” by Jay Therrell via WCA. “We don’t have to become the Museum of Methodism. We can once again be the mission that we were created to be. We simply must turn towards Jesus and ask the Holy Spirit to empower us to become those disciples once again.” (Added 7-11-2023)
“If I Were on Suspended Bishop’s Defense Team…” by Jerry Eckert via UM Insight. “If I were on Bishop Minerva Carcaño’s defense team, I would be pushing at least one major task for the team: providing the presiding bishop for the trial with all of the objections to fair process and all related acts that have occurred to bring the case to trial.” (Added 7-10-2023)
“Renfroe: Time for Methodists to Go Separate Ways” by Rena Mainetti via Juicy Ecumenism. “Renfroe argued that the differences between United and Global Methodists run deeper than sexuality. Instead, they are connected to the cardinal doctrines of the faith—the Trinity, the divinity of Jesus, and his death and physical resurrection as the propitiation for our sins. Renfroe explained that progressives—including bishops and pastors—view these doctrines as nonessential to the Christian faith.” (Added 7-10-2023)
Post by Andrea Vaughn via Facebook. “Sandia Fellowship GMC, in Albuquerque, NM, will have its first service on July 23. This is a new church, and I am so encouraged at how things are going. The group, including the pastor, that has been working on this has obviously done lots of work. The church will be meeting in a movie theater…” (Added 7-10-2023)
“The United Methodist Church has lost 20% of U.S. congregations in schism over LGBTQ rules” by Peter Weber via The Week. “More than 6,180 United Methodist congregations in the U.S. have been granted permission to leave the denomination in a schism that began in 2019 over the role of LGBTQ Methodists in the church and other theological issues, according to an unofficial tally kept by UM News. (Added 7-10-2023)
Post by Warren Lathem via Facebook. “The Sawnee Ridge Global Methodist Church is an example of folks who could not even discuss disaffiliation due to appointive manipulation by the former bishop of North Georgia… when the Sawnee Ridge congregation leaders met to define their vision of the future, the “first thing on the board” was a partnership with a Spanish language ministry. And God dropped this relationship in their laps. Yesterday I introduced pastors Tito and Yami to the Sawnee Ridge Congregation.” (Added 7-10-2023)
“Saving the Institution but Losing the Soul – The Fount Account” by Glen Haworth via The Fount UMC. “In our disaffiliation from the UMC journey, we have run up against a LOT of institutional mindsets, mindsets that regard the life of the institution (in this case, the annual conference) as of primary importance, even over against the life of the congregations seeking disaffiliation.” (Added 7-10-2023)
“Thousands Of Methodist Churches Flee Denomination Over LGBTQ Rift, Splinter Issues: What’s Going On?” by Billy Hallowell via Christian Post. A Inside Story podcast interview with Michael Gryboski who has been covering UM Fallout for The Christian Post. (Added 7-10-2023)
Post by Lonnie Brooks via Facebook. An Alaska lay leader shares his petitions to General Conference now that the process has been opened as July 1, 2023. (Added 7-10-2023)
Post by Mary Lou Reece via Facebook. “Beautiful, spirit filled launching of the Covenant Provisional Conference of the Global Methodist Church with 500 at ordination service this morning! God showed up among these lovely people this weekend! “Breaking through…” With Scott Jameson Jones Luther Oconer” [Photos] (Added 7-9-2023)
“Missouri pastors face ‘heartbreaking’ splits in Methodist churches over LGBTQ issues” by Ethan Colbert via St. Louis Post-Dispatch. “It is heartbreaking that it has come to this, because this was not an amicable split,” Just said. “There are hard feelings and people pointing fingers on both sides, and so people are grieving what they feel is a tremendous loss.” (Added 7-9-2023)
“Springfield’s Schweitzer Church among 75 in Missouri parting with United Methodist Church” by Greta Cross via Springfield News Leader. “Seventy-five churches in Missouri disaffiliated from the United Methodist Church last month, including Schweitzer Church in Springfield and a few others in the Ozarks region.” (Added 7-9-2023)
“Special E-Mail from Trey” by Trey Skaggs via St. Paul’s Ocean Springs (Mississippi). “I wholeheartedly affirm the Discernment Team’s Recommendation that the best possible future for St. Paul exists apart from the United Methodist denomination.” See also here. (Added 7-9-2023)
Tweet via Reconciling Ministries Network. “In some areas, United Methodists have designated “lighthouse” or similarly named congregations, with a mission for receiving members who wanted to stay United Methodists but whose churches were leaving.” [link] (Added 7-8-2023)
Tweet by Jeremy Smith @UMJeremy: “The SBC had the chance to be truly evangelical and reach a whole new generation by removing anti-women policies. They failed. May the #UMC learn from their mistake and be bold on inclusion of LGBTQ+ persons, removing barriers to evangelism and sharing the love of Jesus Christ.” (Added 7-8-2023)
“Moral Concerns for Those Disaffiliated” by Jeffrey Rickman via Substack. “I’m asking that we resolve to learn to fight well. To be fair, but to be firm. Let’s build something worth protecting upon the foundation of Christ himself, something that stands the trying fires of history and lasts to all eternity…” (Added 7-8-2023)
“Problems in the Eastern Pennsylvania UMC Annual Conference (Part 1)” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast (YouTube). “The Eastern Pennsylvania Annual Conference held their annual gathering recently and it, like many other conferences within the United Methodist Church, had its fair share of issues. From the Bishop pushing past opposition to a full on physical altercation between attendees, the splintering of the United Methodist Church was on full display. We go over a few of the instances in part of this installment.” (Added 7-8-2023)
“UMC Has ‘Tremendous Urgency’ to Regionalize its Structure” by Mark Holland via UM Insight. “Now with 20% of US Churches disaffiliating from the UMC, the remaining U.S. constituents will bear an even greater financial imbalance with fewer than 50% of the votes at future General Conferences. Again, the U.S. church is willing to fund mission and ministry around the world, but why should it fund a governance structure that is actively harming the remaining 80% of U.S. churches?” (Added 7-8-2023)
“Beyond Binary” by Sarah Imhoff via UM Insight. “Rabbinic texts illustrate that there is no magical time in the past when every person fit easily and naturally into gender categories.” (Added 7-8-2023)
“Settlement finalizes split for Methodist congregation in Searcy” by Frank Lockwood via Arkansas Democrat Gazette. “The settlement, Jackson said, contained non-disclosure and non-disparagement provisions, but the signs out front telegraph the outcome. The word “United” has been removed — from the building, from the vans, from the $35,000 electronic message board that twinkles out front. The congregation is now known, simply, as First Methodist Church.” (Added 7-8-2023)
“A church split: Northwest Iowa Methodists deal with differing views over sexuality” by Peggy Senzarino via Sioux City Journal. “There’s really one side to this issue. Are we willing to be faithful in what Jesus called us to do or are we going to play some theological game where we pull out certain scripture passages and those are more important that the humanity and divinity of Jesus? We didn’t do that,” he said.” (Added 7-8-2023)
“Wesley Methodist Church disaffiliates over national church’s decisions on same-sex marriage” via Sioux City Journal. “The Rev. Todd Schlitter talks about Sioux City’s Wesley United Methodist Church’s disaffiliation from the United Methodist Church of the church’s decision to allow the ordination of homosexuals and the consecration of same-gender marriages. The church is now affiliated with the Global Methodist Church and is now named Wesley Global Methodist Church. With Schlitter is Tylene Woods, the church’s administrative council chairwoman.” See also here. (Added 7-8-2023)
“Oklahoma City church files lawsuit amid disaffiliation fight with United Methodist Church” via KOCO. Local news coverage with video interviews. (Added 7-8-2023)
“From a judge’s rejection to $30M in assets: First Church United Methodist’s day in court” by Carla Hinton via The Oklahoman. “The trustees of First United Methodist Church of Oklahoma City on Friday made some headway in their disaffiliation pursuit when a judge rejected the Oklahoma United Methodist Conference’s request to toss the church’s lawsuit out of court.” (Added 7-8-2023)
“Former United Methodist church adjusting after disaffiliation” by Jasmine Youngblood via KPSD (Kentucky). “The congregation says their beliefs don’t align with the United Methodist denomination anymore, and they want to keep their legacy intact.” (Added 7-8-2023)
“Frederick County churches disaffiliate from United Methodists; others sue regional conference” by The Frederick News-Post (MD)/Yahoo News. “Salem United Methodist Church in Myersville and Ebenezer United Methodist Church in Ijamsville are two of 23 churches that the Baltimore-Washington Conference — which includes hundreds of churches across Maryland, Washington, D.C., and West Virginia — approved for disaffiliation at its annual conference in June.” (Added 7-8-2023)
“22 Southern California churches plan to break off from United Methodist amid LGBTQ+ dispute” via KCAL. “The money would be paid to the United Methodist Church of Southern California. In an email, Reverend Sandra Olewine, who oversees The Fount, explained that a church doesn’t own its property and if there is a disagreement over homosexuality, a particular church has the option of buying the property for 50 cents on the dollar.” (Added 7-7-2023)
“Tally shows thousands of U.S. congregations leaving United Methodists” by Tobin Jacobson via World. “As of the end of June, over one-fifth of United Methodist congregations in America have been granted disaffiliation from the denomination. More than 6,000 of the denomination’s roughly 30,000 member congregations have left, by the count of United Methodist News Service.” (Added 7-7-2023)
“Engaging an African Bishop” by Tom Lambrecht via Good News. “We call upon all bishops and institutional leaders to allow gracious self-determination by their members, whether in the U.S. or Africa or other parts of the world. Only free and informed decision-making by members will result in a church that is unified in a mission and vision for the future.” (Added 7-7-2023)
“‘Sparkle Creed’ is Dim and Dull” by Mark Tooley via Juicy Ecumenism. “There will always be “sparkle creeds” trying to displace more traditional creeds like the Nicene and Apostles Creed. Supposedly those ancient creeds are restrictive impositions, demanding that we believe what we really logically can’t. But they have endured for millennia because they claim a transcendent permanence outside of ourselves.” (Added 7-7-2023)
“Centerville church joins congregations leaving UMC” by Jack Brammer and James Scogin via The Kentucky Lantern. “The change is in more than the name and is a sign of a schism among congregations and denominations. The United Methodist Church (UMC) has split between UMC and Global Methodist Church, which launched in May. Among the differences are how each views sexuality.” (Added 7-7-2023)
“Thousands of US United Methodist Churches Split from Denomination over LGBTQ Issues” by Ireland Walker via Daily Caller. “More left-wing Methodists have anticipated a proposal modifying the church law to permit same-sex marriage and the ordination of LGBT individuals at the following General Conference in 2024 as a result of these departures, the AP reported.” (Added 7-7-2023)
“Meet Bishop Cedrick Bridgeforth” via UM Communications. The UMC’s second openly gay bishop is interviewed for the “Get Your Spirit in Shape” podcast. (Added 7-7-2023)
“Five Reasons for Regionalization” by Mark Holland via Mainstream UMC. “A two-thirds (2/3) majority of the U.S. church voted at the 2019 General Conference for cultural contextualization through the One Church Plan. It was telling that eighty percent (80%) of the delegates from outside the U.S. declared, through their support of the Traditional Plan, that they are unwilling to allow the U.S. jurisdictions the same cultural contextualization they enjoy.” (Added 7-6-2023)
“United Methodists have lost one-fifth of their congregations as the denomination continues theological drift to the bottom of the sea” via Not the Bee. “Fortunately, it seems a good number of United Methodists have figured out that the denomination is spiraling hell’s toilet since 1-in-5 congregations have jumped ship since 2019.” (Added 7-6-2023)
“Methodist disaffiliation vote fails” via The Humboldt Independent (Iowa). “While a clear majority, 117 members of those in attendance, voted yes to disaffiliating from the United Methodist Church, it did not reach the two-thirds or 66.6 percent criteria, failing by nine votes.” (Added 7-6-2023)
“Over 6,000 United Methodist congregations voted to leave the denomination over LGBTQ+ issues” by Isabelle Butera via USA Today. “One-fifth of United Methodist congregations in the United States have received permission to leave the denomination over disagreements over same-sex marriage and gay preachers.” (Added 7-6-2023)
“Episode 132: Young Pastors in the UMC” via Pod Have Mercy Podcast (Chapelwood UMC, Houston). “Today we are joined by Rev. DeAndre Johnson, Rev. Lindsay Kirkpatrick and Rev. David Horton. We talk about their experiences as young clergy, why they remain in The United Methodist Church and their hopes for the future!” (Added 7-6-2023)
“Ministering To Sexually Damaged People – An Interview With Garry Ingraham” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast (YouTube). “Garry Ingraham is the Executive Director of Transforming Congregations and the Director of the Love & Truth Network. Garry is passionate about local churches being places of authentic transformation for sinners. He is spending his life equipping churches to do such ministry.” (Added 7-6-2023)
“United Methodists lose one-fifth of US churches in schism driven by growing defiance of LGBTQ ban” by Peter Smith via Associated Press. New national coverage. (Added 7-6-2023)
Post by Warren Lathem via Facebook. “When I have often stated that the division which has resulted in 20% of the congregations of the UMC leaving via an onerous and expensive process called paragraph 2553 is essentially a divide over core theological issues in the denomination, most often the rebuttal has been, “Nothing has changed in the Book of Discipline.” That is precisely the point….” (Added 7-6-2023)
Post by Robert Phillips via Facebook. “A rumor is spreading…that the GMC gamed the system so that numerous clergy announced at the last minute that they were leaving for the GMC, stranding churches without pastors (this passed to me by a pastor curious to know if there was any truth to this). I said no. No GMC national conspiracy, no local tactics. Reality check: would pastors under appointment with assured salary-benefits-retirement suddenly leave it all for a system with no guaranteed appointment, deliberately wounding themselves and their families as well as the flock they tended…all out of spite? (Added 7-6-2023)
“Norwegian Methodist priest can perform same-sex marriage” via CNE News (Northern Europe). “The decision of the Norwegian branch of the church is, therefore, “an attempt to create room for action within the current church law”, Refsdal says. The General Conference is to look at the issue next year. However, if it holds onto the traditional view of marriage, not allowing gay weddings in church, the Norwegian Methodist Church may secede from its mother church, the priest warned earlier.” (Added 7-6-2023)
“First Methodist Church in Shreveport votes on affiliation with Global Methodist denomination” by Johnette Magner via KTBS (Louisiana). “It’s something to be really on the ground, at the forefront, of what I would call a new Methodism and movement of the Holy Spirit,” said Steven Bell, senior pastor at First Methodist. “And to go ahead and make this decision. Make it now, and be a part of the early days of the Global Methodist Church is something that is very, very exciting.” (Added 7-6-2023)
Tweet by Diane Butler Bass: “Sadly, fear is driving the ecclesial bus now. That means more hyper-clericalism, gatekeeping & hardening of dogma. This is the wrong way to engage decline. Most religious institutions won’t do anything except try to protect themselves-thus ensuring their own irrelevance & demise.” (Added 7-6-2023)
“Northern Illinois Global Methodist Update” by Scott Field via Northern Illinois WCA. Lists the Northern Illinois GMC Churches. “The Inaugural Session of the Great Lakes Provisional Annual Conference of the GMC will be October 27-28, 2023, at Crossroads Church (GMC) in Washington, Illinois (adjacent to East Peoria). All are welcome to join the anticipated 700+ clergy, lay members, and interested friends for a joyful, inspiring, and encouraging time to learn, worship, strategize and network. Over 80 new Deacons and Elders will be ordained.” (Added 7-6-2023)
“As trial date set, bishop reflects on ministry” by Heather Hahn via UMNS. “The Western Jurisdiction’s website announced that the church trial to adjudicate complaints against [Bishop Minerva G. Carcaño] is scheduled Aug. 21-25. Other details are pending. Carcaño is facing five charges under the Book of Discipline’s Paragraph 2702.1, which lists the denomination’s chargeable offenses.” See also “Pastoral Message from Bishop Sally Dyck.” (Added 7-6-2023)
“Which megachurch became the second OKC church to be sued to pull out of United Methodist?” by Sylvia Quaries via BusinessNews. “In a prepared statement, leaders of the Oklahoma United Methodist Conference said they are disappointed by the Church of the Servant’s decision to take the unaffiliation cases to district court. Like their situation with a similar lawsuit filed by the First United Methodist Church of Oklahoma City, regional leaders said the courts had no role in church matters.” (Added 7-5-2023)
“Next Steps for United Methodism” by Sally Stewart via UM Insight. “Some of the new folks were from nearby UM churches that had disaffiliated leaving groups of people who wanted to #StayUMC. Stories like these are popping up all over, bringing a renewed sense of hope to those affected by the splintering of the denomination. One commenter reflected “I really think we’ll all be better for it.”” (Added 7-5-2023)
“6,182 US Churches Have Exited United Methodist Church in LGBT Rift” by Steve Warren via CBN News. “We think it is highly likely at the General Conference in 2024 that the definition of marriage will change, that the ordination standards will change and that most of the traditional provisions we’ve passed in recent years will be repealed,” Therrell said. (Added 7-5-2023)
“Megachurch becomes second OKC church to file lawsuit seeking United Methodist exit. Here’s why.” by Carla Hinton via The Oklahoman. “In their petition, the trustees of Church of the Servant claim Oklahoma United Methodist Conference leaders have been playing “cat and mouse games” to keep the congregation from moving forward with the process to end their church’s denominational affiliation.” (Added 7-5-2023)
“Bouncing forward as African United Methodists” by Bishop Mande Muyombo via UMNS. “Most episcopal leaders in Africa have vowed that The United Methodist Church will continue in Africa, even after our next General Conference, which was postponed to 2024. Most African bishops have resolved not to support any proposed legislation that calls for dividing or dissolving The United Methodist Church, a denomination that continues to engage in evangelism, health care, education, food security, leadership, peace and justice, as well as environmental issues.” (Added 7-5-2023)
Post by Steve West via Facebook. “I have been a spokesperson for staying UMC in this season when some have been discerning whether to secede from our denomination or remain in the main body… Now that I have finished the last speaking engagement on my calendar, I feel compelled to share my most recent presentation with you here. [video] (Added 7-5-2023)
Post by Jack Harnish via Facebook. “So evidently in some conferences, the WCA/GMC advised pastors to wait until after annual conference to tell their congregations they were exiting the UMC, leaving the congregations hanging and the Bishop and cabinet with open appointments. Crude. Dishonest. Deceitful. I can respect clergy who choose to withdraw because of their convictions about sexual ethics when they did it appropriately through the clergy session. But this….” (Added 7-5-2023)
Church of the Servant Files Suit Against the Oklahoma Conference. Information on a July 3 court filing.(Added 7-5-2023)
Tweet via John Wesley’s New Room. The historic chapel built by Wesley in Bristol is bedecked with pride flags for a Rainbow Service before a Pride March. (Added 7-5-2023)
“Did Cormac McCarthy Write the Sacrifice of Isaac?” by Richard Bryant via UM Insight. UM clergy on Genesis 22: “A god, the Canaanite sky god El, the divine power we call God, or any god who asks for this extreme demonstration of a follower’s faith and devotion is cruel and sadistic. I’m not sure one can see it any other way. For centuries, preachers, pastors, and scholars have tried to put lipstick on this pig.” (Added 7-5-2023)
“Rev. Dr. Young Jin Cho Joins Global Methodist Church and is Designated Bishop Emeritus” by Walter Fenton via GMC. “The GM Church, just over a year old, has welcomed nearly 3,000 local churches and received over 3,200 clergy members. During its transitional season the TLC is guiding the denomination prior to its convening General Conference, slated for the fall of 2024. The Council designated Cho as bishop emeritus in the light of his service as a pastor, district superintendent, and bishop in The United Methodist Church, and for his steadfast proclamation of the Wesleyan expression of the Christian faith.” (Added 7-5-2023)
“Pastor appointed for Oneonta UMC” by Audrey Borden via the Blount Countian. “With support from existing United Methodist Churches and the North Alabama Conference, the church is close to meeting the requirements for being chartered and will formally apply to do so within the next month.” (Added 7-5-2023)
“Global Methodist, United Methodist Churches Split on Nicene Creed” by John Lomperis via Juicy Ecumenism. “The Global Methodist Church is committed to the historic Christian faith of the Nicene Creed, while the United Methodist Church is not committed to the Nicene Creed.” (Added 7-5-2023)
“Sparkle Creed Religion” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast (YouTube). “Last week, footage of a new creed was shared with the Internet, in which a congregation confesses a gospel outside of the one entrusted to the saints. More concerning in this worship service was the children’s sermon, which used a non-biblical Jesus to justify a way of life that stands against authentic Christianity.” (Added 7-4-2023)
“Freedom Isn’t Free” by Jay Therrell via WCA. “In our current season of struggles helping as many churches as possible to break free while we simultaneously helping to build the Global Methodist Church, I could see parallels all over the place. So many laity and clergy have made significant sacrifices so they could break free from a system that we feel mistreats us and honors us only with words but few deeds.” (Added 7-4-2023)
“Huntington Beach, Fountain Valley congregations fight to stay open amid schism over LGBTQ+ stance” by Eric Lycas via LA TImes [paywall]. The LA Times picked up this story from the Daily Pilot (no pay wall). (Added 7-4-2023)
“The Constitutional Episcopacy of The United Methodist Church” by Mitchell Lewis. “It is our structure that led to the situation we are in now.” (Added 7-3-2023)
“UMC congregation forcibly closed before it could disaffiliate sues to reopen” by Michael Gryboski via Christian Post. “The congregation wants to remain open and continue with the disaffiliation process just as thousands of other UMC churches nationwide have been able to do in the last couple of years amid a longstanding debate over the denomination’s stance on sexuality.” (Added 7-3-2023)
“Adam Hamilton Urges: Stay United Methodist” by Rena Mainetti via Juicy Ecumenism. “In a recent podcast series, Andy Miller of Wesley Biblical Seminary separately interviewed two opposing voices from the Methodist tradition—self-described centrist Adam Hamilton and traditionalist Robert Renfroe—to discuss the present state of Methodism and its future.” (Added 7-3-2023)
Post by Ulysis Ambucay via Facebook. “The Global Methodist Church Philippines had victoriously launched July 1, 2023 lead by Bishop Scott Jones. We have over 1,000 delegation from all over the country overflowing the Samsung Hall, SM Premier. There are a hundred churches who have joined and planning to join this vibrant movement from Luzon alone, added to that are the churches from Visayas and Mindanao. More than 100 clergies (newly ordained elders and deacons, transferred elders, Lay Supply Pastors, transferred deaconesses, senior status and Lay Ministers) had been commissioned!
Glory to God!” [photos] (Added 7-3-2023)
“Trinity on the Hill (Augusta) Has Joined the Global Methodist Church” via TrinityontheHill.net. A prominent North Georgia congregation joined the GMC on June 27. (Added 7-3-2023)
“Disaffiliations affecting churches who stay United Methodist” by Brian Ferry via The Times Observer (Warren, PA). “So, there were some things that needed to be seen to as far as pastoral support over the churches that remained,” he said. “A new charge was made for Russell and Sugar Grove. There is also a new charge being made for Youngsville, Lottsville, and Chandlers Valley.” (Added 7-3-2023)
“Opinion: Methodist Church schism is reminiscent of divide over slavery” by Joy Watts via Akron Beacon Journal. “The Rev. Ken Price tells us that his church is leaving because of a “strict belief in the teachings of the Bible.” Those Methodists who left because the church wouldn’t accommodate slaveholders said the same thing. The same sentiments that motivated those Methodists so many years ago motivate them today.” (Added 7-2-2023)
“Congregations to disaffiliate from Methodist denomination” by Sawyer Belair via Lincoln Journal Star (Nebraska). “I’m not happy, to be honest,” said Farias, who has been involved with the church since he was a 15-year-old living Farias in Mexico. “God doesn’t want this to happen … the division, the discord, the disagreements.” (Added 7-2-2023)
“Huntington Beach, Fountain Valley congregations fight to stay open amid schism over LGBTQ+ stance” by Eric Licas via Daily Pilot. “Surf City Church in Huntington Beach, the Fount in Fountain Valley and numerous others whose congregations disagree with the California-Pacific Conference of the United Methodist Church’s inclusion of the LGBTQ+ community into its leadership want to leave the organization, but say they’re being held ransom.” (Added 7-2-2023)
“Bishop Counting Sheet” via Mississippi Conference (UMC). File includes total votes for and against affirming each of the 189 Mississippi disaffiliating church. Percentages range from 86% to 95%. (Added 7-2-2023)
“What Does It Profit a Christian to Protect an Institution but Lose Their Soul?” by Russell Moore via Christianity Today. “What seems to be popular in this moment is not so much a prosperity gospel as a depravity gospel. In this depravity gospel, appeals to character or moral norms are met not with appeals of “Not guilty!” but with dismissals of ‘Get real!'” (Added 7-1-2023)
“How the UMC is Actually, Really, Literally Racist” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast (YouTube). “…there are some serious ways in which The United Methodist Church reveals a low view of nonAmerican people. The institution is unavoidably ethnocentric, to the marginalization of the majority world church… The majority of the content in this segment comes from Odell Horne’s “De-Centering Whiteness in Methodism.” (Added 7-1-2023)
“Former United Methodist churches face first Sunday since split” by Caitlin Herrington via Post & Courier (Greenville, SC). “Come this weekend, more than 100 congregations across South Carolina who had “United Methodist Church” in their name will have their first Sunday services no longer under the denomination’s umbrella.” (Added 7-1-2023)
“There Are Many Reasons For United Methodist Split” by Rosanna Kingsley via Post-Journal. “Jeff Winton’s article “Disappointed with Disaffiliation” sadly misrepresents the true reason for several churches in Chautauqua County leaving the United Methodist Church. The LGBTQ+ is not the main reason for disaffiliation.” (Added 7-1-2023)
Post by Mary Lou Reece (spouse of Bishop Jones) via Facebook. “Launch party for the GMC in the Philippines, around 1000 in attendance! The Holy Spirit was definitely present! They were organized, prepared and spirit led! With Scott Jameson Jones and Luther Oconor and a host of lovely Filipinos who are anxious to serve and grow.” [photos] (Added 7-1-2023)
Global Methodist Church Launch in Philippines via Facebook Videos: Session One with Bishop Scott Jones (ordination), Afternoon Session, Session Two Overheard: Bishop Scott Jones is in the Philippines for the launch of the GMC there. (Added 7-1-2023)
“Great Lakes Conference Welcome Letter” via Great Lakes Provisional Conference (GMC). Includes a welcome packet with a church list, clergy list, leadership lists, as the conference “goes live” on July 1, 2023. (Added 7-1-2023)
Post via GMC Philippines Facebook Page. GMC Philippines Launch: “See you on July 1, 2023, Saturday, from 8AM to 4PM, at the Samsung Hall in SM Aura, BGC, Taguig City!” (Added 6-30-2023)
“The Best and Worst of Disaffiliation” by Tom Lambrecht via Good News. “Local churches are at the mercy of the bishop and annual conference leaders. Those leaders can choose to act graciously and honorably, like Bishop Alsted did – and some have. Or they can choose to act punitively and arrogantly, like the leaders in North Carolina – and some have.” (Added 6-30-2023)
“A Season for Renewal and a Joint Commitment to our Worldwide Connection” by Greg Bergquist and Roland Fernandes via GMHEM of the UMC. GBHEM and GBOM heads: “During this season, we and our general agencies vow to work together to support our worldwide connection as we move towards the future, open our mind, spirit, and body to God, and unite in our faith in Christ as well as our heritage of the Wesleyan and Methodist spirituality.” (Added 6-30-2023)
“Trinity United Methodist says goodbye to pastor” via The Daily Courier (PA). “Following the finalization of Disaffiliation from the United Methodist Church on June 14, that was held at General Conference in Erie, PA TUMC will now be known as Trinity Methodist Church of Scottdale and will be a part of The Global Methodist Church.” (Added 6-30-2023)
“Compilation of United Methodist False Teachings by Top Denominational Leaders” by John Lomperis via Juicy Ecumenism. False teaching catalogs from UM bishops, seminaries, agencies, and clergy. (Added 6-30-2023)
“Ethnic Minorities & The Hope of the Future GMC with Rev. Mao Her” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast (YouTube). “Rev. Mao Her was the first Hmong clergy in The United Methodist Church. Though she served in a very liberal annual conference (Wisconsin), she did not feel the dysfunction of the UMC until the 2019 General Conference. It was at that time that she signed on with the Wesleyan Covenant Association, now serving as the Coordinator for her area. She has led her church through the disaffiliation process and is now serving the Global Methodist Church in her area on her TCAT. Rev. Her is a model of boldness and faithfulness.” (Added 6-30-2023)
“Blessing in a Schism” by Brian Kaylor via Word & Way. “Other UMC conferences have similarly utilized a “parting rite” during meetings in recent months as they reflected on their past time of shared ministry and their familial relationship even as they choose divergent future ministry paths. So this issue of A Public Witness attends multiple disaffiliation blessings to consider a different model for denominational partings.” (Added 6-30-2023)
“Discernment” via Riverchase UMC (Birmingham, reported membership 2,686). “On June 25, 2023, the Board of Stewards voted 40 to 12 in favor of accepting the recommendation of the Discernment Team to disaffiliate from the United Methodist Church and join The Foundry Network. We will contact the North Alabama Conference to set a date for a congregational vote regarding disaffiliation.” (Added 6-30-2023)
Post by Andy Oliver via Facebook. “Dear UMC clergy and laity: Last week, two of our clergy colleagues in Mississippi, who officiated the wedding of two non-binary persons, were forced into a deal to avoid a church trial that involved them taking an involuntary leave of absence. The resolution of this was in no way “just.” One of the clergy will not be impacted financially because she is a deacon at a non-profit. The other clergywoman will miss a year’s salary and not be allowed to do any work that is clergy related, which makes it very difficult to find work to support your family. We need to step up and make sure she receives no loss of income for her prophetic service…” (Added 6-30-2023)
“The United Methodist Church” via Wikipedia. The article on the UMC has been updated to include a section called “2000-2022 Schisms.” (Added 6-30-2023)
“St. John’s Disaffiliation Is Official” by Katherine Parker via The Greenwood Commonwealth (MS). “The church voted 130-23 in favor of the disaffiliation. It will join the Global Methodist Church beginning Saturday.” (Added 6-30-2023)
“Judge signs church possession order” by Keith Inman via The Jonesboro Sun (AR). “In keeping with a decision announced last week, a judge signed an order filed Thursday night that temporarily gives possession of First United Methodist Church of Jonesboro to the Arkansas Conference of the United Methodist Church.” (Added 6-30-2023)
“Convocation 2023: Onward to Perfection” via Reconciling Ministries Network. “John Wesley encouraged Methodists toward perfection in the lifelong pursuit of love. Love looks like affirmation in the face of persecution, like kinship in the face of isolation, and like courage in the face of despair. It is in that spirit that we’re gathering on October 13-15 at First United Methodist Church in Charlotte, NC.” (Added 6-30-2023)
Post by Jimmy Boone via Facebook. “This [map] is from Liam Adams, a reporter in Tennessee. He does not include West Virginia and South Carolina as they did not disaffiliate under #2553.” (Added 6-30-2023)
Tweet by Mark Tooley: “Prediction: In 10 yrs United Methodism & new Global Methodist Church will each have about 1.5 million members in USA.” (Added 6-29-2023)
“WCA Press Release on the Fifth Avenue Lawsuit” via WCA. Information on a Wilmington, NC congregation’s fight to stay open after being closed before they could disaffiliate. (Added 7-3-2023)
“During Pride Month, My Church Conference Passed a Stunning Resolution” Bebe Nicholson via Medium. I also dislike the wording in the Book of Discipline about homosexuality. To say that Christian teachings are incompatible with homosexuality seems radical and dismissive of an entire group of people. However, the radical progressivism in our church and the wording of the resolution that passed at the North Georgia Conference concerns me even more. It’s not only a movement to incorporate gay and lesbian ordination and marriage, but a movement that could ultimately take us far beyond this.” (Added 6-29-2023)
“Tennessee United Methodists look to rebuild amid UMC splintering, disaffiliating churches” by Liam Adams via The Tennessean. “Facing national tides of shrinking congregations and denominational turmoil, Tennessee United Methodists are tightening their belt in some areas and expanding programs in others.” (Added 6-29-2023)
Tweet by Mark Tooley: “Christianity is not in “crisis.” But dying progressive Protestantism has been for long time. “Sparkle Creed” is just latest hiccup.” Link [More on the sparkle Creed controversy here. ](Added 6-29-2023)
“After the split, United Methodists assign clergy, familiar face for new church” by Greg Garrison via AL.com. “Jones, who was the youth minister at Lester Memorial for seven years, decided to stay with the denomination and help with the new church start.” (Added 6-29-2023)
“Over 6,000 UMC churches granted disaffiliation amid schism over homosexuality” by Michael Gryboski via Christian Post. National Christian coverage of disaffiliations crossing the 6K mark. (Added 6-29-2023)
“Conservative vs. Progressive Visions for the UMC Part Two with Rob Renfroe” by Andy Miller III via More to the Story Podcast. “These conversations have been heavy because they represent important issues for our time. Denominations are at a crossroads. Today I finish with a conversation with Rob Renfroe who is the president of Good News for United Methodists.” (Added 6-29-2023)
Overheard: With 998 churches approved via the online system since May 5 and another 177 in process, the Global Methodist Church has 2,585 churches, give or take. (Added 6-29-2023)
“Disaffiliations approved by annual conferences” via UMNS. This updated tally of 6,182 reflects the close of the regular annual conference season. 22 special sessions are scheduled from August though December. (Added 6-29-2023)
“A Tale of Judicial Dysfunction: Updates on the UMC Immune System” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken. “Each annual conference in the UMC is expected to oversee processes around the filing of charges against clergy who work against the doctrine and discipline of the denomination. There is a longstanding effort among progressive activists to use this system to simultaneously waste money and change the norms of the covenant body.” (Added 6-29-2023)
Overheard: Mississippi Bishop Sharma Lewis quote from the Service of Blessing and Anointing (following the disaffiliation vote: “In the current time I will uphold the Book of Discipline, and I have also said that if and when the Book of Discipline changes I will work for us to continue to work in harmony and abide by those changes— and I know some people don’t like that.” (Added 6-29-2023)
“Disaffiliation Announcement” via Wayneboro Methodist Church (YouTube). A Mississippi pastor announces the completion of the disaffiliation process and calls the church to the Free Methodist Church. (Added 6-29-2023)
“UMC claims Dothan church broke internal law by disaffiliating, records” by WDHN (AL) (YouTube). “The United Methodist Church is firing back at Harvest Church after a Houston County judge denied their motion to dismiss Harvest’s lawsuit.” (Added 6-29-2023)
“Lawsuit filed to keep Fifth Avenue Methodist Church open” by Brenna Flanagan via Port City Daily (Wilmington, NC). “The congregation of a two-century old Methodist church in downtown Wilmington is fighting back after it was suddenly closed in March.” (Added 6-29-2023)
“New name, same tradition at Amazing Grace Church” by Catherine Minolli via Tri-CIty Times (Michigan). “Formerly known as Imlay City United Methodist, Amazing Grace Church of Imlay City is now affiliated with the Global Methodist Church. The official change takes place on July 1, says longtime Pastor Dr. Marcel Lamb.” (Added 6-29-2023)
“HLUMC to become Houghton Lake Global Methodist Church” by Krista Tasey-Cater via The Houghton Lake Resorter (Michigan). “Houghton Lake United Methodist Church will take on a new name soon as Pastor Kevin Harbin said the church he leads has chosen to disaffiliate with the United Methodist Church.” (paywall). (Added 6-29-2023)
“A profound question as Kansas Methodists take different paths: How do we care for one another?” by Dave Kendall via Courier Traveler. “I’m sure that those who have chosen to disaffiliate have done so with the belief that it’s a righteous response based upon their interpretation of Christian doctrine as conveyed by their scriptures. But does it reflect the “judge not” values of their faith and the examples provided by their messiah?” (Added 6-29-2023)
“Commentary: Amid struggles, American churches still have reason for hope” by Bill Like via The Roanoke Times. “When I consider the current state of the so called “united” Methodist church, I believe chiggers in wild blackberry vines are more united as they attack an unsuspecting blackberry picker.” (Added 6-29-2023)
“Methodist schism: See how the vote went for the 189 MS churches wanting to leave UMC” by Ross Reily via MS Clarion Ledger. “Mississippi United Methodist Conference‘s eligible voters unanimously agreed to ratify the disaffiliations of 189 member churches from across the state. That allows them to move on to any other denomination or Methodist offshoot. Most, however, have suggested they will affiliate with upstart Global Methodist Church.” (Added 6-28-2023)
“Oklahoma United Methodist leaders ask judge to toss First Church’s lawsuit” by Carla Hinton via The Oklahoman. “The Oklahoma United Methodist Conference is arguing the First United Methodist Church of Oklahoma City’s lawsuit should be thrown out because the court has no jurisdiction over church disaffiliation matters.” (Added 6-28-2023)
Post by Leah Hidde Gregory. “Central Texas Conference special called conference… November 4th.” [Image of letter by Bishop Saenz] (Added 6-28-2023)
“Bishop Scott Jones Welcomes Missouri to the GMC” via via WCA Missouri YouTube. A welcome message to Missouri churches. (Added 6-28-2023)
“Local United Methodist Church takes legal action against conference after closure” via WECT. “Fifth Avenue United Methodist Church in Wilmington has announced that it is taking legal action against the North Carolina Conference of the United Methodist Church (UMC).” (Added 6-28-2023)
Post by Jimmy Boone via Facebook. “We are now at 6,186, a little over 20% of the 30,000 original total of U.M. Churches in the US.” (Added 6-28-2023)
“Discerning the Signs of the Times & Family Ministry – A Conversation with Rev. Daniel Hixon” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast. Topics include “what went wrong with the UMC” and “why disaffiliate now?” (Added 6-28-2023)
Disaffiliation Moment via Mississippi Conference (UMC) YouTube. Starting at 12:00, an emotional Bishop Sharma Lewis leads the conference in a service of blessing during disaffiliation. (Added 6-28-2023)
Overheard: The Mississippi Conference approved all 189 churches for disaffiliation this morning. Bishop Lewis was described as gracious while remaining committed to the UMC. (Added 6-28-2023)
Post by Samuel Padgett via Facebook. “This is a map that I have compiled to help people know the Provisional Annual Conferences (PACs), the Transitional Conference Advisory Teams (TCATs), and regions not fully organized. It is not official but it will help people know who to reach out to.” (Added 6-28-2023)
“Sowing in Tears, Reaping in Joy” by Walter Fenton via GMC. ““It’s as if we traded a building for a mission, and for a much deeper faith,” said Matthews. “While we have an immense amount of work to do, there is an easiness to it, a lightness I have never known before in my life in ministry. In a way, we are just having fun! When we gather, there is a deep joy that we all feel. We know who we are and what we are about, and we know the Lord is with us!” (Added 6-28-2023)
“United Methodist Church split one step closer to fruition” by Vicki Hyatt via The Mountaineer. “Methodists in North Carolina moved full speed ahead be a fully inclusive church where discrimination of all kinds will not be tolerated during an annual gathering at Lake Junaluska earlier this month.” (Added 6-27-2023)
“Estonian churches leave United Methodist fold” by Heather Hahn via UMNS. “The 23 United Methodist churches in the Baltic nation of Estonia are leaving the denomination to form the independent Estonia Methodist Church… The four Eurasian annual conferences’ departure will need the approval of General Conference, the denomination’s top lawmaking assembly now scheduled for April 23-May 3, 2024. Their departure won’t be finalized until 2025.That means the eight delegates from those conferences will be among those voting at the coming General Conference.” (Added 6-27-2023)
“Helping First Church” via Oklahoma WCA E-mail. “The Oklahoma WCA believes strongly in supporting churches who want to disaffiliate but who have hit roadblocks through no fault of their own. We are supporting First Church with our prayers, but we also want to help with their legal expenses. To that end, we are announcing a $15,000 matching grant for the First Church OKC Legal Fund.” (Added 6-28-2023)
Post by David Housholder via Facebook. “Cal-Pac just unilaterally seized the church preschool bank accounts of Surf City Church (SCC) in Huntington Beach, California. An excellent Christian preschool which is vital to the neighborhood; and has a waiting list. The traumatized preschool director is not sure how to make payroll. Ultimate goal of Cal-Pac is to ensure that SCC gets closed (they never let them vote on disaffiliation) so they can sell the property to a developer and pocket the money.” (Added 6-27-2023)
Post by Paige Swaim-Presley via Facebook. One of the Mississippi pastors involved in a recent just resolution for officiating a same-sex wedding writes an “unrelated” post. (Added 6-27-2023)
“Inertia is Deadly” by Warren Lathem via Facebook. “United Methodist Churches in North Georgia have a choice to make regarding the one opportunity that now exists to leave the denomination. Yet many are locked in inertia. Stuck. This will prove deadly to many if they do not actively pursue the options open to them.” (Added 6-27-2023)
“Kid’s Pride” event via Ravenswood Fellowship UMC Facebook Page. The QR code links to the Northside Kid’s Pride Event in Chicago. (Added 6-27-2023)
“Holy history: Gay pastors confirmed into senior positions they were once denied” by Jamie Guirola via NBC Miami. “A church divided went against the rules and confirmed three gay pastors to senior positions — positions they were once denied just a year ago because of their sexuality.” (Added 6-27-2023)
“Synod questions: Do Cardinal Hollerich’s beliefs affect his actions?” by Terry Mattingly via Get Religion. Is the “Synod on Synodality” an effort by Western Catholic bishops to regionalize Catholic moral teaching on human sexuality? (Added 6-27-2023)
[updated] The Forged Network of Churches (DOC). “Forged exists to network new and existing independent Wesleyan churches and leaders for greater kingdom impact.” See also “The Forged Network John Tanner tells us about this network and his church” via First Methodist Church of Hartselle, AL. Tanner is the pastor of Cove Church in Owens Cross Roads, Alabama. This “hub” network exists under the larger umbrella of the Foundry Network for the state of Alabama. Asbury Madison and Cove are the AL Foundry churches sponsoring the Forged Network.(Added 6-27-2023)
“Vicarious Joy, Actual Distress” by Glen Hayworth via WCA. “But in my annual conference, the California-Pacific Annual Conference, there is little joy and quite a bit of distress. Twenty-two local churches in Cal-Pac have voted to disaffiliate, yet not a single one has been given the approval of the conference. Primarily because one of the provisions established by the conference board of trustees, in addition to the provisions of paragraph 2553 of the Book of Discipline, is that the local church pay the conference the equivalent of 50% of the property value of the church and parsonage(s).” (Added 6-27-2023)
Tweet by John Lomperis: “The #UMC ‘s official GCFA agency produced a list of the top-100 American #UnitedMethodist congregations in 2020 membership. Now, at least 25% of these have left the denomination.” (Added 6-27-2023)
“How and Why: Becoming Nokesville Methodist Church” by Jeff Brown via Juicy Ecumenism. “As the only church thus far from the Northern Virginia District of the UMC to disaffiliate, I am hopeful that our church growth will be aided by new membership coming from other churches who have not allowed discussion of the issues, of which there appear to be many.” (Added 6-27-2023)
“Nearly 200 congregations in Mississippi look to leave the United Methodist Church” by Frank Corder via Magnolia Tribune. “The Mississippi Conference of the United Methodist Church is holding its annual conference in Tupelo. Clergy and delegates from across the state will be voting to allow just under 200 congregations to leave their fold. The disaffiliating churches make up roughly 22% of the 852 United Methodist Churches in Mississippi.” (Added 6-27-2023)
Post by Jason Woolever via Facebook. “Very excited that our church, Crossroads GMC, will host the Convening Conference of the Great Lakes Provisional Annual Conference on October 27th and 28th of this year. There will be hundreds of GMC pastors and lay delegates from Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, and Wisconsin in attendance. As of right now, there are 73 people prepared for ordination as new GMC pastors.” (Added 6-27-2023)
Post by Jim Parkinson via Facebook. “After disaffiliations 466 churches remain within the Western Pennsylvania Conference of the UMC. The average worship attendance of the remaining churches is 33 and the median is 20. (The average worship attendance of the 298 churches that are disaffiliating is 45 and the median is 28.) Only 19 (4.1%) of the remaining churches worship >100 per week. 72 (15.4%) of the remaining churches worship 10 or less a week. 361 (77.4%) of the remaining churches worship 35 or less a week. (Added 6-27-2023)
“United Methodist Church loses more congregations, including some from Colorado, over same-sex marriage schism” by Debbie Kelly via The Gazette. “An exodus from the nation’s second-largest Protestant denomination over disagreements about human sexuality, abortion, Christian doctrine and biblical authority is continuing, with approval of 38 congregations in Colorado, Montana, Wyoming and Utah to disaffiliate from the United Methodist Church.” [Photo shows Korean-American UMC that is departing]. (Added 6-27-2023)
“UMC conference with lesbian bishop approves disaffiliation votes of 38 congregations” by Michael Gryboski via Christian Post. “A Colorado-based conference of the United Methodist Church led by a bishop in a same-sex marriage has approved the disaffiliation votes of 38 congregations leaving the denomination amid a schism over the denomination’s stance on homosexuality.” (Added 6-27-2023)
“DISAFFILIATION: Porters Chapel United Methodist Church joins Eagle Lake and Redwood” by Terri Cowart Frazier via The Vicksburg Post. Mississippi coverage. (Added 6-27-2023)
Overheard: From a Mississippi clergy on the announced just resolution: “We were scheduled to vote tomorrow affirming their suspension in clergy session. I imagine that is no longer on the agenda. Rev. Davidson was not serving a local church so this doesn’t impact her much. Rev. Swaim-Presley had been briefly serving a local church when she was suspended, but she and her (also clergy) husband are moving to the Virginia Conference, so I don’t know how much it affects her either.” (Added 6-26-2023)
For Immediate Release via The Mississippi Conference (UMC). “Today we share that a Just Resolution has been reached and that Reverends Davidson and Swaim-Presley are on involuntary leave for a period of 18 months and 12 months, respectively, during which they shall not perform the duties of a Deacon or Elder as outlined in Paragraphs 329 and 340 of The Book of Discipline.” (Added 6-26-2023)
Overheard: The season of regular annual conferences concludes this week with Mississippi (189 churches being considered for disaffiliation). Twenty-one special called sessions begin on August 5 and conclude again with Mississippi on December 9. (Added 6-26-2023).
“Disaffiliation Update 2023… In Case You Missed It!” via St. Luke’s Community UMC (YouTube). An update from a large Dallas-area African American congregation. (Added 6-26-2023)
“First Church OKC Disaffiliation Attempts Hindered” by Traditional Methodist Voices of Oklahoma (YouTube). “Historic First Church OKC is attempting to disaffiliate from the Oklahoma Annual Conference of the United Methodist Church. The leadership of the conference has decided to slow down and stall this process however, with deadlines looming for disaffiliation the only route First Church OKC felt would resolve the issue was litigation.” (Added 6-26-2023)
“First Church OKC Disaffiliation Attempts Stymied” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoke Podcast (YouTube). “Pastor Jeffrey was able to sit down with Hardy Patton, Vice Chair of the trustees board to bring to light what has been going on with this historic church in the middle of downtown Oklahoma City.” (Added 6-26-2023)
“Disaffiliation Ratification by Annual Conference In Compliance with the new 2016 Discipline Paragraph 2553” via Mississippi Conference (PDF, see page 32).Lists 189 churches by district coming before the June 27 regular session. (Added 6-26-2023)
“Do Clergy Really Need High Academic Degrees?” by Robert Hunt via UM Insight. “The second and more radical point is that higher education across-the-board must be rethought. The idea that degrees are necessary to the preparation of persons or ministry must be abandoned. The Master of Divinity degree is declining because it is seen as irrelevant.” (Addd 6-26-2023)
“Many Nebraska Congregations Leaving United Methodist Church” via Lincoln Journal Star (Paywall). “Factions are clashing in a disaffiliation movement in the United Methodist Church over the denomination’s approach to sexuality, but the conflict has played out somewhat differently in the Great Plains.” (Added 6-26-2023)
“Manchester United Methodist Church Changing Name” by Janelle Tucker via KMCH (Iowa). “Starting Saturday, they’ll officially be a Global Methodist Church known as Manchester Methodist Church. Pastor Rogers says it’s been a difficult process, but they’re excited about joining something new.” (Added 6-26-2023)
“Kentucky Methodists tally congregations lost to LGBTQ rift as a conservative alternative grows” by Jack Brammer via Kentucky Lantern. “The exodus of Kentucky Methodists was confirmed earlier this month when delegates to the Kentucky Annual Conference of the United Methodist Church approved requests from 286 churches to leave the denomination that was formed in 1968. About 80 churches had already left in recent years.” (Added 6-26-2023)
“Disaffiliations effective November 30, 2023” via Iowa Conference (UMC). Deadlines and information for the upcoming round of disaffiliation. (Added 6-26-2023)
“Eight Regional Churches Look toward Future Away from United Methodist Church” by Sarah Readean via The Toledo Blade. “These congregations join 80 churches that disaffiliated last year. More than 700 United Methodist churches remain in the conference, according to Bishop Gregory Palmer…” (Added 6-26-2023)
“New United Methodist ministers reveal why they’re excited for the denomination amid rift” by Carla Hinton via The Oklahman. Comments from new OK ordinands in the UMC. (Added 6-26-2023)
“After exit of more than 100 churches, Arkansas Methodists plan for leaner future” by Frank Lockwood via Arkansas Democrat Gazette. “We all know that we look different than we did a year ago and, accordingly, our structure and our finances have to change as well,” Brittany Watson, president of the conference’s Council on Finance and Administration, told attendees at the conference’s annual meeting Wednesday. (Added 6-26-2023)
“Methodist schism hits boiling point this week in Mississippi. See the churches leaving” by Ross Reily via Mississippi Clarion-Ledger. “The 189 churches have completed the required steps to leave the denomination and are seeking ratification to disaffiliate will be voted on individually in 10 ballots. Results will not be released until results of all 10 ballots are in.” (Added 6-26-2023)
“Several congregations in Nebraska among those leaving United Methodist Church” by Sawyer Belair via Lincoln Journal Star. “That all changed when Pastor Jaime Farias gave the official news 10 minutes into the service: the congregation, along with 155 others across Kansas and Nebraska, had been approved for disaffiliation from the United Methodist Church during a regional conference held over Zoom on May 31. The crowd of 20-some churchgoers erupted into enthusiastic applause.” (Added 6-25-2023)
“United Methodist churches see 6 disaffiliations; 2 stay” by Rebekah Wallace via Corry Journal (PA). “Corry First and EUM are joining the newly formed Global Methodist Church, but Brown said not all of the disaffiliating churches are doing that. They may join other Methodist traditions like the Wesleyan Church, or not be any denomination at all.” (Added 6-25-2023)
“Methodist Church Disaffiliation & Revitalization” via GoFundMe. First UMC in New Hampton, IA starts a Go Fund Me page to raise money for disaffiliation costs. (Added 6-25-2023)
Post by Becky Rivers via Facebook. Shares a letter by Bishop Wallace-Padgett and cabinet about North Alabama Conference support for changing church teaching on marriage: “We also know the media coverage of this resolution may bring emotional reactions and questions from your congregation.” (Added 6-25-2023)
“North Alabama Conference of United Methodist Church approves resolution urging the removal of restrictions on homosexuality” by Allen Keller via 1819News.com. “By a vote of 236 to 151, the North Alabama Conference of the United Methodist Church voted to remove language regarding restrictions on homosexuality from the Book of Discipline, its governing document.” (Added 6-25-2023)
“Opinion: Methodists Clean House” by Leonard Hitchcock via Idaho State Journal. A retired professor who looks forward to the day when “the average American regards local churchgoers as ‘slightly weird’,” congratulates the United Methodists for “cleaning house” of traditionalists. (Added 6-25-2023)
“Better Together: A Third Way” Website. A unity effort as the Christian Reformed Church moves toward its General Synod. (Added 6-24-2023)
Tweet by John Lomperis. “The number of #GlobalMethodist or soon-2-be GMC congregations in North Carolina already exceeds those of AMEs + Wesleyans + Nazarenes + Free Methodists COMBINED” (Added 6-24-2023)
Overheard: “What this doesn’t say with regard to Searcy is that the Arkanas Annual Conference settled the lawsuit with Searcy First Methodist Church. It is reported that Searcy First Methodist paid in the neighborhood of $300K plus signed over possession of a parsonage and a non-member made a small contribution for an undisclosed amount. Had they ratified the disaffiliation agreement back in November the AC would’ve received $394K.” (Added 6-24-2023)
Post via IRD Facebook Page. “ATTENTION all friends of any conservative or moderate United Methodists in Upstate New York! It is not too late to join the mass exodus of conservative and moderate congregations from the new, liberalized United Methodism. Spread the word to faithful United Methodists you know.” [included a map of disaffiliated churches] (Added 6-23-2023)
“Court rules in church’s dispute” by Frank Lockwood via Northwest Arkansas Democrat Gazette. “The Jonesboro church, which had voted 69% to 31% to leave the denomination, filed suit on Dec. 19 after a special session of the denomination’s Arkansas Annual Conference refused to ratify their disaffiliation agreement.” (Added 6-24-2023)
“Methodist Churches to vote on possible disaffiliation” via The Humbolt Independent (Iowa). “Members of Faith United Methodist Church (FUMC) of Humboldt County are invited to a special church meeting on June 29, 6 p.m. to vote on whether their congregation should continue to be connected to the United Methodist Church.” (Added 6-23-2023)
“Bishop totaled her Prius, compares it to United Methodist church split” by Greg Garrison via AL.com. “It’s been hard but we’ve come through that with grace and strength,” she said. “It has impacted our perspective.” (Added 6-23-2023)
“Statements on Legal Cases: Jonesboro and Searcy” via Arkansas Conference (UMC). ““We are pleased with the Court’s ruling, and we look forward to immediately restoring the use of these properties for the benefit of all members of The United Methodist Church denomination, including the hundreds of faithful members of First United Methodist Church of Jonesboro,” said Rev. Dr. Ruben “Tony” Griffin, Chair of the Board of Trustees…” (Added 6-23-2023)
“Listener Questions: Part Two” via Firebrand Podcast. At 6:40, there is a question answered about the role of bishops in the GMC. (Added 6-23-2023)
“More than Sexuality: What is Really at Stake in the United Methodist Church” via Amor Dei. “The concern is over more than human sexuality. While an important issue in its own right, the most concerning issue at hand is whether the church will possess the keys to the kingdom of heaven or the keys to Pandora’s Box.” (Added 6-23-2023)
“United Methodists urge repeal of ban on same-sex marriage, openly gay clergy” by Greg Garrison via AL.com. “United Methodists meeting in the North Alabama Conference on Friday voted to call for the upcoming international meeting of the denomination to drop all mention of homosexuality from the Book of Discipline, the book of church law.” (Added 6-23-2023)
Post by Warren Lathem via Facebook. North Georgia analysis. (Added 6-23-2023)
Post by Jimmy Boone via Facebook. “Updated June 23: We are now at 5,991 [disaffiliations]. Mississippi has 189 on the docket next week. By July 1 projections show we will see a total of 6,180! I have alphabetized all 2023 Disaffiliations except the most recent….” (Added 6-23-2023)
“SBC and United Methodist news: Where are America’s two largest Protestant flocks heading?” by Richard Ostling via Get Religion. “Any way you slice it, a large global evangelical denomination with easily a million members, or far more, is being born.” (Added 6-23-2023)
Post by Jimmy Boone via Facebook: “Mountain Sky has just completed voting and approval of 38 churches. Give a great shout out to Karen Oilveto who said “We are here to bless these departing churches.” She was extremely gracious. After the vote they had a time of lament, but it was not negative of the departing churches. (Added 6-23-2023)
Post by Jason Eric Sutfin via Facebook. Extended thoughts on the Jonesboro First suit. (Added 6-23-2023)
Overheard: You can read a bit of the Denver Post article by Noelle Phillips on the UM Schism in Colorado here. The main article is behind a pay wall. (Added 6-23-2023)
“Church of the Lakes, others leave United Methodist Church over LGBTQ+ clergy, other issues” by Charity Goshay via The Canton Repository (OH). “If you talk to my bishop, she’ll talk about the issue of human sexuality,” George said. “If you talk to myself and some of my colleagues, we’re gonna emphasize things like authority of Scripture and accountability to our covenant which, from our standpoint, has been an issue.” (Added 6-23-2023)
“Wesley United Methodist Church disaffiliation” by Tim Hynds via Sioux City Journal (IA). “The congregation is one of the 11-percent of Methodist churches in the state that have decided to disaffiliate from the denomination of due to disagreements over the Iowa Annual Conference of the UMC’s decision to permit same gender marriage and ordination of LGBTQ members.” (Added 6-23-2023)
“First United Methodist Church-Montgomery continues to seek ways to disaffiliate despite rule change” by Craig Monger via 1819News. “The head pastor of FUMC was missing from the meeting, as congregants said he was more sympathetic to staying in the UMC, despite the congregation’s desires.” (Added 6-23-2023)
Post by Brad Elrod via Facebook. A video clip of a sermon by Bishop Laura Merrill at the Arkansas Conference. “The voices that have tried t break down this body…” (Added 6-23-2023)
“Judge rules in Methodist property dispute” by Keith Inman via The Jonesboro Sun (AR). “The church group formerly known as First United Methodist Church of Jonesboro will no longer be in control of its century-old building, as of Aug. 1, a special judge ruled late Thursday. Judge Gary Arnold said the real estate at 801 S. Main St. will be in the temporary control of the statewide governing body for the United Methodist Church, pending the outcome of a full-blown trial, scheduled for Jan. 24.” (Added 6-23-2023)
Post by Jay Clark via Arkansases STAYing United Facebook Group. Lots of comments about the ruling that gives that minority STAY group possession of the building on August 1, 2023. (Added 6-22-2023)
“Judge issues ruling over ownership of Jonesboro’s First United Methodist Church” via KAIT. “According to interim Pastor Britt Skarda, the judge ruled the church property belongs to the First United Methodist Church and a group of members who are a part of a group known as Stay FUMC will be able to return to the property.” See also coverage from Fox19 and WIFR. (Added 6-22-2023)
Overheard: The Baltimore-Washington Conference has filed a motion to dismiss lawsuits from churches with supporting affidavits from Bishop Easterling & Conference Chancellor Tom Starnes. (Added 6-22-2021)
“Hotel Cal-Pac, Where You Can Never Leave” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast. “…there was a great showdown at Cal-Pac Annual Conference a few days ago by those petitioning with clear conscience to renegotiate the disaffiliation agreement. The bishop’s response was resoundingly clear and emblematic of the UMC institution as a whole. Take a few minutes to see excellent modeling of pastoral non-anxious presence, coupled with brusque power politics. While those disaffiliating didn’t carry the day, they definitely stand on the side of right.” (Added 6-22-2023)
“Letter to the editor: Explaining the Methodist splist [sic]” by David Scandrol via The Tribune-Review (PA). “Wesleyan theology would have that those who believe in a new life in Christ are first called to be holy in conduct.” (Added 6-22-2023)
“Alaska Conference Says: Regionalize, Reform, Restructure” by Lonnie Brooks via UM Insight. “The bad news is that next year if the General Conference does not do these three things, it will be seen in history as being a total failure.” (Added 6-22-2023)
“‘It’s a New Day in North Texas’” by Eric Folkerth via UM Insight. “There appears to be great joy that we are moving past a painful few years of disaffiliations, where church members were sometimes pitted against one another, and where bald-faced lies were told about the future of the United Methodist Church (and even about some of us personally!).” (Added 6-22-2023)
“OPINION: How widespread is disaffiliation from church bodies?” via McDonald County Press. An Arkansas editorial. (Added 6-23-2023)
“Ogallala feels new spirit after vote to stay UMC” by David Burke via Great Plains Conference (UMC). “This is the second in our series about churches in the Great Plains that survived disaffiliation votes.” (Added 6-22-2023)
“Bishops called to renew church amid rupture” via UMC.org. “The denomination is experiencing an upheaval unlike any that these leaders have experienced in their lifetimes, as they deal with a mounting number of disaffiliations under a church law that allows U.S. congregations to leave with property if they meet certain procedural and financial requirements.” (Added 6-22-2023)
“More than 30 Colorado congregations to leave United Methodist Church in rift over gay marriage, clergy” via The Denver Post (paywall). “The 38 churches filed petitions for disaffiliation, citing “reasons related to human sexuality” as the basis for their departure. They represent about 10% of …” (Added 6-22-2023)
“Great Lakes Conference E-News” via GLC GMC. News on the formation of a conference covering Illinois, Michigan, Indiana, and Wisconsin, approved to form July 1 with 173 churches. (Added 6-22-2023)
“Bishop Carter’s Reflections with the 2023 Clergy Session of the Western North Carolina Conference of the United Methodist Church” via Western North Carolina Conference. “We will be a bit smaller, but more focused. Some of what we have lost is a kind of purging. To complete the hard work we have done is for the sake of people we have singled out for exclusion, and for generations of people we are not reaching. We are not going back.” (Added 6-21-2023)
“Living Our Wesley’s Covenant Prayer in Dickinson” via Dakotas Conference (UMC). UM News featured this post-disaffiliation story. (Added 6-21-2023)
“Just How Bad is Denominational Decline?” by Ryan Burge via Ministry Watch. “The mainline is just a bloodbath. Five traditions are down by at least 30%. The ELCA is down 41%. The United Church of Christ is less than half the size it was in the late 1980s. The United Methodists are already down 31%, but with over 15% of their churches disaffiliating just this year, I wouldn’t be surprised in membership is down 40% or more by this time next year.” (Added 6-21-2023)
Post via Friends of the GMC Facebook Group. “The attached letter was sent out by a UMC pastor to their congregation in the NC Conference following last week’s Annual Conference. The UMC institutionalists are doing their best to spin this blatant violation of the Book of Discipline….” (Added 6-21-2023)
“Toward a GMC Episcopacy” by Chris Ritter via PeopleNeedJesus.net. Thoughts on the future shape of the episcopacy in the Global Methodist Church. (Added 6-21-2023)
“Episode 61: “Living the United Methodist Way of Life Through “Unrelenting Grace” with Bishop Kenneth Carter, (Part 1)” via Be Encouraged with Julius Trimble Podcast. “Orthodoxy should be generous and include everyone with God’s grace at its heart. Wesley didn’t think anyone was outside of the reach of God’s grace, making him a great evangelist. The speaker believes in the importance of the Scriptures, creeds, and hymns, and has a high view of Scripture and believes in the articles of religion.” (Added 6-21-2023)
“The United Methodist Church in 2023: Congregations Leaving and the Future of the Church” via Ministry Answers. “The future of the UMC is uncertain. The denomination is currently undergoing a reorganization, and policies can be changed at the next General Conference in 2024. The creation of the Global Methodist Church has no bearing on the existing policies of the UMC, which are set by its General Conference.” (Added 6-21-2023)
“PCUSA Presbytery Separation-Dismissal Policies” via The Layman. A compendium of presbytery level gracious separation policies. (Added 6-21-2023)
“What’s dividing the United Methodist Church? Core beliefs over LGBTQ issues, biblical authority” by F. Amanda Tugade via The Des Moines Register. “Byrd said religious divides caused by warring beliefs aren’t uncommon. Still, he’s never heard of a denomination that created an “organized” disaffiliation process — let alone one that includes a sunset clause.” [Note: the PCUSA has similar Gracious Separation processes.] (Added 6-21-2023)
“Eight churches seek disaffiliation with UMC convention” via The Voice. Northern Illinois: “Earlier this year, 18 churches expressed interest in disaffiliating. Ten of these took the step of taking a church-wide vote on the decision. Eight have signed disaffiliation agreements.” (Added 6-21-2023)
“The Global Methodist Church in Central and Eastern Europe” by Bishop Mark Webb via GMC. “As the Global Methodist Church continues to grow and mature, our sisters and brothers in Bulgaria and Slovakia are demonstrating a boldness and commitment to the mission and purpose of the Church. They are providing leadership that is shaping our movement.” (Added 6-21-2023)
“Bishop Fairley: There is more to United Methodists than the debate over human sexuality.” via Courier-Journal (op-ed). “Our remaining members are ready to step into a new reality with a leaner, nimbler desire to “Show the Love of God” – which just happened to be the theme of our 2023 gathering. As United Methodists, both clergy and nonclergy, we are called to serve as disciples of Jesus Christ for the transformation of the world.” (Added 6-20-2023)
Post by Charles Emery via UM Clergy Facebook Group. “As we emerge from the season of disaffiliation and begin to seek an answer to what now, we must face the shadow side of our denominational persona as United Methodists. There are dangers that lurk in our group shadow as pointed out by Jungian scholar Ann Belford Ulanov…” (Added 6-20-2023)
“By the Numbers” by Jay Therrell via WCA. “By the end of June, we expect to be approaching 6,000 disaffiliated churches which will represent approximately 20% of the denomination in the United States.” (Added 6-20-2023)
Tweet by Reconciling Ministries Network. “Ruth Marston-Bihl, one of the writers of our upcoming intersectionality VBS, brings our Pride blessing for this week.” (Added 6-20-2023)
Tweet via Reconciling Ministries Network: “Congratulations, Rev. Charles Daly: the first-ever out and partnered LGBTQ+ candidate ordained by the North Carolina annual conference! Rev. Daly currently serves as the Associate Pastor of Epworth UMC in Durham, NC.” (Added 6-20-2023)
Tweet via Reconciling Ministries Network: “In July, we’re relaunching Reconciling Clergy: an extension ministry that serves active and retired clergy or clergy candidates.” (Added 6-20-2023)
“Clarifying Conversations on the Future of Methodism” via Sun Creek UMC (Allen, TX). Discernment information and videos. (Added 6-20-2023)
“Thousands of congregations leave United Methodist Church over LGBT stance” via International Family News. “Members fed up with liberal indoctrination.” (Added 6-20-2023)
“Local Methodist churches splitting off over LGBTQ+ issues” by Jonathan Shipley via WiscNews.com. Wisconsin coverage. (Added 6-20-2023)
“Remaining United Methodists look to religious life after disaffiliations” by Julia Maruca via TheTribLive.com (PA). Bishop Moore-Koikoi: ““It’s friends, family, persons that were formerly part of my cabinet that are leaving,” she said. “Churches that I’ve preached in, churches that I’ve gone to their apple dumpling festival and been a part of their ministry, we’ve worked alongside each other in mission work. … There are some personal relationships that will be different now. I’m hoping that we still will be in a relationship, but it will be different.” (Added 6-20-2023)
Overheard: This Thursday June 22, there will be a fourth hearing in Jonesboro, Arkansas. At the end of this hearing, it is anticipated the judge will make a decision, as to who will be given temporary use of the facilities until the trial, which is scheduled for January of 2024. (Added 6-19-2023)
Floor Speeches via Cal-Pac Conference. At 15:47, there are two floor speeches requesting the conference to reconsider its requirement of 50% property value to disaffiliate. The bishop rules a motion out of order and offers a prayer. [The trustees report (page 60) states that twenty churches are seeking disaffiliation.] (Added 6-19-2023)
“As United Methodist church splits, local churches welcome like-minded congregants” via Randolph Record. Asheboro coverage: “The splintering — often grievous and tense — has spurred new initiatives to provide havens for the unmoored.” (Added 6-19-2023)
“Is There Hope for Methodism?” by Riley Case via Juicy Ecumenism. “The faithful remnant in the UM Church has its work cut out for it. There must be some strong voices for reform. Can this happen?” (Added 6-19-2023)
“The Breakup of the United Methodist Church” via Uncensored Pilgrim Podcast. “The UMC is losing over 5000 member churches over the “rainbow issue”. But is that their biggest problem?” (Added 6-19-2023)
“5 theologically conservative denominations that allow women to serve as pastors” by Michael Gryboski via Christian Post. The GMC is #5, along with Assemblies of God, The Christian & Missionary Alliance, Evangelical Covenant Order of Presbyterians, and Evangelical Presbyterian Church. (Added 6-19-2023)
“Regrouping in the Wake of Disaffiliation” by Paul Nixon via Discipleship Ministries. July 20 event: “With respect to forming churches in the wake of disaffiliations, we should expect an additional season (Grieving), to occur near the front end of the planting journey.” (Added 6-19-2023)
“Column: Suppose they held a schism and nobody left” by Randall Balmer via Valley News (New Hampshire). Episcopal Priest: “Methodists along with most Southerners and nearly all Americans came to recognize the sin of slavery. So too most contemporary Methodists understand that the biblical mandate to love God and neighbor applies to everyone.” (Added 6-19-2023)
“No More Eggshells” by Mark Holland via Mainstream UMC. “The United Methodist Church does not believe the Bible is black-and-white. We do not have a black-and-white theology. In the secular world, we call this gray; in the church, we call this GRACE.” (Added 6-19-2023)
“Holy Hex” Prayer via Facebook. A video clip of Derek Kubilus’ prayer at the 2023 East Ohio Annual Conference. The full and original video was removed by the conference. (Added 6-18-2023)
“Florida Conference of the United Methodist Church Approves Ordaining Gay Clergy” by Anne Stych via Ministry Watch. “The die is cast. We’ve crossed the Rubicon. It’s done. There’s no turning back,” said Larry Rankin, a retired minister who was at the meeting. (Added 6-18-2023)
“The Baggage of Hope” by Brad Davis. “Reflections of a Newly-Ordained Elder on the Future of United Methodism.” (Added 6-18-2023)
“Why Join the GMC?” by Chris Morgan via Centenary Methodist Church (Vimeo). A message to disaffiliated churches about considering the GMC. (Added 6-18-2023)
“‘Ministry to all’: Williamsport-area Bishop presents information about Global Methodist Church” by Pat Crossley via Williamsport Sun-Gazette. “About 70 people, many of them pastors or elders at churches which had chosen to disaffiliate with the United Methodist denomination, gathered recently to learn more about the Global Methodist Church (GMC) as a possible alternative for their congregations.” (Added 6-18-2023)
“‘Difficult work’: Nearly 300 churches in Pennsylvania leave UMC over homosexuality debate” by Michael Gryboski via Christian Post. ““It has been challenging spiritually, intellectually and emotionally. These persons before you were here for such a time as this,” stated Moore-Koikoi. “Because of their deep spirituality, their deep faith, because of their trust in God, they were able to carry out this painful process.” (Added 6-18-2023)
“Indiana’s Grace Church splits with United Methodist Church” by Patrick Cloonan via The Indiana Gazette. (paywall). (Added 6-18-2023)
“United Methodist Church in Kentucky losing congregations to rift over LGBTQ inclusion” by Jack Brammer via Kentucky Lantern. “To further highlight that Seddon was leaving the United Methodist Church, light red paint was used to obscure the word “United” on the awning over the church’s front door. It now reads “Seddon Methodist Church.” Also, a large metal cross with a flame — the symbol of the United Methodist Church — was removed from the church and its van.” (Added 6-18-2023)
“In Penn’s Woods: Disaffiliation” by Michael Hartley via The Corry Journal (PA). “Nearly all the mainstream denominations, UMC among them, seem nonplussed that society no longer much seeks their counsel. Many politically-minded Christians, whether they attend a mainstream church or not, seem frustrated, even angry, that society seems no longer chiefly informed by Judeo-Christian tradition.” (Added 6-18-2023)
“Queering Jesus: How It’s Going Mainstream at Progressive Churches and Top Divinity Schools” by John Murawski via RealClearInvestigations. “These examples from this year and last are just a few illustrating how progressive churches are moving beyond gay rights, even beyond transgender acceptance, and venturing into the realm of “queer theology.” (Added 6-18-2023)
“Thoughts On the United Methodist Schism” via Men of the West. “Basically, in a denomination where the Traditionalists and the Progressives could agree on nothing, the moderates boldly capitulated every step of the way, abandoning the denomination’s fealty to the Scripture and their own Book of Discipline along the way. Proudly sticking their heads in the sand – after all THEIR church wasn’t like those kooky Progressives. And THEIR church was so much more accepting than those bigoted right wingers. But in the end, they may as well have just decked their halls with gay pride flags and invited a drag queen in to give the children’s moment.” (Added 6-18-2023)
“Louisiana Delegates Approve Petition to Create LGBTQIA+ Ministries Team” via Louisiana Conference. “The petition was submitted by Caleb Porter, director of music ministry and organist at First United Methodist Church in Hammond, who gave delegates a heartbreaking description of the ways in which the Book of Discipline says he cannot serve in the United Methodist Church.” (Added 6-17-2023)
“Order of the Day with Rev. Adam Hamilton” via North Carolina Conference. “His vision for the future of The UMC is mission-driven rather than conflict-driven. He gave several examples of how the loss of churches through disaffiliation is leading to exceptional growth in churches remaining United Methodist and the birth of many new faith communities.” (Added 6-17-2023)
“United no more, local Methodist clergy speak on decision to split” via Ground News (paywall). “Some United Methodist churches are officially splitting up after years of being apart. The decision coming out of the Western PA United Methodist Conference (WPAUMC) The Glenwood Methodist Church is one of 298 churches to be voted out at the annual conference.” (Added 6-17-2023)
“Why Global Methodist?” by Jeff Pospisil via Ten Minute Treasurer (YouTube). A ten-minute answer to why a church should consider the GMC over independent status. (Added 6-17-2023)
“Disaffiliation Begins For Some Methodist Churches” via The Post-Journal. “There are dozens of similar cases on state Supreme Court dockets throughout New York state amid a nationwide movement of some 3,500 U.S. congregations that have received their local conferences’ permission to disaffiliate from the United Methodist Church, according to United Methodist News Service via a recent Associated Press report.” (Added 6-17-2023)
“United Methodist pastor in Alabama-West Florida Conference: Disaffiliation rule change ‘really just unfair’ to churches that trusted bishop, conference leadership” by Will Blakely via 1819News.com. “Reverend John Blount of St. Andrew United Methodist Church in Panama City, Fla. questioned the integrity of the United Methodist Church’s (UMC) Alabama-West Florida Conference (AWFC) leadership at this week’s annual conference.” (Added 6-17-2023)
“Conservative vs. Progressive Visions for the UMC Part One with Adam Hamilton” by Andy Miller III via More to the Story Podcast. This Part One features Adam Hamilton. Part Two will feature Rob Renfrroe. (Added 6-17-2023)
Post via Grace Evangelical Methodist Sanctuary Facebook Page. A former UM bishop, Pete Torio of the Philippines, becomes the first elder in a new church body. Four deacons were also ordained. (Added 6-16-2023)
“S35 E45: The Root of the Rift in the Methodist Church” via At Issue (PBS). “Two pastors [Bob Phillips, Eric Swanson] with varied opinions offer their thoughts on disaffiliation in the United Methodist Church. Congregations have until year’s end to decide if they want to leave the United Methodist Church because of differences in their views on human sexuality and more.” (Added 6-16-2023)
“2023 Czech Republic Annual Conference” via UMNS. “He did not choose the theme of unity by chance, since the Annual Conference was faced with the momentous decision to separate from The United Methodist Church and found an autonomous church because of the question of how to deal with the topic of human sexuality.” (Added 6-16-2023)
“2023 Baltimore-Washington Conference” via UMNS. “A part of that love, was letting go — with grace and blessing — as members voted to allow the disaffiliation of 23 churches. The churches wanted to leave the denomination over the church’s stance on homosexuality and were able to do so under guidelines provided by the board of trustees and Paragraph 2553 in the Book of Discipline.” (Added 6-16-2023)
“2023 Austria Provisional Conference” via UMNS. “During the Annual Conference meeting, the members of the UMC in Austria made a clear commitment to unity within the worldwide United Methodist Church and the Central Conference of Central and Southern Europe… The decision as to whether a church wedding can take place lies with the pastors in accordance with the church order.” (Added 6-16-2023)
“The Curious Case of the Questionable Delegate” by Cynthia Astle via UM insight. Questions in the Indiana Conference (UMC) about the membership status of UM Action’s John Lomperis. (Added 6-16-2023)
“Cabinet Offers Clarity on Relationship of Retired Clergy to The UMC” via North Texas Conference (UMC). “The document outlines how the United Methodist connection extends into retirement, noting the necessity to establish a charge conference relationship and live out their discipleship in a United Methodist community.” (Added 6-16-2023)
“Louisiana Laity Want “No Louisiana United Methodist Left Behind”” by Mark Lambert via Louisiana Conference (UMC). “United Methodist laity in Louisiana wants a church that is inclusive and welcoming, is engaged with its communities, and is building new ministries in “deserts” so that “no Louisiana United Methodist is left behind,” the conference lay leader said Thursday at the 2023 Annual Conference.” (Added 6-16-2023)
“Conference Ratifies Disaffiliation Agreements” via Western PA Conference. “The Western Pennsylvania Conference of the United Methodist Church ratified the disaffiliation agreements for 298 churches during a special session in Erie, PA on June 14, 2023. Bishop Cynthia Moore-Koikoi presided. Voting on churches in blocks by districts, the body overwhelmingly affirmed all the disaffiliation agreements with no contestations.” (Added 6-16-2023)
“UMC Alabama-West Florida Conference ends as leadership defends new disaffiliation rule, delegates ask questions” by Will Blakely via 1819News.com. “The policy also requires churches seeking to disaffiliate to take 40 days of prayer and fasting. The trustees changed the policy on Tuesday, banning certain topics from official church meetings. This includes arguments to leave the UMC based on a “financial opportunity” or information about alternatives to remaining in the UMC.” (Added 6-16-2023)
Post by Jimmy Boone via Facebook. June 15 disaffiliation update: “Added W. PA & West Virginia (under 2549), New Mexico, and North Carolina. We are now at 5,947.” (Added 6-16-2023)
Overheard: The North Carolina Conference (eastern part of state) voted the approve the disaffiliation of 59 churches. (Added 6-16-2023)
“Disaffiliation & A “Holy Hex”” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast (YouTube). “Disaffiliation is a fraught time and some annual conferences within The United Methodist Church have had more issues than most. With emotions running high, Vicar Derek Kubilus, decided to call down a “Holy Hex” upon the disaffiliation process rather than blessing those leaving the denomination. We take a look at the prayer, Bishop Tracy Malone’s response, and Derek’s apology.” (Added 6-16-2023)
Tweet by Tom Lambrecht: “Amazing perspective on Euro-centeredness in the liberal and progressive agenda. “Regionalization” is the epitome of colonialism. Many Africans will not support it. De-centering whiteness in Methodism – https://go.shr.lc/3qL6HMj via @shareaholic” (Added 6-15-2023)
“De-centering Whiteness in Methodism” by O’Dell Horn via Ministry Matters. “Now that many churches have disaffiliated, and some have joined the Global Methodist Church, it is time for us to deal with White liberal racism… please understand that the black church is not with you. We will not be used as pawns in your battle against white conservatives, as the late Reverend Calvin Butts has previously stated. And we reject your Western Eurocentric interpretation of scripture, including on marriage.” (Added 6-15-2023)
Post by Jeff Greenway via Facebook. “The Allegheny West Provisional Conference is excited to report we anticipate having 450-550 churches by the end of 2023. We invite all churches who have yet to affiliate to consider joining our movement. Our goal is to move forward as like-minded, warm-hearted, Spirit-filled, Jesus-loving, evangelical, orthodox Wesleyan Christians committed to offering the whole Gospel to the whole world…” (Added 6-15-2023)
Tweet by Jeremy Smith: “This verse of “and are we yet alive?” hits different after a season of disaffiliating churches sowing discord and seeding the salt of discontent. They failed to destroy us, and the world is ready to see a better face of the #UMC.” (Added 6-15-2023)
“83 churches have split from the United Methodist Church” by Tyler Euchner via WCAU. Iowa Coverage. (Added 6-15-2023)
“113 Churches Leave UMCSC” by Jessica Brodie via South Carolina Conference. “The 113 churches comprise almost 12 percent of the 958 total churches in the South Carolina Conference of the UMC and represent every one of the 12 districts in the conference.” (Added 6-15-2023)
Tweet by Daniel Silliman: “20 UMC [conferences] with the most disaffiliation so far” [chart] (Added 6-15-2023)
“Grieving and glimmers of hope mark United Methodist breakup status” by Cynthia Astle via Baptist News Global. A round-up written for a progressiive Baptist readership. (Added 6-15-2023)
“UMC Alabama-West Florida Conference ends as leadership defends new disaffiliation rule, delegates ask questions” by Will Blakely via 1819News.com. “In the final business session of the United Methodist Church’s Alabama-West Florida Conference’s (AWFC) annual conference on Wednesday, an AWFC trustee addressed a new policy that makes it harder for churches to disaffiliate from the denomination, sparking questions from the delegates in attendance.” (Added 6-15-2023)
“What Every Western North Carolina United Methodist Needs to Know” by John Lomperis via Juicy Ecumenism. “Western North Carolina United Methodists, your congregation has “a limited right” to also join the mass exodus from the new, liberalized United Methodism and keep your property—but only if your church council acts before the end of June!” (Added 6-15-2023)
“Some Western Pennsylvania United Methodist churches make split official at conference” by Julia Macura via TribLive.com. “There were 298 churches in the Western Pennsylvania Conference of the United Methodist Church that took the final step to leave the denomination Wednesday evening at the conference’s annual meeting.” (Added 6-15-2023)
“Bishop Williamston Tells Louisiana United Methodists to Get Up Off the Mat” by Mark Lambert via Louisiana Conference. “It is understandable that many United Methodists miss friends who are in churches that disaffiliated, but the bishop signaled a defiant note to anyone with designs on siphoning away any more United Methodists.” (Added 6-15-2023)
“United Methodists ask for loyalty from leaders, tighten rules on disaffiliation and downsize” by Greg Garrison via AL.com. “Such a realignment would mean that United Methodist churches in south Alabama would again be under the supervision of a statewide bishop based in Birmingham, as it was before 1988. The conference office in Montgomery would be sold under current plans.” (Added 6-15-2023)
“Four ways to leave your denomination: How churches are disaffiliating from the UMC” by Emily McFarlan Miller via Religion News Service. “…other congregations and annual conferences have tried different ways to leave the mainline denomination — to varying degrees of success.” (Added 6-15-2023)
“Alabama megachurch votes to remain with UMC amid schism on homosexuality” by Michael Gryboski via Christian Post. Discernment Team recommendation at Centerbury UMC. (Added 6-15-2023)
“United Methodist Church Alabama-West Florida approves rule clarification preventing 275 disaffiliated clergies from receiving post-retirement medical benefits” by Will Blakely via 1819News.com. “The United Methodist Church’s (UMC) Alabama-West Florida Conference (AWFC) elected to approve a rule clarification by its Board of Trustees which would prevent over 200 disaffiliating clergies from receiving retirement benefits.” (Added 6-15-2023)
“2023 Cabinet Property Report” via West Virginia Conference. A list of the West Virginia Conference churches closed or disaffiliated. (Added 6-15-2023)
“Evangelism Is Crucial In The New Methodism” by Jack Jackson via Seedbed. “As Methodists seek to restructure ecclesial bodies or form new ones, it is imperative to recognize that the ministry of evangelism, by definition, must center on telling the story of Jesus in ways that people can encounter and, hopefully, embrace. ” (Added 6-15-2023)
“Fool me once, shame on you….but, fool me twice….?” by Ed Rodarmal. “If it was the WCA that was the primary vehicle to try to hold accountable the United Methodist Church, well then, who will hold the Global Methodist church accountable…..accountable to THEIR Book of Doctrines and Discipline….accountable to scripture?” (Added 6-15-2023)
“Seattle’s Quest Church leaves ECC over LGBTQ Issues” by Emily McFarlan Miller. “Most prominently, the United Methodist Church is splintering over issues of sexuality—namely, whether to ordain and marry its LGBTQ members. It’s schism that is accelerating as its regional annual conferences meet this summer and approve requests from their member churches to disaffiliate. Since 2019, the UMC, the second-largest Protestant denomination in the U.S., has approved the departures of 4,359 of its 30,000 churches. Many of those leaving are concerned the denomination is compromising its views on biblical sexuality.” (Added 6-14-2023)
Overheard: 25 West Virginia Conference churches were allowed to exit, but not under Par. 2553. A total of 47 churches were closed. (Added 6-14-2023)
Post by Phillip Vickery via Facebook. A member of First UMC in Henderson, TN celebrates that he may get the opportunity to vote on disaffiliation. (Added 6-14-2023)
Post by Great Lakes Conference (GMC) via Facebook. “…welcome to the 219 clergypersons and 156 churches who will call the Great Lakes Global Methodist Church “home” beginning July 1!” (Added 6-14-2023)
“The Importance of Connectionalism for Methodists” by Bishop Mark Webb via GMC. “Being a part of a connectional church creates an opportunity to partner with, invest in and encourage followers of Jesus Christ around the world, who seek to live the call of the Apostle Paul as shared with the Church at Philippi: “Therefore if there is any encouragement in Christ, if there is any consolation of love, if there is any fellowship of the Spirit, if any affection and compassion, make my joy complete by being of the same mind, maintaining the same love, united in spirit, intent on one purpose”” (Added 6-14-2023)
“Over 5,000 Methodist Congregations Depart Over Debates on Sexuality and Gender” by Ace Vincent via MSN. “A theological storm is raging within the United Methodist Church (UMC), the second-largest Protestant denomination in the U.S. Over 5,000 congregations have departed due to disagreements mainly over human sexuality.” (Added 6-14-2023)
“Mountain Brook’s Canterbury United Methodist Church votes to stay in denomination” by Greg Garrison via al.com. “Since December, 330 of 638 churches in the North Alabama Conference have left the United Methodist Church, most of them to join more conservative denominations where opposition to same-sex marriage has not been up for debate.” (Added 6-14-2023)
“Three Chicago-area churches to sever ties with United Methodist Church following split over LGBTQ inclusion” by Graydon Megan via Chicago Tribune. “Faith Evangelical United Methodist Church in Elmhurst, First United Methodist Church Plano and La Luz de Cristo United Methodist Church in Elgin will join thousands of congregations nationwide splitting from the denomination following decades of rising tensions between progressive congregations that flouted church bylaws banning same-sex marriage and clergy and their traditionalist counterparts.” (Added 6-14-2023)
Tweet by Mark Tooley: “This exited former United Methodist church despite unjustly losing property is thriving. Its former sanctuary was seized by Virginia United Methodism & mostly sits empty.” (Added 6-14-2023)
Tweet by John Lomperis: “Remember, decision by #UnitedMethodist bureaucracy 2 disregard #UMC Discipline in order to prevent new delegate elections ensures that in 2024, well over 60% of denomination’s membership will B African while majority of General Conference delegates will B American. Accidental?” (Added 6-14-2023)
“174 UMC churches in Indiana granted disaffiliation amid debate over homosexuality” by Michael Gryboski via Christian Post. Coverage of Indiana exits. (Added 6-13-2023)
“Leaked email shows newly elected UMC General Conference delegate touting new Alabama-West Florida Conference rule change – ‘The days of mass and easy disaffiliation’ are over” by Will Blakely via 1819News.com. (Added 6-13-2023)
“New WCA Global Council Officers Elected” via WCA. “After deliberations, the Council unanimously elected Ms. Elizabeth Chryst of Florida to be the new chairwoman of the Global Council. Ms. Chryst has served on the Global Council for several years and was just recently reelected to a second term. She has deep experience helping to lead a regional chapter and brings much professional wisdom to bear.” (Added 6-13-2023)
“A Time to Be Quiet” by Wil Meiklejohn via UM Insight. “In deep despair, humble pain and profound sadness; I propose a moratorium, a cease-fire, on all confrontational efforts. The varying philosophies have been made crystal-clear; repeating them only serves to harden our hearts and minds. May we use the next months before General Conference to anticipate the “sound of sheer silence” (I Kings 19:12 NRSV), secure in the knowledge that God is in control!” (Added 6-13-2023)
Post by Stan Copeland via Facebook. “The North Texas Annual Conference has been nothing short of a revival for me. It’s been a long season of hurt across the connection for many months. We got a taste at the South Central Jurisdiction of what it means to have the fighting quelled and the mission raised. We elected three bishops on the first ballot, which was history in the making and a huge statement of a new day for the UMC.” (Added 6-13-2023)
“Nearly 200 Hoosier churches leave United Methodist Church” via WNDU. “The size of the Indiana Conference of the United Methodist Church (INUMC) is somewhat shrinking after nearly 200 congregations cut ties with the Protestant denomination.” (Added 6-13-2023)
“Over 5,000 Churches Bolt Methodist Church Over LGBT Debate” via ToddStarnes.com. “The controversy comes after liberal leaders in the UMC disregarded a 2019 vote upholding the church’s ban on ordaining LGBT clergy and officiating at or hosting same-sex weddings.” (Added 6-13-2023)
“Methodist Church in Youngstown disaffiliating from United Methodist Church over sexuality differences” by Grace Christopher via WFMJ. “On Thursday, June 8, 2023, the Millcreek Community United Methodist Church in Boardman joined hundreds of other United Methodist churches and clergy in northeast Ohio in officially disaffiliating from the United Methodist Church. Approximately 38% churches in the East Ohio Conference were approved to leave the denomination due to theological differences surrounding human sexuality.” (Added 6-13-2023)
“For first time, Florida United Methodists approve LGBTQ clergy at Lakeland meeting” by Gary White via Lakeland Ledger. “The historic vote occurred Thursday evening during the annual gathering of the Florida Conference of the United Methodist Church in Lakeland, and it reversed a vote from last year’s meeting. More than 90% of the clergy members voted to commission a slate of clergy candidates, three of whom are known to be LGBTQ.” (Added 6-13-2023)
“Leighton disaffiliates with Methodist denomination” by David Young. “The church, located at the corner of 142nd Avenue and Second Street in Leighton Township. Henceforth it will be regarded as independent. Members of the church held a “Miracle Sunday” June 11 and raised more than 125% of the needed funds to exit the denomination.” (Added 6-13-2023)
‘I’m kind of over it’ — Bishop David Graves delivers opening remarks at UMC Alabama-West Florida Annual Conference as churches continue to weigh disaffiliation” by Will Blakely via 1819 News. “Traditional Methodists have suggested that the policy, in effect, limits rule 2553 disaffiliation to progressive churches seeking to leave the denomination and prevents traditional churches acting in good faith from leaving out of concern that the UMC has grown too theologically liberal.” (Added 6-13-2023)
“Over 5,000 Congregations Approved to End Affiliation with United Methodist Church over Homosexuality Debate” by Susan Berry via The Tennessee Star. “This, and other barriers, have led hundreds of churches to seek legal action in states like Florida, Georgia and Maryland,” the Post reported. (Added 6-13-2023)
“United Methodists after split: ‘God is not finished with us’” via AL.com. “I have tried everything in my power to get people to stay,” Graves said. “The changing of the church won’t happen if you change the name on the church.” (Added 6-13-2023)
“In Praise of Itineracy” by Keith Sweat. “Itinerancy is dead. All the emerging and continuing branches of Methodism are abandoning the practice. I do not write to stem that tide, nor do I imagine this work to instigate a revival of the itinerant pastor. I have a saying, when I find that my opinion is shared by 51% or more of the people, then I know it is time to re-evaluate my position. This is a minority report.” (Added 6-13-2023)
Post by Warren Lathem via Facebook. Shares thoughts from Beth Ann Cook as she prepares to leave the UMC: “That’s a Wrap: Reflecting on INUMC” (Added 6-13-2023)
“Pastor calls church disaffiliation ‘brutal’” by Keith Inman via The Jonesboro Sun. “The Rev. John Miles, the longtime pastor of what had been First United Methodist Church, said he felt his congregation had “no choice” but to resist the worldwide Christian denomination’s rules.” (Added 6-13-2023)
“Liberal mainline United Methodists see more than 5,000 congregations leave amid arguments over sex, gender” by Jon Brown via Fox News. “Hundreds of the churches attempting to disaffiliate have faced legal or financial hurdles as the UMC has demanded large sums to maintain their property, which has led to legal battles in some states, according to the Christian Post.” (Added 6-13-2023)
“As Methodists Head for the Exit, Some Find the Way Blocked” by Megan Fowler via Christianity Today. National Christian coverage of UM churches that want out but find the way blocked. (Added 6-13-2023)
“What the Hex?! Disaffiliation Rhetoric Gone Awry” by Suzanne Nicholson via Firebrand Magazine. Thoughts on the East Ohio Conference prayer that mentioned a “holy hex” on the disaffiliation process. (Added 6-13-2023)
“How Many Methodist Exits?” by Mark Tooley via Juicy Ecumenism. “So there will probably be at least 6,500 exiting churches this year before the deadline, or about 22% of the 29,598 USA United Methodist churches existing in 2020 before the pandemic and schism.” (Added 6-13-2023)
Post by Jason Woolever via Facebook. “or those evangelical friends who feel called to stay in the UMC and fight for the gospel, I pray that you overcome the fatigue and embrace the fight with great joy and courage. I pray that you will be realistic in your assessment of the direction things are headed so you won’t be continually caught off guard by the tactics of others. I pray you’ll daily put on the full armor of God and stand firm. I pray that you’ll never compromise your conscience no matter how much pressure you face.” (Added 6-12-2023)
“Caught in the Rye” by Richard Bryant via UM Insight. “If the annual conference didn’t feel like an exercise in forced superficiality and superficial spirituality, an imposed family reunion, and reading from a religious script so that all the right things are said at the right time and imagining that Israel’s God who loves justice, humility, and mercy is pleased with Methodists conducting a worship extravaganza in eastern North Carolina, I might be more excited about going.” (Added 6-12-2023)
“Judicial Council Needs to Recalibrate Its Perspective” by Linda Richard via UM Insight. “The frequency or number of General Conferences shouldn’t be the concern of the Judicial Council or of the Book of Discipline. The concern should be instead: “How can we conduct the business of the United Methodist Church in a way that ensures that the proper number and makeup of the delegates and how we meet allows for the continued mission of the church…” (Added 6-12-2023)
“Complaints, Charges and Specifications – What Do They Mean for a Church Trial?” by Jerry Eckert via UM Insight. “As the United Methodist Church looks to the possibility of a trial for suspended Bishop Minerva Carcaño, I’d like to clarify the terms being used rather carelessly about the process, resulting in confusion. I refer to “complaints,” “charges,” and “specifications.” (Added 6-12-2023)
“Church Trial for Suspended Bishop Should Also Focus on Western Colleagues” by Stephen Bryant via UM Insight. “Just when the UMC needs spiritual leaders who model the Wesleyan balance of vital piety, true knowledge, and prophetic zeal for justice that Bishop Carcaño has always sought to embody, the Western Jurisdiction College of Bishops — a small group of five active bishops — essentially sidelined her.” (Added 6-12-2023)
“Trying to heal after church disaffiliation votes” by Heather Hahn via UMNS. “Across the U.S. are United Methodists who, like Cunningham, need healing after bruising battles over whether their churches should leave the denomination. The resulting polarization in the pews has strained family ties, fractured friendships and left many people feeling their faith impugned.” (Added 6-12-2023)
“Indiana Conference Cabinet Resolution: Our Collective Mission and Witness” via Indiana Conference (PDF). An AC resolution decrying “fear-mongering” and calling on laity and clergy to recommit to clergy and lay covenants. (Added 6-12-2023)
“Eviction, church closure? Why an Oklahoma congregation worries it could happen to them” by Carla Hinton via The Oklahoman (PDF). “Regional leaders would not disclose which Oklahoma churches, other than First Church, are in the viability study process. They said their goal is to present the appropriate study data to regional conference delegates as they consider ratifying disaffiliation requests of churches at a special meeting in October.” (Added 6-12-2023)
Post by Jimmy Boone via Facebook. “Updated June 9: We are now at 5,556. By July 1 projections show we will see a total over 6,000!” (Added 6-12-2023)
Post by Jimmy Boone via Facebook (June 9). “The long day ends… New England: 14 (Two were Progressive) Indiana: 174. Current Grand Total: 5,307. New England was fascinating… a speaker from all 14 churches had to speak of their reasons to disaffiliate. So churches had to speak of concerns over human sexuality. Than speakers spoke of “the harm” to LGBTQIA members. They even set up counseling for the Gays. “Gay Triage” for those feeling harm. Indiana went through fast and smooth.” (Added 6-12-2023)
Overheard: Six Churches in the New York AC were approved for disaffiliation on June 10 with energetic opposition and close voting (as low as 60% approval). See here starting around at 6:39:00. Several Korean congregations were among those disaffiliating. The NYAC did not charge a share of the property value for congregations joining the GMC but did so for those going independent. (added 6-12-2023)
Post by Vaughn Stafford via Facebook. “[As of June 9] 51.9% of the United Methodist (UM) churches in the North Alabama Conference (NAC) have disaffiliated (331 of 638). Many more NAC churches will do so on September 12, 2023. 25.3% of the UM churches in the Southeastern Jurisdiction (SEJ) have disaffiliated (2612 of 10,318). There are 11 more AC votes coming before the end of 2023 (There are only 14 ACs in the SEJ.)” (Added 6-12-2023)
Post via Philippines Central Conference Facebook Page. Promoting a June 16 “Why I am Staying UMC and Why You Should, Too” Event featuring Liberato Bautista. (Added 6-12-2023)
“United Methodist’s ‘Open Table’ welcomes all. Conservatives would rather divorce the church” by Rob Tucker via Courier-Journal (commentary). Pastor of Watkins UMC: “United Methodist history is complicated. As with most Christian denominations, it is a history full of the wide range of human emotions, from great hope in revival and great sadness in division. For Kentucky United Methodism, this past Sunday brought us to one of those moments.” (Added 6-12-2023)
“4,000+ Churches Split from Pro-LGBTQ+ United Methodist Church Denomination” by Katherine Hamilton via Breitbart News. “We absolutely believe that the United Methodist Church is drifting day by day ever more progressive,” Therrell said. “We have bishops all across the globe who are completely violating the Book of Discipline. They are allowing all sorts of things to happen that violate various paragraphs, much of it to do with human sexuality.” (Added 6-12-2023)
“Historical First Church in OKC Fears Closure Over UMC Split” by Carla Hinton via The Oklahoman (paywall). (Added 6-12-2023)
Tweet by Mark Tooley: “Here’re my United Methodist schism pies.” [shows pie charts related to disaffiliation, seemingly in response to a pie chart shared by Adam Hamilton.] (Added 6-11-2023)
“Local SC churches separate from United Methodist denomination” by Sydaija Smalls via WCIV. “Cheri Yates, who is the pastor of the Cypress, Mount Tabor, and Trinity United Methodist churches in Ridgeville, says the future of her services will be to follow the gospel of Jesus Christ. She’s passionate about her calling to preach in the Ridgeville area and once the opportunity presented itself to leave the United Methodist Church, she never looked back.” (Added 6-11-2023)
“Santee Pride Walk to symbolize unity within community: Dozens of people gathered outside Santee United Methodist Church to show off their pride” by Ariana Cohen via cbs8(San Diego). “Wood found herself in the center of a controversy in January when protests erupted after a teenager thought she saw a naked man in Santee YMCA locker room; bringing forth the opposition of allowing transgender people in locker rooms according to their gender identity. “For Heaven’s sake, we’re meeting at a church, and thanks Channel 8 for understanding. God Bless,” said Wood.
“Methodist Doctrinal Standards and Schism as Sin” by Rick Wright. Who is splitting the church: Those leaving or those violating the Discipline? (Added 6-11-2023)
“Clergy Session, Thursday, June 8, 2023, Opening Remarks” by Magrey deVega, Florida Conference Chair of BOM. A speech offered to the clergy session the Florida Conference on why non-celibate gay candidates were recommended for commissioning and ordination. (Added 6-11-2023)
Post via Allendale UMC-St. Petersburg( Facebook) “Florida United Methodist clergy voted to commission openly LGBTQ candidates for ordained ministry! This historic first is pictured below, as the class embraced each other following the vote….” (Added 6-11-2023)
“Last day at Annual Conference: The new “D” word isn’t disaffiliation” by Annette Spense via Holston Conference. “The new “D” word for Holston Conference is not disaffiliation. It’s discipleship. That’s what the Rev. Kim Goddard said on the final day of Holston Annual Conference, joining other speakers in sending United Methodists forth with an urgent call to follow Jesus — and to teach and lead others to follow him, too.” (Added 6-11-2023)
“St. Paul United Methodist Church Discernment Team Report to Administrative Council” via St. Paul Ocean Springs (MS). “Discernment Team feels that if St. Paul were to remain as part of the UMC denomination, we would continue to face challenges that would significantly impede the future vitality of our church family…” (Added
“Discernment team at Mountain Brook’s Canterbury United Methodist recommends church remain in denomination” by Will Blakely via 1819. “Throughout the discernment process, Canterbury UMC has revealed itself to be a profoundly committed church, filled with people holding theologically diverse perspectives, yet consistently and deeply rooted in the foundation of salvation that is given through the love and grace of God through Jesus Christ,” the recommendation read. “Through these deep roots of faith, Canterbury has become a faith community that is made stronger, not weaker, by its differences.” (Added 6-11-2023)
“8 Regional Congregations to Leave United Methodist Church” via Toledo Blade. [Paywall] (Added 6-11-2023)
“Closed Hearts, Closed Minds, Closed Doors. United Methodist Church Split Accelerates Over LGBTQ Issues” via Milaukee Independent. An interesting headline on an earlier AP story. (Added 6-11-2023)
“What Just Happened In The Baltimore-Washington Annual Conference?” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast (YouTube). “The Baltimore-Washington Annual Conference of the United Methodist Church just held their annual conference meeting that last week. We go over some of the more surprising things that happened during the meeting and respond to them.” (Added 6-11-2023)
“Joint Statement on Just Resolution” by Sam Duenckel via Virginia Conference (UMC). “All parties are grateful to have reached a resolution, especially as Rev. Ensz remained under complaint for more than 1,300 days. Together as a conference, they hope there can be a refocus on the Church’s public witness to those seeking God’s grace and love and on serving others.” (Added 6-11-2023)
Post by Matthew Sichel via Facebook. A Baltimore-Washington clergy shares his thoughts upon surrendering his UMC credentials, includes a photo of a parting hug with Bishop Easterling. (Added 6-10-2023)
Tweet via Beth Ann Cook: “@inumconference #umc Disaffiliation Vote passes no debate or drama on one combined ballot. By quick count of slides 174 churches. I think with previous votes about 300 churches exited via 2553.” (Added 6-10-2023)
“On My Way to the Great Divorce” by John Alexander Wright via UM Insight. “Today I’m headed to the Rio Texas Conference session in Corpus Christi. Ironic, isn’t it—that there in City of Christ’s Body, we will give the risen Lord cause to say to us, “This is my body, broken by you.” (Added 6-10-2023)
“Grieving and Glimmers of Hope Mark United Methodist Breakup Status” by Cynthia Astle via UM Insight. “Baker’s views about the ongoing current of churches leaving the United Methodist denomination appear typical of how grassroots congregations are dealing with the split, according to reports in secular newspapers, from church members and from a church agency tasked with helping local churches.” (Added 6-10-2023)
“Mainstream UMC is Back” via PDF. After taking break to run for the U.S. Senate, Mark Holland is relaunching Mainstream UMC to advocate for regionalization at the next UM General Conference. Holland is a member of the jurisdictional delegation of the Great Plains Conference this time after being a vocal organizer for the One Church Plan at GC2019. Holland has been on personal leave from UM ministry since 2018. See also “Advocacy Group Relaunches After Pandemic Postponements” via UM Insight. (Added 6-10-2023)
“Colton congregation ‘split right down the middle’ forms new church” by Sean Brynda via WWNY. “Congregations around the nation are severing ties with the United Methodist Church over LGBTQ disagreements. But one congregation in St. Lawrence County split from UMC for a different reason. Bruce Winters is helping set up for Saturday’s inaugural celebration of the Colton Community Church. The congregation separated from the United Methodist Church, as have thousands of congregations around the country. Some congregations feel the church isn’t traditional enough when it comes to the LGBTQ community. In Colton, the congregation just wanted to stay together.” (Added 6-10-2023)
Post by Norman Harold Patterson, Jr. via Facebook. Video clip: “A Claim from a “pastor” of the New York Annual Conference: “John Wesley rejected the Scripture…” What say you Methodists?” (Added 6-10-2023)
Post by Jimmy Boone via Facebook. June 9 Disaffiliation tally: “We are now at 5,524. By July 1 projections show we will see a total over 6,000!” (Added 6-10-2023)
“United Methodist Church in Kentucky losing congregations” by Jack Brammer via The Interior Journal. “To further highlight that Seddon was leaving the United Methodist Church, light red paint was used to obscure the word “United” on the awning over the church’s front door. It now reads “Seddon Methodist Church.” Also, a large metal cross with a flame — the symbol of the United Methodist Church — was removed from the church and its van.” (Added 6-10-2023)
Overheard: Some churches who are required by their conference to state their objections to the actions of GC2019 in order to disaffiliate under Par. 2553 are using this language: “While General Conference 2019 upheld current teachings on human sexuality, it failed to approve “the heart of the Traditional Plan” (a new Par. 2801) which allowed release and gracious exit to progressive conferences and congregations. The failure to approve a complete Way Forward plan has left the UMC in disarray and without the instruments that might have resulted in a denomination compatible with our understanding of Christian discipleship.” (Added 6-10-2023)
“United Methodist Church Alabama-West Florida Conference changes terms on churches voting to break away; Traditional Methodists call it a ‘nail in the coffin’” by Will Blakely via 1819 News. “The updated policy now requires that the Church Council of churches in the AWFC which seek to enter the disaffiliation process “adopt a statement of eligibility that demonstrates the current and specific disagreement(s) that the local church has with the changes in the Book of Discipline made in 2019.” (Added 6-10-2023)
“24 South Dakota Churches to Split from United Methodist Church on LGBTQ Ministers, Gay Marriage” via the Argus Leader [paywall]. “Forty-three churches in total have now disaffiliated from the United Methodist Church in South Dakota, largely over LGBTQ+ rights in the church.” (Added 6-10-2023)
“UMC loses 174 Hoosier congregations at annual state conference in ongoing schism” by David Penticuff via Muncie Star Press. “A schism persists between believers in traditional Methodist doctrine and those pressing for a more progressive faith that, among other issues, includes the acceptance of LGBTQ rights within the church. Another 107 traditional congregations left in November, meaning 284 community churches in Indiana have split from the UMC in the past eight months.” (Added 6-10-2023)
“Over 5,000 UMC churches granted disaffiliation amid schism over homosexuality; 3,000 in 2023” by Michael Gryboski via Christian Post. “This week, according to numbers compiled by UM News, the number of churches that have had their disaffiliation votes approved by their annual conferences under Paragraph 2553 of the UMC Book of Discipline went from around 4,600 on Tuesday to 5,321 as of Friday morning.” (Added 6-10-2023)
Overheard: All 43 Wisconsin churches presented for disaffiliation were approved. (Added 6-9-2023)
Tweet by Mark Tooley: “92 churches just ratified for exit from United Methodism in Delaware & Maryland Eastern Shore, joining 16 from last year, equaling over 25% of total. These churches acted quickly before bishop imposed exorbitant exit fee as in rest of Maryland. USA total now over 5400.” (Added 6-9-2023)
“What is a Methodist?” by Tom Lambrecht via Good News. “I have argued before that a consistent Methodist identity has been blurred and obscured in The United Methodist Church… The launching of the Global Methodist Church signals a desire to reclaim a consistent Methodist identity.” (Added 6-9-2023)
Overheard: The Missouri Conference approved 76 churches for disaffiliation. (Added 6-9-2023)
Tweet Reply by Beth Ann Cook: On John’s Lomperis’s seat on the Indiana delegation: “During session pastor of church verified chain of membership John at request Bishop Trimble. He testified that John has remained an active member of umc at all times even though church he belonged to disaffiliated.” (Added 6-9-2023)
Post by Adam Hamilton via Facebook. “The chart shows the latest data we have on disaffiliations in the US. Of those churches disaffiliating, it appears 2,000 to 3,000 have or will join the GMC and the GMC will have about 450,000 members. Another 2,000 will be non-denominational or join another Methodist denomination. The UMC will have 24,000 to 26,000 churches with about 4.5 million members.” (Added 6-9-2023)
Letter by Geoffrey Lentz via PDF. On a change in the Alabama-West Florida disaffiliation process: “I believe that the June 5 update to the AWF Trustee policy effectively gets us to that point [of a pause]. Providing accountability to the eligibility requirements of the BOD for instance means that likely few if any churches in our conference are truly eligible.” (Added 6-9-2023)
Overheard: “Peninsula Delaware just approved disaffiliation of 92 churches on a vote of nearly 89%. Out of those somewhere around 4or 5 ended up having to pay property, and that property amount was over 5 million dollars. The rest of them got out with no property payment whatsoever.” (Added 6-9-2023)
Tweet Reply by Chris Ritter. “The laity are [John Lomperis’] peers. This seems like clergy horning in on lay elections. If ineligible, he should be ruled as such. The fact he wasn’t is telling. The IN delegation could have called for new elections, but that would have endangered their own seats.” (Added 6-9-2023)
Tweet by Jeremy Smith: “I’m told the Indiana Conference passed a motion by 62% to send a letter to the Secretary of General Conference to remove IRD staffperson John Lomperis from the Indiana delegation, noting he is no longer eligible to serve on the delegation but refuses to willfully withdraw. #umc” (Added 6-9-2023)
Overheard: 92 churches were just approved for disaffiliation from the Peninsula Delaware Conference. The margin was 88.9%. (Added 6-9-2023)
Post via WCA Florida Facebook Page. “Thank you to all who attended the WCA luncheon in Lakeland. We had a packed house. The few that couldn’t attend, we missed you!. We heard “witness to freedom” stories about getting out of the UMC into the GMC. Jay [Therrell] framed the future of the GMC amazingly. I want to be a part of THAT! Take the 7 mins to listen & share!” (Added 6-7-2023)
Tweet Thread by Brian Felker Jones: “Many (me included) have wondered what #UMC #disaffiliation will mean for our #UnitedMethodist “connexion” globally. But today I’m reflecting on it with a different perspective- for as of yesterday EVERY CONGREGATION I grew up in has voted to leave the UMC in Indiana. /1 #INUMC” (Added 6-9-2023)
“Episode 129: God is Doing a New Thing” by John Stephens via Pod Have Mercy Podcast. I conversation with Texas Conference Church Planters building new churches from disaffiliation dissidents. (Added 6-9-2023)
“Faith leaders react to methodist church divide” by Deric Rush via WITN (NC). ““You know there are those on both sides who would agree that you can’t be together when you disagree over something that’s significant and yet we managed to stay together as a church when we had disagreements about divorce in the early part of the 20th century we stayed together when the church integrated in 1968 the United Methodist Church integrated and you know my point was always if we can make it through that we ought to be able to make it through this,” said Spivey. (Added 6-9-2023)
“Faith Works: Disaffiliation and the challenges facing the United Methodist Church” by Jeff Gill via The Newark Advocate. “Last year there were around 950 congregations “in full connection” with the West Ohio Conference, but there were 80 congregations who asked to disaffiliate in that year; the 2023 annual conference that just ended approved another 172 disaffiliations, leaving about 700 congregations. That’s 26.5% of the conference’s congregations choosing to depart, and looking at nationally reported figures, I’d suspect that will total around 30% or a bit more of membership.” (Added 6-9-2023)
Updated: “Holy Hex?”: Did someone put a holy hex on the disaffiliation process at the 2023 East Ohio Conference? Sort of. In a prayer that led into the disaffiliation report, Rev. Derek Kubilus led a prayer that included, “We dare not ask you to bless this work of disaffiliation… no more than we could ask you to bless a work of idolatry or fornication….but before we go and do what we are going to do, since we won’t ask you to bless the disaffiliation itself, a guess we need to ask you to put a holy hex on it….”. There were audible groans during that line. See here at 3:08:00. See a tweet by Evan Rohrs-Dodge on the subject. See also tweet (and another tweet) by the EOC Director of Communications: “The person who prayed admittedly used a poor choice of words, and his intent was not as you described. Our Bishop addressed this with the person who prayed and with the conference acknowledging the harm. May grace and forgiveness follow accountability.” Bishop Malone addressed the prayer at 5:26:15 after the lunch break. (Added 6-8-2023)
Tweet by Ed Fashbaugh: On the East Ohio “Holy Hex” prayer, the Director of Communications comments: “Clergy are invited to pray at annual conference to open or close sessions. These prayers are usually full of grace & goodwill. This prayer was something other. I don’t know the pastor’s intention, but the impact was harm. Our Bishop openly addressed the harm before entire AC.” (Added 6-9-2023)
“Methodist Meltdown in Miniature: A Review of the 2023 Eastern PA Session” by Joe DiPaolo via PeopleNeedJesus.net. How one AC session points to larger dysfunctions in the UMC in terms of process and episcopal overreach. (Added 6-9-2023)
“43 Wisconsin congregations are set to leave United Methodist Church over LGBTQ issues” by Sophie Carson via Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. “Last year the Wisconsin conference set a 17-step process for more congregations to disaffiliate, and 43 congregations voted among their own members to leave the United Methodist Church. It all comes to a head Friday when conference delegates meet in Green Bay to vote on approving those requests.” (Added 6-8-2023)
Tweet by John Lomperis. “Elite #UnitedMethodist clerics sanctimoniously blaming those they have driven out 4 “the evils of division,” without taking any responsibility for their own actions, sound like adulterous, abusive husbands putting all the blame on wives for seeking divorce as a final resort #UMC” (Added 6-9-2023)
“The split in UNY’s United Methodist Church just got wider” by Jules Struck via Syracuse Post-Standard. “The exodus was just one sign of a shrinking Upstate UMC, which is grappling to remain united under the global church’s binding anti-LGBTQ+ policy and during expensive legal negotiations with people who say they were abused by clergy. In money and members, the church has lost over the past few years.” (Added 6-8-2023)
“Kentucky Methodists are dividing —and division is an age-old tradition in itself | Opinion” by Paul Prater via Lexington Herald-Leader. “Church splits aren’t the exception; they’re the rule. The history of Christianity sometimes seems to be one division after another, endlessly, each split as agonizing for those involved as the previous ones were for earlier generations.” (Added 6-8-2023)
“United Methodism Lives On In Amarillo” by Sam Hodges via UMNS. “The Northwest Texas Conference has been especially hit hard by disaffiliations. The Rev. Margie McNeir led the effort to start a new United Methodist church in Amarillo, Texas, which was at risk of having no church in the denomination.” (Added 6-8-2023)
Post by Jimmy Boone vi Facebook. A clergy who tracks tallies 5,152 disaffiliations as of noon on June 8. (Added 6-8-2023)
“Grace Evangelical Methodist Sanctuary Jurisdictional Convention” via Facebook. The group launched with former UM Bishop, Pete Torio, holds a convening meeting. (Added 6-8-2023)
“GMC Official Launch in the Philippines” via Facebook. “See you on July 1, 2023, Saturday, from 9AM to 4PM at the Samsung Hall in SM Aura, BGC, Taguig City!” (Added 6-8-2023)
“First openly gay United Methodist bishop talks about Pride month” by Mekialaya White via NewsBreak. “It is Pride month, and we are celebrating at CBS News Colorado. That includes highlighting people blazing trails in the LGBTQ community, like Bishop Karen Oliveto. She’s the first openly gay bishop in the United Methodist Church.” (Added 6-8-2023)
“Alabama – West Florida Conference Entrapment” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast. “After 193 churches left the Alabama-West Florida Conference of the United Methodist Church on May 7th, 2023 the board of trustees has now made it more difficult for the remaining churches in the conference to leave. On top of the already stringent requirements leveled against those wishing to leave, the conference has now implemented updated disaffiliation eligibility requirements that make it almost impossible for conservative churches to leave the denomination.” (Added 6-8-2023)
Post by Won D. Kim via Facebook. A farewell post to the UMC includes, “I never had any intention of leaving the United Methodist Church at first, but after facing some critical challenges in the UMC, and after many years of praying for God’s wisdom and discernment, the Holy Spirit made it clear to me that I needed to pursue ordained ministry in a different expression of the Wesleyan witness [GMC].” (Added 6-8-2023)
“Q&A About the Disaffiliation Process in the North Georgia Conference” via North Georgia Conference Trustees. Spells out many requirements for disaffiliation, including “turning in hymnals.” (Added 6-8-2023)
Post by Warren Lathem via Facebook: Shares “Q&A About the Disaffiliation Process in the North Georgia Conference” document with: “I strongly urge any churches in NGA desiring to vote on disaffiliation under paragraph 2553 to have your church council vote immediately and submit your letter to your DS requesting a date for the Called Charge Conference. Do not delay.” (Added 6-8-2023)
Overheard: East Ohio Annual Conference just disaffiliated 237 churches and over 130 clergy. That’s 36% of their churches and about 26% of their Conference budget. More: “Votes cast at 12:47 pm. Motion 776/72 approved. Also, 3 churches were inadvertently left off of the list (but not the count). They were also approved. Including the 11 who disaffiliated in 2022, 248 churches have left the UMC. (Added 6-8-2023)
Overheard: In an Adam Hamilton speech, the Great Plains Conference is celebrating the end to Texas’ hegemony over the South Central Jurisdiction of the UMC. Large numbers of Texas churches have disaffiliated. (Added 6-8-2023)
Tweet via Great Plains Conference UMC: With so many Texas disaffiliations, ““The center of gravity in the SCJ has shifted to the #GPUMC from Texas.” #gpac2023 #umc ” (Added 6-8-2023)
Tweet by JJ Warren: “The clergy of @neumc voted & approved me & my fellow candidates to be commissioned as provisional Elders & Deacons in The United Methodist Church! #BeUMC #HappyPride #FaithfullyLGBT” (Added 6-8-2023)
Tweet via Great Plains UMC: “Despite the loss of 155 churches, we still have 750 churches. We are still the largest annual conference in the South Central Jurisdiction. gpac233 #gpumc” (Added 6-8-2023)
Overheard: The 99% vote at Christ Church Memphis to join the GMC can be paired with the affiliation decision of The Woodlands and shows former UM evangelical flagships choosing to stay connected to a larger group rather than assuming an independent status. Christ Church leaders had narrowed their options to the GMC or The Foundry Network. (Added 6-8-2023)
“LGBTQ+ Controversy Shakes United Methodist Church: Congregational Divisions Emerge” by Judah Olanisebee via TDPel Media. “As of Tuesday afternoon, 4,876 Methodist churches have completed the process of breaking away from the UMC this year [sic].” (Added 6-7-2023)
“Church factions spar over information” by Keith Inman via The Jonesboro Sun (Arkansas). “As another hearing approaches in the ongoing battle over the split of what had been one of the largest churches in Arkansas, the various parties involved are fighting over the right to each others’ information.” (Added 6-8-2023)
“AC 2023 Finds Assurance Amid Troubles” via Michigan Conference (UMC). “Michigan United Methodists find themselves in an in-between space, as church members grapple with post-pandemic realities, such as attendance decline, budget contractions, the reduction of conference staff and the number of districts, and ongoing denominational disaffiliation and religious disaffiliation, and yet hold fast to God’s promises.” (Added 6-8-2023)
Tweet by Paul Lawler: “Christ Church Memphis has voted by a 99% margin to join the new Global Methodist Church over the Foundry Network.” (Added 6-8-2023)
“Christ Church Votes to Join the Global Methodist Church” via the Daily Memphian. [paywall] (Added 6-8-2023)
“The New Methodists: An Update” by Chuck Kelly. Baptist: “If Southern Baptists are unwilling to do what is necessary to change their direction with sustained attention to breaking free of decline for at least a decade, look around at Methodists today to see the Southern Baptist Convention of tomorrow.” (Added 6-8-2023)
Post by Bob Phillips via Facebook: “Not the future but the present of UM theological education. Read carefully. I don’t recall a General Conference officially recognizing the ABC as a legitimate faith group…similar to the GMC official lack of recognition. Irony…” [link: “Jen Harvey Appointed New Dean of Garrett“] (Added 6-8-2023)
“Why 1 Myrtle Beach church is staying United Methodist while 100 others in SC are leaving” by Eleanor Nash or Sun News via Yahoo! News. “Ann Sowers was shocked. The lay leader of Joseph B. Bethea United Methodist Church in Carolina Forest learned that more than a quarter of the 90 Myrtle Beach-Marion area UMC congregations planned to leave the Christian denomination.” (Added 6-8-2023)
“UMC of Indiana Conference expected to tackle disaffiliation of congregations” by David Penticuff via Muncie Star Press. “Dozens more Indiana congregations are expected to leave the United Methodist Church in Indiana this year, said John Lomperis, who has been a United Methodist General Conference delegate and supporter of traditional church doctrine.” (Added 6-8-2023)
“Coverage of Methodist split leaves questions unanswered” by Myrna Loehrlein (Letter to Editor) via The Gazette (Cedar Rapids, IA). “The recent article in The Gazette describes the disaffiliating churches as striking “out in a new … direction.” This is, in fact, the opposite of the actual situation. It is the disaffiliating churches that have chosen to maintain the old rules. It is the continuing congregations that support new rules welcoming everyone into all aspects of church life.” (Added 6-7-2023)
“4,876 Methodist Churches Leave the Pro-Abortion United Methodist Church” by Micaiah Bilger via LifeNews. “In 2021, the United Methodist Women, an organization within the denomination, went further by issuing a statement that openly promoted legalized abortion on demand. In the statement, the United Methodist Women criticized the Texas heartbeat law, which has saved thousands of unborn babies from abortion, and promised to “pray” for abortions to become legal again in Texas.” (Added 6-7-2023)
“UMC 2023 – Opening and Plenary 1” via Northern Illinois Conference (YouTube). A fascinating view into a disaffiliation discussion at an annual conference session. The high financial price paid by each congregation was displayed on the screen during each vote (toward the end of the video). (Added 6-7-2023)
“No sanctuary for secular conflicts in United Methodist Church” by Cheryl Tevis via Iowa Capital Dispatch. “The focus of this column isn’t specifically on the schism of the second-largest mainline Protestant church. Nor is it on the building where they meet. After all, “The church is a people,” according to a favorite UMC hymn. My concern is how this schism fits into the broader context of our shared rural communities, and our state.” (Added 6-7-2023)
“New UMC: More Hopeful Than Ever” by Steve Harper via UM Insight. Five reasons why Harper is hopeful about the UMC. (Added 6-7-2023)
Post by Bruce David via UM Clergy Facebook Page. On a Richard Bryant article in UM Insight: “Serious question: Is this the direction we can anticipate once the Progressive faction has sealed its ascendency at the 2024 GC? If so, perhaps its unfair to suggest the Global Methodist types have been spreading “disinformation.”” (Added 6-7-2023)
“un-United: Another church votes to leave UMC; one staying” by Phil Attinger via Highland News-Sun. Florida coverage with a paywall. (Added 6-7-2023)
“What to know about the Methodist church exodus in Kentucky” by Caleb Wiegandt via Louisville Courier Journal (Yahoo! News). “Nearly half of Kentucky’s United Methodist Church congregations were granted a split from the denomination this week, significantly shrinking the church’s footprint in the state.” (Added 6-7-2023)
“286 Kentucky churches leave UMC amid homosexuality debate” by Michael Gryboski via Christian Post. “Conference members approved the disaffiliation votes of the churches on Sunday, in a vote of 489 in favor to 56 opposed, the majority representing 89% of those gathered at the Owensboro Convention Center.” (Added 6-7-2023)
“Eight Churches Approved for Disaffiliation from Norther Illinois Conference UMC” by Victoria Rebeck via NIC. “Earlier this year, 18 churches expressed interest in disaffiliating. Ten of these took the step of taking a church-wide vote on the decision. Eight have signed disaffiliation agreements.” (Added 6-7-2023)
“2023 Annual Conference Session Agenda” via New England Conference. Shows 14 churches scheduled for individual debate and vote. (Added 6-7-2023)
“Churches Presented by the Trustees for Disaffiliation June 8” via Rio Texas Conference. 34 church listed (scroll down). (Added 6-7-2023)
“South Carolina OKs 113 churches separating from denomination” by Jessica Brodie via South Carolina UM Advocate. Extensive report includes a photo of Bishop L. Jonathan Holston wiping his eyes during an emotional prayer just before the closure vote. “The names of the churches intending to separate (listed), as well as the number, had been kept confidential until the vote to ‘preserve the integrity of the voting process,’ according to Dan O’Mara, communications coordinator for the annual conference.” (Added 6-7-2023)
“North Carolina Conference Disaffiliation List” via AC Workbook (p. 92). 59 congregation presented at the regular 2023 session of the NCC. 249 churches disaffiliated previously. p. 89 describes seven church closures, three pending closures, and two forced closures against the wishes of the congregation. One of these is Fifth Avenue UMC in Wilmington that promises legal action if they are closed as a UMC. (Added 6-7-2023)
“Disaffiliating Congregation Disengages with Required Process” by Victoria Rebeck via Northern Illinois Conference (UMC). “An NIC staff member arrived at the church on May 28 as previously scheduled to introduce the congregation to their new pastor, Rev. Sam Park. Some of the KUMC members—along with police officers they had summoned—blocked the NIC representatives’ entry into the building at 2403 W. Diehl Rd., Naperville. KUMC’s previously appointed pastor (who had not yet been ordained) had been relieved of his clergy credentials with the NIC on May 23, through the denomination’s prescribed process.” Bishop Schwerin: “Those who have declared themselves non-United Methodist and taken over conference property have stepped beyond the bounds of civility and appropriate remedies will be sought. We have a duty to protect the mission of the annual conference. Please pray for this congregation that is suffering with complicated loss, and for our capacity to live into God’s vision for us all.” (Added 6-7-2023)
Overheard: The South Carolina Conference today approved 113 churches to separate from the Conference. Final transfer of property June 30. SCC has its own non-Par. 2553 process and more exits are forthcoming. See a list of separated and closed churches here via WCBD. (Added 6-6-2023)
“Local churches break with Methodists” by Jill Doss-Raines via Thomasville Times. “United Methodist churches across the country are undergoing a historic transformation as many — including 19 in Davidson County — have requested to leave the denomination, while other churches that are staying seek to draw those left without a church.” (Added 6-6-2023)
“Thousands of United Methodist churches break away over LGBTQ+ disagreements” by Peter Pinedo via Catholic News Agency. “As of Tuesday afternoon, 4,876 Methodist churches this year have officially completed the process to break away from the UMC, Therrell said…. “We absolutely believe that the United Methodist Church is drifting day by day ever more progressive,” Therrell said. “We have bishops all across the globe who are completely violating the Book of Discipline.” (Added 6-6-2023)
“Dozens of Pee Dee churches leave UMC, many remain with some advocating inclusivity” by Andrew James via WPDE. South Carolina coverage. (Added 6-6-2023)
“A Bad Start For Pride Month” by Scott Hogenson via Townhall. The exodus from the UMC is “is the largest, loudest, most well considered repudiation of transgender ideology in recent memory – maybe ever.” (Added 6-6-2023)
“Departing with a Blessing” by Cambron Wright via Substack. “It was a bittersweet time, with people I have genuine affection for—and affection is the right word, even more so than love—Methodists are a connectional people, who just long to be around one another, to share in life together. And this is what makes our division all the more painful. Bishop Fairley wisely said in our conference: if there was no love, then there would be no grief in parting.” (Added 6-6-2023)
“Church Files Lawsuit to Separate from United Methodist Church in Oklahoma City” via News9. “First Church, known for its inclusivity, is located near the site of the Oklahoma City Bombing.” (Added 6-6-2023)
“Three Franklin County United Methodist Churches leave over LGBTQ+ issues and theology” by Peter Gill via The Columbus Dispatch. “Reynoldsburg Community Church and Riverside Church in Upper Arlington disaffiliated at the beginning of this year, and Canal Winchester Faith Church will disaffiliate beginning June 30.” (Added 6-6-2023)
Post by Jimmy Boone via Facebook. “We are now at 4,736 [disaffiliations]. After Tuesday we should be over 5,000.” (Added 6-6-2023)
Post via Holston WCA Facebook Page. “The Holston WCA facebook page will be shutting down at the end of this week. The Global WCA is reconfiguring it’s local chapters into Jurisdictional chapters to better serve traditional/orthodox churches, clergy, and laity who remain in the United Methodist Church.” (Added 6-6-2023)
“Baltimore-Washington Methodists approve exit of 23 congregations, each with a price tag” by Mark Kellner via The Washington Times. “The 23 congregations — including 222-year-old Oakdale Church in Olney, Maryland — will have to pay 12 months of “mission shares,” or donations to the district; a prorated share of unfunded pension obligations; and half the assessed value of the church’s property in order to exit. The terms were set at a 2019 special session of UMC delegates.” (Added 6-6-2023)
“Ecumenical Pride Service” via First Presbyterian Church, Annapolis, MD. “Ecumenical pride service at First Presbyterian Church of Annapolis, MD (PCUSA) involving two Baltimore Washington Conference UMC clergy, Rev. Jennifer Karsner and Pastor Christopher Broadwell. The main preacher was a drag queen called Bella Centric DeFlaire. Broadwell’s spouse led the children’s sermon. Cookies and Fresca served as communion. (Added 6-6-2023)
“Gathering of European Methodist Conservative Churches” by Marjana Luist via WCA. “Some countries have disaffiliated from the UMC and joined the Global Methodist Church (GMC). This has been done, for example, by Bulgaria, whose superintendent was unable to participate in the gathering. A Zoom meeting was organized during the Adrian Connection meeting with him. According to Bulgarian superintendent, disaffiliation from the UMC was a big risk for the Bulgarian Methodist Church, because it was financially dependent on UMC. The church sold some property to create a financial reserve for the period when the church structure is redesigned to be more mission oriented.” (Added 6-6-2023)
“AC Day 2: Bishop says 2 new directors will help begin conference ‘pivot’” via Kentucky Conference. “Two new staff members were formally introduced Tuesday, June 5, during the opening plenary session of the Kentucky Annual Conference – the Rev. Dr. Kimberly Pope-Seiberling, director of New Church Development, and the Rev. Dr. Tina Patterson, director of Connectional and African American Ministries… Fairley put it, “starting the pivot” after Sunday night’s session to approve the disaffiliation of 286 churches in the conference. (Added 6-6-2023)
“Disaffiliating Church List” via Missouri UM Conference. 75 churches to be voted on June 9. Another 17 to be closed. (Added 6-6-2023)
“Dan Rodricks: Anti-LGBTQ+ is not Christian. It’s childish and a waste of valuable time” by Dan Rodericks via Sentinel and Enterprise (Opinion). Baltimore area UMC split shows the differrence between childish Christians and grown up Christians. (Added 6-6-2023)
“New Church Coming to Bladen County: Welcome Grace United Methodist Church” via Bladen Online (N. Carolina). “After a United Methodist Church in Elizabethtown disaffiliated from the state conference, a devoted group of believers wanted to continue to worship as United Methodists, according to Toni Dickerson, with the promise of “Open hearts, open minds, open doors.” (Added 6-6-2023)
“Bishop Delores J. Williamston Announces Strategic Appointments” vi Louisiana Conference. “In the wake of disaffiliations and emerging faith expressions, Bishop Williamston emphasizes the importance of strategic thinking and a better understanding of the local context. With the aim of gathering new faith communities and also strengthening Black United Methodist churches, the bishop believes that these appointments will pave the way for a thriving witness in Louisiana and a renewed sense of mission.” (Added 6-6-2023)
“FAQ’s Regarding the Upcoming Vote” via Mt. Pisgah UMC. 6300 member church in Johns Creek, GA shared information about their June 7 disaffiliation vote. (Added 6-6-2023)
“Nearly half of Kentucky United Methodist congregations split from church” by Caleb Wieghant via Louisville Courier Journal. “More than 250 Kentucky congregations of the United Methodist Church have split from their parent denomination, effectively shrinking the sect’s size to just over half of what it was in the state.” (Added 6-6-2023)
“Peninsula-Delaware Conference Disaffiliation Resolutions” via conference. Over 100 churches up for vote. Website: “(any changes or updates to the 2023 Disaffiliation Resolutions will be listed below). 5/16/2023 – UPDATED R11, R15, & R16. 6/5/2023 – ADDED R17-R46, R49-R93, R96-R103. (Added 6-6-2023)
“172 UMC congregations in Ohio disaffiliate amid LGBT schism” by Anugrah Humar via Christian Post. “The Western Ohio Conference of the UMC, which oversees congregations mostly west and south of Columbus, voted to allow 172 out of approximately 960 congregations to disaffiliate at the 2023 West Ohio Annual Conference over the weekend.” (Added 6-6-2023)
“Both sides of West Ohio Methodist Church split say they’re optimistic” by Chris Welter via KVXU (NPR affiliate). Officially, the United Methodist Church doesn’t permit LGBTQ+ marriage or ordination but with the recent trend of disaffiliation across the country, [Bishop] Palmer said that might change at the next general conference (which includes all congregations from across the world) in 2024. (Added 6-6-2023)
“Historic church in downtown Oklahoma City has trouble leaving denomination” by Alyse Jones via KOCO News. “A 94-page petition by the First Church in downtown OKC detailed how they believe they’re being singled out by the conference in slowing their disaffiliation, but the conference claimed there are concerns about the church they want to look into.” (Added 6-6-2023)
“The Self-Deception of Self-Righteousness” by Greg Weeks via UM Insight. Quotes Richard Rohr: “When we idolize institutions and refuse to hold them fully accountable—I am going to dare to say the unsayable—they usually become demonic in some form.” (Added 6-6-2023)
Special Announcement to the Congregation by Jim Walker (Chair of Governance Board) via Church of the Servant (Oklahoma City) [PDF]. Rev. Randy Shrauner surrenders his UMC credentials and is hired as Executive Director of a large OKC church that narrowly failed the disaffiliation threshold (66.4% on 9/11/22). The church seeks another church conference for the purpose of disaffiliation and is prepared to litigate as necessary. Additional Context: The Church of the Servant disaffiliation vote was the first in the OK Conference last September. Concerns were immediately raised that DS Sam Powers opened the disaffiliation meeting with a strong speech against disaffiliation. He is said to have voiced criticism of WCA and to have mentioned the letter by African bishops. It is also said that he shamed the pastor for leading the church toward a disaffiliation vote. Dr. Matthew Mitchell, the church’s current senior minister, called for healing following the vote. On 5-5-2023, Bishop Nunn announced his intention to appoint Rev. Terry Koehn, current District Superintendent of the Green Country District, as the next Senior Pastor of church effective September 1, 2023. The conference announced a 7-1-2023 leave of absence for Matthew Mitchell on 5/31/23. (Added 6-6-2023)
“How Do Congregations Pay for Disaffiliation?” via Michigan Area WCA. “It has varied. Some have had investment funds that were set aside for a rainy day. Some have had fundraising campaigns. Some have had matching funds gifts. Others have taken out low interest loans and are planning on using the money saved from reduced ministry shares to pay down the loan.” (Added 6-5-2023)
“GCAH kicks off Pride Month with collection, initiatives” via Press Release. The General Commission on Archives and History celebrates Pride Month in spite of a denominational ban on church funds being used to promote the acceptance of homosexuality (Par. 806.9, 613.19). (Added 6-5-2023)
“Memorial Service for Estero United Methodist Church” by Estero Church via Vimeo. Pastor TIm Carson leads a memorial service to mark the disaffiliation of a Florida congregation that voted out by 95%: “Our 104-year-old church did a Memorial Service for Estero United Methodist Church on the last night before our disaffiliation became official on June 1. We were trying to give people a space to celebrate, grieve, and leave well so we could arrive wherever the Lord leads us next.” (Added 6-5-2023)
“Alabama-West Florida Conference – Corrections & More Details” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast (YouTube). “With every conference I report on, I get things wrong, or I don’t emphasize some of the details as I should. So I always get helpful follow-up and corrections from viewers & listeners. I got a lot of good stuff for this conference, so I knew I needed to issue a new episode. This segment has a few details about other conferences, but I mostly just read through corrections pertaining to AWF, which I think is actually pretty important as they are preparing to gather again to vote on things of consequence.” (Added 6-5-2023)
Overheard: All 286 Kentucky Conference churches presented for disaffiliation were approved on Sunday, June 4. (Added 6-5-2023)
“Beyond the Sunset: Why the UMC Can’t Disaffiliate from Disaffiliation” by Chris Ritter via PeopleNeedJesus.net. The sunset clause of Par. 2553 will not mark the end of the UMC exodus. (Added 6-5-2023)
Post by Jimmy Boone via Facebook. “After Tuesday we should be over 5,000 [disaffiliations]. (Added 6-5-2023)
“The Methodist Church is Beyond Woke” by The Indie Thinker (YouTube). One outside view into the UMC. (Added 6-5-2023)
“These 60 Michigan churches are disassociating from United Methodist Church” by Jakkar Aimery via The Detroit News. This version has no paywall. (Added 6-5-2023)
“North Ga Methodist meeting concludes at Classic Center” by Tim Bryant via WGAU. “We celebrate the judge’s decision, because a year ago and we know how that felt. We are very excited for them,” Mt. Bethel director of communications Andrea Black said. “No one who loves the church and Jesus wants to see that level of conflict,” Moore said.” (Added 6-5-2023)
“Letter from Bishop Sue Haupert Johnson” via PDF. “As churches have decided to disaffiliate, many are still trying to utilize the resources of the denomination that they chose to leave. This is not acceptable and the Virginia Conference will not be appointing pastors to these churches.” (Added 6-5-2023)
“Letter to the editor: June 3” by Craig Nichols via The Courier (Findlay, Ohio). “The twisting of the Trust Clause is not the fault of the individual congregations, but the failure of the individual bishops to provide John Wesley’s own guidance.” (Added 5-4-2023)
“Some Methodists look to new futures after disaffiliations; see brighter paths ahead” by Ken Stickney via The Acadiana Advocate (Louisiana). “The Rev. Steve Bell, senior pastor at First United Methodist Church in Shreveport, said his flock — one of the largest in Louisiana — voted April 16 to leave the UMC: 940 of those voting opted to leave, 166 voted to stay…. Bell said his church marked the end of the affiliation Wednesday night with prayers and communion at 11:30 p.m. As the bread was broken for communion, he said, the midnight hour struck. “It was beautiful,” he said.” (Added 5-4-2023)
“Marshalltown United Methodist churches split over theology, social issues” by Lana Bradstream via Times-Republican (Iowa). “One Marshalltown Methodist church has severed ties with the United Methodist Church denomination, and another has stayed. The decisions stem from fractured beliefs in theology and social issues within the denomination.” (Added 5-4-2023)
“Louisiana Conference Set to Gather for Annual Conference with Renewed Hope and Unity” via Louisiana Conference. “Although the decision to approve disaffiliation for nearly 40% of its churches has caused a reduction in size, the Louisiana Conference remains steadfast in its commitment to ministry and the strengthening of hope. Bishop Delores J. Williamston, set to preside over her first annual conference as a bishop in the United Methodist Church, expressed her excitement for the upcoming event and the prospect of reconnecting with fellow United Methodists.” (Added 6-4-2023)
“Amarillo United Methodist Church to be chartered as official UMC congregation” via Amarillo Globe News. “This comes about three months after United Methodists from around the Texas Panhandle gathered in The Craig searching for a place to worship after the majority of Methodist churches in the Amarillo area, and throughout the Texas Panhandle, voted to disaffiliate from the United Methodist denomination.” (Added 5-4-2023)
“Chattanooga’s lone breakaway Methodist church seeks to remain (mostly) the same” by Andrew Schwartz via Chattanooga Times Free Press [paywall]. “Lookout Valley’s Wauhatchie Methodist Church spent the past year mulling the prospect of leaving an institution which has grounded the spiritual identity of many families, like that of member Bill Clouse, for generations.” (Added 6-4-2023)
“Church split in Louisiana: Some staying, some leaving” via Rita LeBleu via American Press. “The split has been some time in coming. Grove said she felt the undercurrents of change as early as 2018. In 2020, differing opinions regarding church bans on same-sex marriage and LGBTQ clergy came to a head, and at that time the church announced a plan to split into two branches, traditionalist and progressive.” (Added 6-4-2023)
“‘Difficult Moment’: Learn which Michigan Congregations are Leaving the United Methodist Church” via Detroit News [paywall]. (Added 6-4-2023)
“Most United Methodists in Georgia plan to stay with the denomination” by Shelia Poole via Atlanta Journal-Constitution [paywall]. “The Rev. Sharon Coley grew up Southern Baptist but found her spiritual home among United Methodists. And that’s where the pastor of Pleasant Hill United Methodist Church-Summerville plans to stay ‘until I draw my last breath.'” (Added 6-4-2023)
“What’s Going On In The Alabama-West Florida Annual Conference?” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast (YouTube). “What makes this conference difference from the other annual conferences in the US, what controversies are happening in this area and how they are dealing with disaffiliating churches.” [Premieres at 10 am Central Time] (Added 6-3-2023)
“Vote due on Methodist split” by Dierdre Curren via SCNow.com. “Delegates to the annual S.C. Conference of the United Methodist Church will hold a vote this week that could let some churches separate.” (Added 6-3-2023)
“172 more Ohio UMC congregations disaffiliate in slow schism from church” by London Bishop via the Dayton Daily News. “American Methodists are undergoing a period of significant change, as the prominent Protestant denomination fractures along lines of progressive and traditional theology. Despite their disagreements, however, members of the now-two denominations wish each other well.” (Added 6-3-2023)
“United Methodist Church no longer ‘united’ as more churches will ‘disenfranchise’ over gay rights” by Jack Brammer via Northern Kentucky Tribune. “Disenfranchise”…the people who write the headlines are often not the same people who write the articles. The post is otherwise very detailed but does not mention the 286 churches seeking disaffiliation at the June 4 session. (Added 6-3-2023)
“United no more: Some Southern Illinois congregations have left the United Methodist Church” by Les O’Dell via The Southern Illinoisan. Highlights Marion Aldersgate and West Frankfort Trinity. (Added 6-3-2023)
More on the Travis Knoll incident via PDF. On the evening of May 31, an elder in the Baltimore-Washington Conference was escorted from the premises for distributing materials critical of the conference in a place he understood this was allowed. This document contains a letter he wrote to all conference members following the incident, the letter he was distributing, and the response by the conference communications director. (Added 6-3-2023)
“Greed is at heart of delays, First Church alleges in lawsuit against United Methodist Church” by Carla Hinton via The Oklahoman (PDF… no paywall). “The congregation also was granted a temporary restraining order Thursday to keep regional conference officials from locking church members out of their church building at 131 NW 4 and seizing more than $30 million in property and assets while matters are sorted out in the courts.” (Added 6-3-2023)
Tense Moments at Baltimore-Washington Conference via YouTube [50:00]. In a debate over postponing consideration of legislation calling for investigation into the loyalty of clergy, Rev. Melissa Rudolph, chair of the order of elders, mentioned a desire to do physical harm to Rev. Matt Sichel. Rev. Mark Gorman expressed his dismay in a point of order. Bishop Easterling corrected and later chastised Rev. Rudolph for lack of decorum and mention of physical harm. (Added 6-2-2023)
“UPDATE: Methodists allow 2 Georgia churches to leave denomination” by Shelia Poole via Atlanta Journal-Constitution. “The two churches, Trinity on the Hill United Methodist Church and Mann-Mize United Methodist Church, had earlier filed a lawsuit to restart the disaffiliation process after conference leadership halted the process last year. A Columbia County Superior Court judge ruled in favor of the Augusta churches.” (Added 6-2-2023)
“Interview with John Nadasi (Leaving The United Methodist Church)” by Jeffrey Rickman via PlainSpoken Podcast (YouTube). “John is a career clergy, most recently serving in the Mountain Sky Conference. He has severed his relationship with the UMC and is now GMC clergy. This conversation is sort of an exit interview. We do not bash the UMC, but we do talk about some of the structural realities. John even has kind acknowledgments for his former bishop and many of his colleagues in ministry.” (Added 6-2-2023)
“North Georgia Lifts Disaffiliation Pause” via UMNS. “The North Georgia Conference board of trustees announced June 2 that it has officially lifted the pause on churches going through the disaffiliation process. The decision follows two civil court rulings ordering the conference to allow churches that sued the conference leadership to vote on disaffiliation. The trustees’ announcement also applies to churches that have not been involved in litigation. Also on June 2, the conference approved the disaffiliations of two congregations in Augusta after a Columbia County Court judge ordered the conference to hold the disaffiliation votes. The annual conference declined to reconsider the disaffiliation of these two churches. The North Georgia Conference plans to hold a special session Nov. 18 to vote on disaffiliation requests. (Added 6-2-2023)
Overheard: The North Georgia Conference affirmed the “Queer Delegates’ Call to Center Justice and Empowerment for LGBTQIA+1 People in the UMC” 56%/44%. Point two (See here on Page 149-150) was struck prior to passage. (Added 6-2-2023)
Overheard: In an afternoon session of the North Georgia Conference, a motion to reconsider the morning’s vote to ratify disaffiliations was taken up. It failed: 45% yes / 55% no. One speaker against reconsidering said: “We are a connectional system… not a correctional system, which holds people against their will.” (Added 6-2-2023)
“First Church (OKC) Files Lawsuit to Separate from United Methodist Church” via Press Release (PDF). “The doors of First Church have been open to the people of Oklahoma City since 1889 — long before the UMC and its governing boards existed,” Patton says. “It would be a tragedy to allow greed to shutter our doors after we have continuously served Oklahomans for more than 130 years. We are an active and financially self-sufficient church that has always been dedicated to our community. Even though we voted to part ways with UMC, the purpose of our lawsuit is not to settle a spiritual dispute. This is simply a property dispute.” (Added 6-2-2023)
“What Every Iowa United Methodist Needs to Know” by John Lomperis via Juicy Ecumenism. “To her credit, Iowa Bishop Kennetha Bigham-Tsai has allowed a somewhat later deadline than other annual conferences, by having a disaffiliation-focused special session later this year. But on the other hand, she recently imposed heavy-handed new restrictions on freedom of discussion for moderate and conservative Iowa United Methodists still interested in disaffiliation.” (Added 6-2-2023)
“Of Borrowed Lawnmowers and United Methodist Clergy Status” by Bob Phillips via Good News. Good News picked up this article first appearing on PeopleNeedJesus.net. (Added 6-2-2023)
North Georgia Conference Livestream. via North GA Conference. (Added 6-2-2023)
Overheard: Despite opposition on the floor of the North Georgia AC to even hold a vote, in order to comply with a court order, Trinity on the Hill UMC and Mann-Mize UMC were granted a vote regarding their disaffiliation. Trinity on the Hill’s disaffiliation was ratified with a vote of: 55% yes / 45% no. Mann-Mize was ratified with a vote of: 56% yes / 44% no. (Added 6-2-2023)
Overheard: North Georgia lifts the pause for all churches, not just those involved in the lawsuit. (Added 6-2-2023)
Post by Jimmy Boone via Facebook. Updated disaffiliation totals from a clergy who tracks them: 4363 as of June 1. (Added 6-2-2023)
“N’West Iowa churches fracture, some stay: Part 1” by Aleisa Schat via nwestiowa.com. “It is not a new American story: Mainline Protestantism is in decline. Faith, in general, is in decline, and the numbers of the religiously unaffiliated continue to rise. Still, amid decline, and at odds with the dissent fracturing many denominations, there are small bursts of renewal — tiny signs of hope that, for the community of the faithful, point to a God still at work among a stumbling and wayward people.” (Added 6-2-2023)
“Local churches disassociate from United Methodist Conference” by Erin Rydgrin via Cherokee Chronicle Times. Iowa coverage. (Added 6-2-2023)
“UMC Baltimore-Washington Conference allows 23 churches to disaffiliate amid LGBT schism” by Michael Gryboski via Christian Post. “Rev. Kevin Baker, the senior pastor of Oakdale Church in Olney, Maryland, said that his church is responsible for paying nearly half of the $10.8 million aggregate total of the 23 churches. He pushed back against the bishop’s previous assertions that “racism” might be behind some of the desire to disaffiliate. Baker submitted a motion that the $10.8 million the conference receives in property payments should benefit African-American-majority churches.” (Added 6-2-2023)
“A Speech Against the Christmas Covenant” by Matt Sichel via The Baltimore-Washington Conference. At 3:21:08, a speech from the floor of the regular session draws connection between regionalization and jurisdictionalism. [The entire Thursday evening session is fascinating.](Added 6-2-2023)
“Arrivals to North Georgia Methodists’ Conference seek clarity” by Shelia Poole via Atlanta Journal-Constitution. Preview of the regular session of the North Georgia Conference. (Added 6-2-2023)
“Wisconsin Annual Conference Disaffiliation Update” via WI Conference (UMC). “When the Annual Conference gathers in Green Bay on June 9, there will be 43 requests from local churches to disaffiliate from The United Methodist Church and our annual conference. All the churches have met the deadlines and completed required steps of the Wisconsin Conference’s disaffiliation policy implementing The Book of Discipline ¶2553 up through making financial payments by May 26. [list included] (Added 6-2-2023)
“Kansas United Methodist Church congregations split with denomination over LGBTQ issues” by Holly Edgell via KCUR. An NPR article with a provocative lead quotes Bishop David Wilson: “We look at what the Bible says about human sexuality,” Wilson said. “I see us continuing to move to catch up with what’s happening in society.” See Nebraska coverage by same author. (Added 6-2-2023)
“Happy Birthday Global Methodist Church!” by Scott Field via Northern Illinois WCA. A telling of the GMC story thus far includes: “By the end of the year there are expected to be over 200 GMC congregations in the Great Lakes Annual Conference. Approval is expected from the Transitional Leadership Council (See? There’s that “transitional” word again) for the Great Lakes PAC to begin “officially” this summer.” (Added 6-2-2023)
Motion for a Temporary Restraining Order and Temporary Restraining Order granted to First UMC of Oklahoma City against the Oklahoma Conference. The evidentiary hearing is scheduled on July 7th for the motion for injunctive relief. (Added 6-2-2023)
First UMC in Oklahoma City Sues Conference for Exit via PDF. “…we believe that we are now left with no other options than to initiate a lawsuit, including a motion for a Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) against the conference that will allow us to seek to disaffiliate. By going this route, we acknowledge that there is a good possibility it will draw media attention to our church. As such we believe it is in our best interest to attempt to control the narrative by issuing a press release shortly after filing of the lawsuit and a motion for a TRO. We anticipate this to occur in the next few days.” See Church Discernment webpage and this news story. (Added 6-1-2023)
Overheard: The Baltimore-Washington Conference voted today to approve all 23 churches requesting and presented for disaffiliation. There are churches that did not meet the deadline and will not able to disaffiliate. (Added 6-1-2023)
Overheard: 172 church disaffiliations were ratified today by the West Ohio Conference, bringing the total number of WOC disaffiliations to 252. (Added 6-1-2023)
Post by Bruce Davis via Facebook. “…Are we not told that younger generations want us to liberalize?… Our Episcopalian neighbors liberalized years ago and their congregation is as devoid of young families as ours. It would seem that young adults/families in our town attend either the RC congregation or Four Square Assembly. I fear that liberalizing our stance on human sexuality will be applauded by secular folks who aren’t much interested in actually going to church, while further turning off a lot of actual church goers…” (6-1-2023)
Post by Justin Leonard Lee McCall via Facebook. “I have concerns about the future of the UMC if we do not move toward LGBTQ+ inclusion in the next GC. As of last year, about 71% of Americans supported same-sex marriages (the actual language is “marriages between same-sex couples should be recognized by law as valid”)…” (Added 6-1-2023)
Tweet by John Lomperis: Mormons practice baptism of the dead. Now, do #UnitedMethodist s practice ordination of the dead? The largest US #UMC Conference will perform a “posthumous ordination” tomorrow. Hmmm… https://mailchi.mp/ngumc/annual-conference-daily-update-wednesday-244184?e=c5d9c3e49e” (Added 6-1-2023)
“WI Conference Weekly E-News May 31, 2023” via Wisconsin Conference. A list of the 43 churches to be approved for disaffiliation on June 9. (Added 6-1-2023)
“Cape Girardeau Methodist church expected to change name, affiliation” by Jeff Long via The Southeast Missourian. “We will not have to reinvent the wheel by affiliating with Global Methodist, which has former U.M. Bishop Scott Jones in leadership,” said Kinder, who noted Jones on May 15 was at Dempster Hall on SEMO’s Cape Girardeau campus to speak with representatives of eight local congregations interested in joining GMC. “It seemed to most of us at that meeting with Jones that it made perfect sense to join this community of like-minded congregations,” Kinder said. (Added 6-1-2023)
“North Georgia Methodists to meet, disaffiliation not on agenda… so far” by Shelia Poole via Atlanta Journal-Constitution. Coverage of the regular session of the North Georgia Conference. (Added 6-1-2023)
“Methodists to Vote of Departure of 23 Churches Over LGBTQ+ Clergy, Marriages” by Jonathan Pitts via Baltimore Sun. Maryland Coverage. (Added 6-1-2023)
“More United Methodist churches leave denomination; North Alabama Conference looks forward” by Harry Butler via Gadsden Times. “The North Alabama Conference, which covers the upper half of the state from Montgomery to the Tennessee line and the Mississippi state line westward to the Georgia border, has lost more than half of its membership since December, with only 308 churches remaining on its roster.” (Added 6-1-2023)
“Southwest Virginia congregations join growing wave of disaffiliations from United Methodist Church over LGBTQ+ ministers and marriages” by Susan Cameron via Cardinal News. “I would say, ‘Imagine you’re married, and your spouse says, ‘I know we took all those vows together a few years back, but I’m not going to live by them anymore. Oh, and by the way, I’m not leaving the house and I’m not giving you a divorce. What would you do in that situation?’ (Added 6-1-2023)
“Rev. Dr. Robert Hayes Joins Global Methodist Church and is Designated Bishop Emeritus” by Walter Fenton via GMC. “At its May 22, 2023, weekly meeting, The Global Methodist Church’s Transitional Leadership Council (TLC) received the Rev. Dr. Robert Hayes, Jr. as a clergy member in the new denomination and then immediately voted to confer upon him the title bishop emeritus. Hayes joins Bishop Emeritus Mike Lowry as the only other bishop granted that status.” (Added 6-1-2023)
“Plant a Global Methodist Church” via The River Network. According to ¶350 of the Global Methodist Church’s Book of Discipline, “A new local church may be planted by any lay person or clergyperson of the Global Methodist Church with the consent of the bishop or presiding elder.” (Added 6-1-2023)
Post by Warren Lathem via Facebook. Thoughts on the upcoming session of the North Georgia Conference. (Added 5-31-2023)
“United Methodist Supplants Scripture with Critical Gender Theory” by Josiah Hasbrouck via Juicy Ecumenism. Reporting on a presentation by JJ Warren. (Added 6-1-2023)
See Also: March-May 2023, Nov 2022-Feb 2023, Aug-Oct 2022, May-July 2022, Jan-April 2022, 2021, 2020, 2019, or earlier.
People Need Jesus 
Comments are closed.